Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:45:29.022Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Statistical signatures of $u$ component wall-attached eddies in proper orthogonal decomposition modes of a turbulent boundary layer

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 June 2022

Longwei Wang
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Chong Pan*
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR ChinaAircraft and Propulsion Laboratory, Ningbo Institute of Technology, Beihang University, Ningbo 315800, PR China
Jinjun Wang
Affiliation:
Fluid Mechanics Key Laboratory of Education Ministry, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, PR China
Qi Gao
Affiliation:
School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: panchong@buaa.edu.cn

Abstract

Physical representation of coherent motions in wall-bounded turbulence satisfying Townsend's attached-eddy hypothesis (AEH) is still an open question to be debated. Here, we apply proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) to instantaneous snapshots of $u$ component velocity fields in the streamwise–wall-normal plane of three turbulent boundary layers, which cover a frictional Reynolds number ($Re$) of $Re_\tau \approx 1000{\sim} 4000$ and were either measured by large-field-of-view planar particle image velocimetry or calculated by direct numerical simulation. The $u$ component POD modes characterized by streamwise recurring large-scale motions are decomposed into wall-attached and wall-detached parts depending on the wall-attachment condition. The former, i.e. wall-attached POD eddies, are believed to be the prime statistical representations of attached eddies. The reason lies in three aspects. Firstly, wall-attached POD eddies are geometrically self-similar and statistically independent. Secondly, the wall-normal variation of the variance of reduced-order streamwise velocity components $\tilde {u}_{AE}$, which is only contributed by wall-attached POD eddies, presents logarithmic decay in the inertial flow region. Thirdly, analysis on the scaling behaviour of the high-even-order moment, moment generating function, as well as longitudinal two-point structure function, all indicate a quasi-Gaussian behaviour of $\tilde {u}_{AE}$. None of these AEH-predicted behaviours are evident when the contribution of superstructure-like POD eddies are considered. Furthermore, wall-detached POD eddies are found to also present quasi-Gaussian behaviour. They might be treated as passive fragments of wall-attached ones.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Characteristic parameters of all three TBLs studied here. The characteristic boundary layer thickness $\delta$ takes the value at the middle $x$ station of the FOV.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Wall-normal variation of single-point turbulent statistics in TBLs of all three datasets at the middle $x$ station of the FOV. (a) Inner-scaled mean streamwise velocity vs inner-scaled $y$. The constants of the logarithmic law that is indicated by the green bold line are $\kappa =0.384$ and $B=4.17$ (Chauhan, Monkewitz & Nagib 2009). (b) Inner-scaled Reynolds stress vs outer-scaled $y$. In (b), vertical dashed lines in black, red and blue indicate the lower bound of mean-flow log layer in Cases DNS, WC and WT, respectively, while the vertical dash-dotted line in green indicates the upper bound, the same as in figures 8–10, 13, 19 and 21. The $y$ range of the mean-flow log layer is $3\sqrt {Re_{\tau }}< y^{+}<0.15 \delta ^{+}$ (Marusic et al.2013).

Figure 2

Figure 2.Pre-multiplied streamwise 1-D spectra or co-spectra; (a) $k_x\varPhi _{uu}(\lambda _x, y)$, (b) $k_x\varPhi _{vv}(\lambda _x, y)$ and (c) $k_x\varPhi _{uv}(\lambda _x, y)$. Case DNS, Case WC and Case WT are denoted by grey scale patches, dashed contours in red and solid contours in blue, respectively. The spectra are normalized by their maximum value beyond $y^{+}=40$, and the iso-contours are plotted at the level of 0.15 : 0.15 : 1.2. The magenta dash-doted and black solid triangles in (a) indicate the spectral triangle of (4.4) (proposed by Baars et al.2017) and (4.5) (proposed by Hu et al.2020) in Case WT, respectively. It is noted that the streamwise spectra were calculated from $u(x)$ or $v(x)$ over the whole $x$ span of the FOV, the same as in figure 11, 12, 20 and 22.

