Sex selection technologies have become increasingly prevalent and accessible. We can find them advertised widely across the Internet and discussed in the popular media—an entry for “sex selection services” on Google generated 859,000 sites in April 2004. The available services fall into three main types: (1) preconception sperm sorting followed either by intrauterine insemination of selected sperm (IUI) or by in vitro fertilization (IVF); (2) preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD), by which embryos created by IVF are tested and only those of the desired sex are transferred to the woman's uterus; and (3) prenatal testing of fetuses through ultrasound or chromosomal analysis, followed by selective abortion of fetuses detected to be of the undesired sex.1
Infanticide is also a form of sex selection that is practiced throughout the world in areas where ultrasounds to determine fetal sex are not accessible.
Our aim in this paper is twofold: (1) to explore the problematic relationship between what is advertised (gender selection) and what is really being offered (sex selection via chromosome selection), and (2) to explore the moral responsibilities of fertility experts who promote and entrench false and troubling expectations about the connections between biological (chromosomal) status and the social category of gender through their participation in ambiguously described “sex selection” practices. We will discuss some of the problems that emerge from the conflation of biological categories of sex with social categories of gender in the context of these reproductive services, paying particular attention to the ways in which medicalized approaches to gender in sex selection obscure the reality of such phenomena as intersexuality, transsexuality, and homosexuality and, more generally, perpetuate harmful stereotypes that attach to traditional conceptualizations of gender. Consequently, we will argue that sex selection practices are so potentially harmful to the social interest that their prohibition by governments is warranted and even morally required.
To get a flavor of the marketplace, consider the following assortment of quotes from ads chosen at random from the Internet:
Research and work carried out in the 1980's and 90's have finally provided methods offering the chance of obtaining a desired pregnancy gender outcome that ranges from excellent to virtually GUARANTEED. —The Fertility Institutes; Los Angeles, Las Vegas, and Mexico.
The PGD process does not involve any “engineering” or “manipulation”—it merely reveals the already determined gender status of the embryo. Compared to other sex selection methods, PGD offers an extremely high accuracy rate. Couples can now be almost certain that their child will be the gender they request. —Sydney IVF; Sydney, Australia.
PGD is also used in non-medically related gender selection. In contrast to other available gender selection techniques, which are largely based on sperm sorting (X- vs. Y-carrying sperm), PGD is virtually always accurate. —Centre for Human Reproduction, 4 centres in Illinois, 2 in New York.
The Genetics and IVF Institute (GIVF) advertises an “exclusive scientifically-based sperm sorting gender selection procedure [MicroSort].” —Laguna Hills, California.
The Midwest Fertility and Sex Selection Center offers sex selection using the more traditional Ericsson method of sperm sorting and advertises from the website: www.selectagender.com.
In resistance to this growing pressure to legitimize and market reproductive services aimed solely at facilitating parental choice over the sex of their offspring, some nations have introduced legislation that restricts provisions of such services. For example, Canada recently passed an Assisted Human Reproduction Act that prohibits or regulates several types of reproductive and genetic technologies that most Canadians find disturbing. Notable for our discussion here is the section on prohibited activities. In particular, Section 5(1)(e) of the Act states:
No person shall knowingly for the purpose of creating a human being, perform any procedure or provide, prescribe or administer anything that would ensure or increase the probability that an embryo will be of a particular sex, or that would identify the sex of an in vitro embryo, except to prevent, diagnose or treat a sex-linked disorder or disease.
Because state regulation is the only effective way to restrict individual preferences when such a restriction is in the social interest, we argue that such legislative restrictions are an appropriate response to the growing marketplace in sex selection technologies and we encourage other nations to adopt similar policies.2
We have some reservations about the exception made for sex-linked disease because we do not share the common view that prenatal testing and selective abortion on the basis of disease or disability is unproblematic, but we will not enter into that debate here.
