No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
This thoughtful exploration of various aspects pertinent to intercultural contact presents itself as a blend of autobiography and ethnography. Caesar's portrait of the United Arab Emirates is a close reading of one particular Middle Eastern context and succeeds in highlighting its complexity and distinctness. Before accepting a teaching position at the American University of Sharjah, Caesar had lived for six years in Egypt and Saudi Arabia and also traveled in China and Japan; by the time she began her stay in Sharjah, she was a seasoned traveler who was familiar with the stages of enthusiasm and alienation felt by anyone who spends a relatively long period in an unfamiliar cultural setting. Drawing on these prior experiences, her study of Emirati society becomes a springboard to reflect on questions related to intercultural contact. In addition, Caesar meditates on the views Americans hold of themselves and those that others hold of them.
The book is highly didactic in that Caesar takes the reader through a learning process by describing the different stages of entering a previously unknown cultural setting and acknowledging fears and preconceived notions to demonstrate how Emirati society can be explored in meaningful ways by gradually abandoning prejudiced attitudes.
The study is divided into four sections; the first two focus on describing Emirati “places” and “people,” and the last two sections are designed mainly to reflect more directly on the nature of intercultural contact, on the “multilayeredness” of cultures, and, in the last section, the necessity and practice of teaching multiculturalism.
The dominant theme that emerges in Caesar's discussion of the Emirati locale is complexity, even contradiction, particularly when it comes to the coexistence of the modern and the traditional, the West and the East, all of which is visible in the architecture, the infrastructure, and the composition of the population. Meticulously constructed heritage villages contrast with often extraordinary examples of modern architecture and with areas of pristine natural and inhabited places. Observing these diverse modes of living raises questions about authenticity and about the relationship between past and present expressions of cultural belonging and self-definition.
Caesar highlights the range of ethnic groups who live in the Emirates, where foreign-born individuals outnumber local Emiratis and all groups combined make up a multicultural society. Whereas Emirati society is distinguished by a high degree of compartmentalization when it comes to housing and private life, other public areas of the society, such as shopping malls, are portrayed as more cosmopolitan than any area in the United States. Cultural, social, and religious differences are visible especially in the wide range of accepted dress codes, which indicate a great deal of tolerance for diverse identities. Pressing issues, such as the role of immigrant workers in raising Emirati children or the career prospects of female students, are discussed in informative and sensible ways. Caesar convincingly describes cultural complexity when she observes that “those students who adopted American clothing styles and body language were among the most adamant in condemning the ‘decadence’ of Western society, or what they thought was Western society” (p. 70). The section on Mohammad al-Murr's novels is persuasive (and, once more, very pedagogical) in that it allows the reader to think through the various stages of engaging with literature from a culture he or she knows little about.
Caesar's reflection on the multilayeredness of cultural systems dominates the third section of the study and leads her to discuss the ways in which Americans' understanding of themselves at times clashes with the views others hold of the United States. The question of when a particular aspect of a culture is to be taken as representative or as exceptional is central here; in addition, the author emphasizes the difficulty of stepping outside the norms and belief systems of one's own culture to be able to perceive its internal contradictions. As Caesar writes: “from Sharjah … I saw a different America than I would have seen if I had stayed at home” (p. 150). On the last few pages of the book, Caesar argues strongly for the significance of teaching about multiculturalism, with all its inherent ambiguities and tensions. This credo amounts to the central thesis of the book.
The study is written for an audience curious about traveling and the Middle East, in particular an audience not familiar with or interested in academic explorations of the topics touched on here. Caesar offers historical information when relevant, for example, about political movements or the economic relevance of specific places. But the reader will find no footnotes, index, or bibliography. The insights and the factual information shared here are based on scholarly knowledge and on years of first-hand experience of the subject that is at the center of the account. Even without the scholarly apparatus, Caesar's book is no less sophisticated than other, more scientific studies. The readable style of the exploration will make the book appealing to a large audience, and its level of analysis is clearly superior to some presently popular titles. This inspiring study is also an ideal read for undergraduate courses on issues of multiculturalism and intercultural contact.