Figure 3

Figure 3.An example of extracting different components from a snapshot of the instantaneous streamwise fluctuating velocity. (a) The original $u(x, y)$ in Case WC. Regions highlighted by dashed ellipses or dotted contours denote large-scale coherent motions with quasi-streamwise periodicity or wall-detached clusters, respectively. (b) Dominant spatial Fourier modes of the snapshot in (a). (c–e) Reduced-order velocity field $\tilde {u}_{SU}$, $\tilde {u}_{AE}$ and $\tilde {u}_{DE}$ contributed by superstructure-like POD eddies, wall-attached POD eddies and wall-detached POD eddies, respectively. Horizontal dashed lines in each panel represent the upper bound of the mean-flow log layer.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Spatial eigenmodes $\varPsi ^{u \mid v}_i$ of the first 13 POD modes in Case WC and Case DNS. The left or right column indicate the $u$ or $v$ component, and the results of Case WC and Case DNS are shown as pseudo-colour map and coloured contours, respectively.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Pre-multiplied streamwise spectrogram $k_x\varPhi _{\varPsi _i \varPsi _i}(\lambda _x, y)$ of the $i$th eigenmode $\varPsi ^{u \mid v}_i$ of Case DNS; (a) $i=6$, (b) $i=14$, (c) $i=24$. Red pentagram in each panel indicates the dominant spectral peak.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Energy and scale characteristics of POD modes of all three datasets. (a) The TKE contents $e_i^{\ast }$ and the cumulative TKE portions $\varSigma _1^{i} e_i^{\ast }$ of the first 100 modes. (b) The outer-scaled dominant streamwise wavelength $\lambda _{x, i}^{peak}$ with respect to the TKE contents $e_i^{\ast }$ of POD modes. Solid symbols in (b) denote superstructure-like POD eddies. Dashed and dash-dotted lines in (b) highlight the main branch of the scale–energy curve, which has the largest $e_i^{\ast }$ given a fixed $\lambda _{x, i}^{peak}$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Illustration of the procedure of decomposing the eigenmode $\varPsi _{i}$ into wall-attached and wall-detached POD eddies. (a–c) Show the original $u$ component $\varPsi _{i}$, wall-attached part $\varPsi ^{{AE}}_{i}$ and wall-detached part $\varPsi ^{{DE}}_{i}$ of the $24$th POD mode in Case DNS, respectively. Contour lines denote the level of $\alpha \varPsi _i^{max}$ or $\alpha \varPsi _i^{min}$ with $\alpha =0.2$. The inset in (b) defines the height $H$, the area $S$ and the lowest position $y_{bm}$ of one single POD eddy.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Wall-normal profiles of the streamwise TKE contributed by (a) superstructure-like POD eddies, (b) wall-detached POD eddies and (c) small-scale motions. Vertical dashed lines or dash-dotted lines indicate the lower or the upper bound of the mean-flow log layer in the same sense as those shown in figure 1(b).

Figure 9

Figure 9.Wall-normal profiles of the streamwise TKE contributed by (a) wall-attached POD eddies and (b) wall-attached POD eddies together with superstructure-like POD eddies. Vertical dashed lines or dash-dotted lines indicate the lower or the upper bound of the mean-flow log layer in the same sense as those shown in figure 1(b). Insets in (a) and (b) respectively plot the logarithmic indicator functions $\varXi _{AE}$ and $\varXi _{SA}$ defined in (4.3), the horizontal grey patches indicate the Townsend–Perry constant of $A^{AE}_1=1.56\pm 0.10$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Wall-normal profiles of the streamwise TKE contributed by wall-attached POD eddies in all $j$ POD modes with $j\ge i$, i.e. $\varSigma ^{\infty }_i \langle \tilde {u}^{2+}_{{AE}, i} \rangle$. (a) Case DNS and WC; (b) Case DNS and WT. Vertical dashed lines or dash-dotted lines indicate the lower or the upper bound of the mean-flow log layer in the same sense as those shown in figure 1(b).

Figure 11

Figure 11.Pre-multiplied streamwise spectra of $\tilde {u}$ contributed by (a) wall-attached POD eddies, (b) wall-detached POD eddies and (c) both of them. Here, $y_t^{+}=60$. Grey scale patches with thin solid contours in black denote results of Case DNS and bold dash-dotted contours in red correspond to Case WC. The spectra are normalized by their maximum value beyond $y^{+}=40$. The iso-contours are plotted at the level of 0.15 : 0.15 : 1.2. The magenta dash-doted and black solid triangles indicate the spectral triangle of (4.4) and (4.5), respectively.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Pre-multiplied streamwise spectra of $\tilde {u}$ contributed by (a) wall-attached POD eddies, (b) wall-detached POD eddies and (c) both of them in Case WT. Here, $y_t^{+}=60$. The format is the same as that in figure 11.