To be clear about the practices we are criticizing, here is a brief review of the actual services available. Depending on the techniques that are used, sperm sorting can be the simplest, least invasive, and, therefore, least expensive option. This procedure involves the provision of sperm (collected through male masturbation), which is then subjected to mechanical, chemical, or light-based techniques to separate sperm according to whether they carry X or Y chromosomes. Once the sperm are sorted, a pregnancy can be sought in a variety of different ways. The least medicalized method is for the sperm of the desired sex to be delivered to the partner's vagina through intrauterine insemination (IUI), where drugs may be used to induce ovulation. If this procedure is unsuccessful (or looks unfavorable), in vitro fertilization (IVF), possibly including intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), may be used. IVF involves artificial stimulation of the woman's ovaries, careful monitoring, surgical removal of the eggs, and fertilization of the eggs in vitro; in cases of a low sperm count or sperm of poor quality, ICSI may be used for fertilization purposes. Fertilized embryos are then transferred back to the womb or frozen for later use.
Although IUI represents the safest, lowest technology option (especially when drugs are not used for ovulation), IVF (and/or ICSI) is invasive, expensive, and carries serious risks of harm to the women involved, the children who are produced through its use, and the relationships of the contracting couples. Whichever method is used to procure a pregnancy, however, whether the eventual child produced will be of the desired sex is uncertain. There are a variety of different methods by which sperm are sorted and there is little available scientific evidence as to the actual success rates of different approaches.
Preimplantation genetic diagnosis is a second type of sex selection technology that also involves the use of in vitro fertilization. Instead of introducing sorted sperm prior to fertilization, however, the harvested eggs are allowed to develop to the eight-cell stage; at that point, it is possible to extract a cell to analyze its chromosomal makeup. Embryos can then be sorted into male and female groupings and only those with the desired sex chromosomes will be transferred to the woman's womb (or frozen for later use). In contrast to other sperm-sorting techniques, this procedure has the distinct advantage of removing virtually all uncertainty regarding the sex chromosomes, but, again, it involves the serious physical and psychosocial risks that are associated with IVF.
Alternatively, it is possible to initiate a pregnancy and then make use of various types of prenatal testing (ultrasound, amniocentesis, or chorionic villi sampling) to determine the chromosomal sex of the developing fetus. If abortion is legal within the jurisdiction, the woman can then abort the fetus if it is the “wrong” sex. If there are multiple fetuses, a frequent occurrence when women use assisted reproduction technologies, they may choose to selectively terminate some fetuses; sex is often used as the basis for choice in such circumstances. Interestingly, in countries where abortion is legal (such as it is in Canada), prenatal testing and selective abortion would still be permitted even if legislation were to prohibit preconception sex selection. However, although women are able to obtain prenatal information about the likely sex of their fetus in most medical facilities in Canada, the information may not be available until well into the second trimester, and most doctors refuse to perform abortions so far into a pregnancy unless there are strong medical indications (i.e., risk of serious illness to the pregnant woman or the resulting child).
Ever since these technologies became available, there has been vigorous debate in the literature as to the legitimacy of using the powers of reproductive and genetic medicine for sex selection purposes, especially because the most reliable forms of sex selection technology involve prenatal testing (and now PGD) and selective abortion (or discarding) of fetuses (embryos) that happen to be of the undesired sex. Many feminists who have fought hard for women's unfettered “right to choose” abortion find themselves distressed to think that some women would terminate wanted pregnancies solely on the basis of the sex of the child. The ethical battle lines quickly formed. On one side were the defenders of procreative liberty, led by their standard-bearer, John Robertson.3
Robertson JA. Children of Choice. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1994.
