This multifaceted work will interest several audiences. Beyond a special appeal for scholars of the European Parliament (EP) and of electoral systems, it speaks also to theorists of representative democracy, analysts of legislative behavior, and electoral system designers. The authors move from theory to analysis of an array of evidence to policy prescription. They are well grounded in the literature, already having contributed significantly to the study of electoral systems, and to work on EP members (MEPs).
Farrell and Scully open their study with the stark observation that the EP “has been a failure as a representative body” (2). Their principal reason for this judgment is that “The manner that Europe's Parliament is elected in many member states is actively obstructive of Europe's voters being represented in the way that those voters are most likely to respond positively towards” (2–3). The EP has gained power, but not the enhanced legitimacy hoped for when direct elections were introduced in 1979.
The authors employ a rich variety of data sources including the familiar Eurobarometer surveys of citizens of EU member states, mail questionnaire surveys of MEPs done in 1996, 2000 and 2006, and face-to-face interviews with most British MEPS between 2001 and 2003. Scully or Farrell or both were principal investigators of the 2000 and 2006 MEP surveys and conducted the British interviews.
Chapter 2 provides an overview of recent trends in public views of the EP, which include growing skepticism, declining trust, and little constituent contact with MEPs. Chapter 3 surveys the existing literature on the connections between electoral system characteristics and the process of representation. Although a considerable literature exists on the links between electoral systems and descriptive representation (the traits of members of parliaments), much less is known about the impact of electoral systems on styles of representation. Scully and Farrell thus chose to study the connection between the mostly proportional systems used to elect the EP since 1979 and the representative behavior of MEPs, while also taking account of national and individual differences.
They move toward their objective (Chapter 4) with an informative discussion of the evolution of the EP's electoral systems toward the EU's stated goal of having uniform electoral procedures. As of the 2004 EP election, all member states were using either proportional representation (PR) or single transferable vote (STV) systems. Over time the EP has become more representative of Europe's population with more parties and many more women MEPs. But the authors demonstrate that potentially important differences remain, such as the degree to which lists are closed or open, electoral formulas, and district magnitude. Farrell and Scully maintain that the most important remaining difference is between the systems that provide for some form of regional representation and those that do not. They assert that regional representation should be encouraged in the EP in order to counter the national perspectives of the Council of Ministers.
The focus shifts in Chapter 5 to MEPs' opinions, particularly their views of (1) the representative role of the EP as an institution and (2) the role of the individual MEP as representative. Not surprisingly, the 2006 survey of MEPs reveals that most want a greater policy role for the EP. Analysis of how MEPS see their individual roles finds that in the aggregate they believe they should be representing a variety of groups with party, nation, and constituency/region earning the highest scores. The MEPs also reported that working on legislation was their most important task followed by articulating societal interests; representing individual citizens' interests ranked much lower. Multivariate models employing individual traits, ideology, nation, and electoral system as independent variables are used to further analyze the MEPs' responses to questions about how they see their work. The models yielded findings rarely very potent, but electoral system variables were significant in several instances.
The authors then pursue the electoral system connection thread (Chapter 6), asking whether there is an observable link between the institutions under which MEPs are elected and how they seek to represent their electors. Indicators of geographic representation are used with other MEP survey data to test propositions about electoral system effects. For example, MEPs elected under more “open” ballot structures (STV and open list systems) have greater incentives to cultivate personal as opposed to party votes. The results demonstrate modest but fairly numerous electoral system effects, most in the hypothesized direction, such as the observation that more open ballot structures are positively associated with MEP geographic representation activities. The analysis also shows that British MEPs have been distinctive in their commitment to geographic representation. The authors explore this in Chapters 7 and 8, taking advantage of the natural experiment provided by Britain's change of its EP election system.
Since 1999 British MEPs have been chosen via closed list PR. But MEP survey data indicate that they exhibit a high level of constituency focus. The authors ask whether this behavior is due to a distinctive British political culture or the continuation of habits developed from the long tradition of SMP electoral systems, including the first four EP elections. If the latter, they expect to see change in British MEP behavior away from geographic representation. They draw extensively upon their interviews with British MEPs. They find that the change in electoral systems affected descriptive representation in the British delegation, such as more political parties, more women, and more minority MEPs. Most British MEPs believe that their role has changed and that the new electoral system is the reason. Farrell and Scully also find that MEP behavior is adapting to the incentives of the new electoral system. The focus on geographic constituency representation is diminishing and new MEPs are more oriented to functional representation.
In conclusion, Farrell and Scully recommend that all EU members adopt open list PR systems with provision for regional representation in countries larger than the Netherlands. This would help address an apparent paradox of the EP's current PR system: better descriptive representation but thinner ties to individual electors and communities. The current Finnish and Italian MEP electoral systems meet the authors' criteria. Recent Eurobarometers find Finns relatively well informed about the EP, and Italians voting at higher rates in EP elections. However, to this reviewer's eyes, the general picture is that Italians and Finns are not notably more positive about the EP than other Europeans. Perhaps case studies of the representative behavior of Finnish and Italian MEPs would provide additional evidence to support the recommendation.
Overall, this book offers a compelling model of how to analyze the connections between the traits of electoral systems and the behavior of representatives. The authors know that electoral systems are but one influence on representation, but the techniques, tools, and insights they employ could and should be applied by scholars to the electoral system–representation connections of other legislatures. The many fairly new mixed member proportional systems would be interesting candidates.
The authors' stated goals for this book were to contribute to the understanding of the politics of the EU and to the understanding of the politics of electoral systems. They have been achieved admirably.
