This monograph represents a solid addition to the expanding library of literature on the history of race and racial science. It carefully examines the interrelationships in Britain between science, policy and research over a period that somewhat overlaps that given in the title, stretching as it does from the mid-1920s and reaching into the 1970s with the publication of J.R. Baker's book Race in 1974. Essentially, the author aims to ‘question the social impact of expert thinking on race as well as exploring in detail the political influences which may have impacted on racial science’ (p. 4). The heart of the argument will be extremely familiar to readers of BJHS, resting as it does on the assertion that neither science nor society can be adequately understood in the other's absence, and focusing on the need to place the development of scientific research in the context of constantly evolving public policy and vice versa. The author clearly and consistently demonstrates the benefit of adopting such an approach, and as such it is a very useful exemplar of the important contribution that the science-studies approach can make to the writing of history more generally.
Despite the book's methodological strengths, the nature of its content means that it will remain on lists of secondary literature for both academics and their students. Little that is new is revealed within these pages – which is perfectly understandable, since it seems to be aimed squarely at the senior undergraduate level. Having presented the relationship between science and race as a three-step process involving a broad shift from ‘race’ as a unproblematic synonym for ‘variety’ or ‘species’, first to ‘race’ as a relatively permanent and politically loaded category, and then to a conceptualization of human difference in which the notion of ‘race’ is (at least notionally) absent, the author aims to concentrate on the latter stages of this development. The main body of the book is divided into three substantive chapters covering the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s/1960s: each delineates the major developments of the decade(s), and illustrates them by reference to case studies of significant research projects. However, this process is most useful and most detailed in relation to the 1930s and 1940s, and becomes less revealing – and less useful for the history of science – as we move closer to the present day.
Two elements in particular would have repaid the author's closer attention, and enabled the book to develop a much wider significance – especially in the context of the shift away from biology and towards sociology as the disciplinary locus of race-based research. The first is the UNESCO statement on race and the context of its production (the absence of biologists from the initial panel of experts, the dissent surrounding its revisions). The second is the eventual publication of John Baker's Race by Oxford University Press. Although this happened a dozen years after the period with which this book is most concerned, since it was in production and (to a limited extent) in circulation to presses and individuals during the earlier period it is perhaps legitimate to regret that it did not receive a closer examination. Both of these elements deal directly with the efforts of biologists to reclaim, and to retain a greater degree of authority over, the scientific study of race within institutions and within the public eye, but both are dealt with descriptively rather than analytically, and too briefly. Space constraints are always an issue, but (for example) the detailed account of segregationism in the USA could have been lost in favour of sustained attention to the specifically British context.
As indicated above, this monograph undoubtedly fills a useful niche within the secondary literature on science and race. The footnotes are detailed and rich, and the bibliography is comprehensive and meticulous. Finally, it should also be noted that throughout the author is also concerned to situate his account of racial science within the framework of science in public, and, as such, it could also be a useful addition to undergraduate courses on this latter topic.
