Assessing the impact of the 1988 Federal Constitution – the so-called ‘Citizen's Constitution’ – 20 years after its promulgation, several analysts have recently argued that one of the main changes it promoted in Brazil's legal-political order was the original treatment given to the Ministerio Publico (MP), this rather unique Brazilian institution that is basically in charge of promoting, defending and expanding the public sphere in the country. Following more than 20 years of military rule, the 1988 Constitution was expected to restore and strengthen democracy, especially by establishing the bases of a solid public legal-political order broader than the traditional state order typical of representative democracy. The very first article of the 1988 Constitution determines a combination of representative and participatory democracy, thus widening the notion of the public sphere. A crucial agent in this process has been the MP: whereas prior to 1988 this institution was part of executive power both at the federal and at the state governmental levels, with its action largely restricted to criminal prosecution and the legal protection of vulnerable groups such as children, with the promulgation of the 1988 Constitution it became an independent institution, the political nature and legal scope of which are still being discussed. Given their exclusion from the traditional political process, Brazilians initially avidly embraced the renewed MP, which has since then become a leading defender of all sorts of public interests, often against the state apparatus.
Another significant constitutional development was the approval of a series of collective rights, including a special chapter on environmental preservation, thus fully recognising the claims conveyed in a popular amendment that had been submitted by thousands of social organisations. This constitutional chapter consolidated a significant environmental lawmaking process that had been taking place since the 1980s, aiming to materialise the long-standing, but still largely rhetorical, constitutional notion of the social function of property. An important step in the process had been the enactment, in 1985, of the pioneering ‘civil public action law’ which, recognising the existence of a ‘diffuse interest’ to preserve the environment, conferred locus standi to individuals, social movements and NGOs, as well as to the MP, to promote public litigation against both private and public agents who violate the wide range of environmental laws in force. Since then, the MP has been very active in Brazil in all sorts of environmental matters, promoting public litigation against both private and state agents, either by taking the initiative or by responding to provocation from individuals, social groups and NGOs.
Lesley K. McAllister's important book explores this original Brazilian institution, rightly emphasising its significance in the Brazilian case and its potential relevance for other countries, particularly regarding the imperative need to enforce fully the more progressive legislation that has been approved as a result of growing social mobilisation. The book presents and discusses the nature and action of the MP in a detailed and critical manner, including many of its shortcomings – organisational deficiencies, lack of resources, etc. – as well as the serious procedural difficulties it has had to overcome given the constraints of the obsolete judicial system still prevailing in the country. The author shows a good understanding of the intricacies of the complex Brazilian legal order – not an easy task – and fully explores the rich findings from her fieldwork in São Paulo and in Pará.
So much has happened in Brazil since the author's research in 2001–02 that future research on the role of the MP should perhaps embrace an even more critical approach. At least four additional dimensions should be stressed. First, together with its prosecutorial role, the MP has had a pivotal role promoting extrajudicial conflict resolution in environmental matters, particularly through the so-called ‘terms for behaviour adjustment’ involving several stakeholders. Given the range of problems affecting Brazil's judicial system, this is perhaps a more pragmatic way of achieving possible solutions to existing environmental problems. Second, the MP has played an increasingly significant lobbying role in the lawmaking process, a good example being the ongoing discussion of the draft federal law on land subdivision in urban areas. Third, it would be important to discuss the extent to which the MP still has the unquestioned socio-political legitimacy it certainly had following the promulgation of the 1988 Constitution. Indeed, there have been many layers of criticisms of the action of the MP, not only from the expected quarters – for example, politicians, public managers and/or judges whose actions have been targeted by the MP – but also from progressive political forces. Several high-profile cases have been jeopardised by the less than competent or rushed actions of prosecutors, often young and ill-prepared, some of whom have perhaps been motivated by an excessive attraction to the public limelight when not involved in thinly disguised politically motivated litigation. Brazilians have been gradually asking who controls the MP, as well as whether it is enough to have a law degree and pass a public selection process in order to become a defender of the public interest and a champion of collective rights on behalf of society as a whole. Finally, a fourth dimension would be a critical discussion of the role played by the MP in the dissemination throughout the country of a rather damning false conflict between environmental preservation and housing rights. Generally speaking, the MP has been much closer to what can be called a ‘middle-class sensibility’ and its action has expressed a certain anti-urban bias, often using environmental arguments to oppose the recognition of other social rights approved by the 1988 Constitution, particularly those recognising the rights of the enormous contingent of Brazilians who have long lived informally in cities, often in environmentally sensitive areas.
That said, this is a highly commendable book that deserves to be widely read not only by environmentalists and/or legal professionals, but also by all those interested in discussing the necessary conditions for the consolidation of a solid public sphere in Brazil and in many other countries that are undergoing a process of political democratisation.