Figure 13

Figure 13.High-even-order moments of (a) $u$, (b) $\tilde {u}_{AE}$ and (c) $\tilde {u}_{SA}$ as a function of $y/\delta$. Vertical dashed lines or dash-dotted lines indicate the lower or the upper bound of the mean-flow log layer in the same sense as those shown in figure 1(b).

Figure 14

Figure 14.The log–linear slopes $A^{AE}_p$ of the logarithmic part of $\langle \tilde {u}_{AE}^{2p}\rangle ^{1/p}(y)$. The error bars are the standard deviation of $A^{AE}_p$ when changing the fitting region in the mean-flow log layer. The results of Meneveau & Marusic (2013) and Cheng et al. (2020) are plotted as hollow symbols for reference.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Wall-normal variation of MGF of (a) $u$ and (b) $\tilde {u}_{AE}$ in Case WT for $q=\pm 0.45,q=\pm 0.9,q=\pm 1.35,q=\pm 1.8$. Grey patches indicate the flow region with a power-law scaling, i.e. $500< y^{+}<0.2\delta ^{+}$ in (a) and $3\sqrt {Re_{\tau }}< y^{+}<0.15\delta ^{+}$ in (b). Dash-dotted lines in black represent the linear fit of the power-law scaling in log–log plot.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Power-law exponents $\tau (q)$ of MGF of (a) $u$ and (b) $\tilde {u}_{AE}$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Log–log plots of the $n$th-order SFs as a function of (a) $r_x/\delta$ and (b) the third-order SFs at the wall-normal position of $y/\delta = 0.05$. Only results of Case WT are presented for brevity. Hollow and solid markers denote SFs of $u$ and $\tilde {u}_{AE}$, respectively. The grey patch in (a) indicates the valid inertial subrange for a power-law scaling of $\langle {\rm \Delta} u^{|n|}\rangle \propto r_x$, which is illustrated by a blue solid line for the $3^{rd}$ SFs. In (b), solid lines and dash-dotted lines in black indicate the ESS power-law fit of SFs of $u$ and $\tilde {u}_{AE}$, respectively. The fitting range is the valid inertial subrange shown in (a).

Figure 18

Figure 18.The scaling exponent $\zeta _n^{\chi }$ of the longitudinal SFs of (a) $u$, (b) $\tilde {u}_{SU}$, (c) $\tilde {u}_{AE}$, (d) $\tilde {u}_{DE}$ and (e) $\tilde {u}_{AD}$. Results of different datasets are vertically shifted for clarity. The black dash-doted lines and the red-dashed lines indicate the predictions by the SL model and the K41 model, respectively.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Effect of the FOV size and the number of snapshots on (a) the streamwise TKE profiles contributed by wall-attached POD eddies in all $j$ POD modes with $j\ge i$ and (b) the streamwise high-even-order moments contributed by all of the wall-attached POD eddies.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Effect of the FOV size and the number of snapshots on the pre-multiplied streamwise velocity spectra of (a) $\tilde {u}_{AE}$, (b) $\tilde {u}_{DE}$ and (c) $\tilde {u}_{AD}$. The spectra are normalized by their maximum value beyond $y^{+}=40$. The iso-contours are plotted at the level of 0.15 : 0.15 : 1.2.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Effect of the wall-attachment condition on (a) the wall-normal profiles of the streamwise TKE contributed by wall-attached and wall-detached POD eddies and (b) the power-law exponent $\tau (q)$ of MGF of $\tilde {u}_{AE}$ in Case DNS. Inset in (a) plots the logarithmic indicator function $\varXi _{AE}$ defined in (4.3), the horizontal grey patches indicate the Townsend–Perry constant of $A^{AE}_1=1.05\pm 0.04$ and $A^{AE}_1=1.56\pm 0.10$, respectively.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Pre-multiplied streamwise spectra of $\tilde {u}$ contributed by (a) wall-attached POD eddies, (b) wall-detached POD eddies and (c) both for Case DNS. Here, $y_t^{+}=15$. The format is the same as that in figure 11.