In opposition, particularly to the forms of sex selection that involve destruction of embryos or fetuses, we find, not surprisingly, the various conservative factions that oppose all forms of abortion; indeed, many conservatives have felt vindicated in their opposition to allowing choice on abortion by the idea that, once available, women will choose such a “trivial” reason to terminate a pregnancy. In the case of sex selection, however, conservatives are not alone. As noted above, many feminists have also expressed deep reservations about the practice. They observe that, worldwide, the vast majority of people seeking sex selection technologies do so to produce male rather than female children. In the overwhelming number of cases, the technology is used to destroy female fetuses to facilitate another pregnancy that might turn out to be male. This is no mere coincidence in the view of feminists. Rather, it is an expression of cultural prejudices against girls and women, a sex so devalued that it is often judged better that a child not be born than it be born female. It seems that legitimizing such prejudices by treating them as appropriate targets for medical intervention is likely to deepen, rather than lessen, their impact. Although most feminists have been reluctant to authorize state intervention in women's hard-won right to choose abortion for any reason, many have proposed that restrictions be put in place regarding disclosure of fetal sex to discourage the practice of selectively aborting female fetuses.4
See, for example, Wertz DC, Fletcher JC. Sex selection through prenatal diagnosis: A feminist critique. In: Bequaert Holmes H, Purdy LM, eds. Feminist Perspectives in Medical Ethics. Bloomington: Indiana University Press; 1992.
Rather than get caught up in the abortion debates, we will concentrate on the new technological options that occur outside of women's bodies, namely, sperm sorting before conception and PGD before implantation; restrictions on either or both of these technologies leave intact women's right to choose abortion. We believe that there is still plenty of reason for concern about the proliferation of these options. We fear that if these practices become accepted as familiar, even routine (or at least acceptable) options in reproduction, the social message that it is normal to try to control the sex of one's offspring will be enacted again and again.5
Results from surveys show that 25%–35% of parents or prospective parents in the United States would choose to use sex selection services if they were available. Microsort alone, a technology involving the separation of sperm using a modified flow cytometer, is predicted to have a market in the United States of $200 to $400 million per year; Wadman M. So you want a girl? Fortune; 2001;143(19 Feb):174–79.
At present, there is little evidence that most North Americans are interested in avoiding the birth of female children.6
See Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies, Proceed with Care: Final Report of the Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies, chap. 28. Ottawa: Canada Communications Group; 1993.
See Robertson JA. Preconception gender selection. American Journal of Bioethics 2001;1(1):2–9.
This figure is for women in Canada aged 15–49 in 2002, according to Statistics Canada. Canada's fertility rate falls in the middle of the rates of other nations around the world, with Italy, Japan, and Germany having slightly lower fertility rates and the United States, Australia, the United Kingdom, and France having slightly higher rates.
Our worry addresses the pervasive and harmful gender norms that are being reinforced when the practice of selecting the sex of one's (next) child is legitimized. If we look to the advertisements for the companies marketing these technologies, we can readily see that they are promoting a simple equation: that predetermining the sex of a child is concomitant with predetermining its gender. The Fertility Institutes advertises, for example, that “It has been known for many years that the gender of a pregnancy is determined by the sex chromosome carried by the sperm.”9
Fertility Evaluation and Procedures: Scientific Understanding. Los Angeles: The Fertility Institutes. Available at http://www.fertility-docs.com/fertility_gender.phtml; last accessed 3 Oct 2006.
Sidney IVF. How is sex selection done at SIVF? Sidney, Australia: SIVF. During the publication process, the page was removed from SIVF's website as a result of new Australian ethical guidelines recommending against sex selection services being performed for nonmedical reasons. While publicly disagreeing with the moral reasons given in the guidelines, SIVF has halted its sex selection services. The original webpage can still be viewed at http://web.archive.org/web/20041015073938/http://www.sivf.com.au/ss_how.htm; last accessed 3 Oct 2006.
The emphasis placed on “family balancing” in Western arguments in support of sex selection technologies also suggests that what is desired by families seeking these techniques is not primarily a child with different genitals but a child who conforms to the opposite gender role to the children they already have. The fact that couples are willing to pay thousands of dollars for sex selection services and spend the time, effort, and emotional energy, not to mention facing the physical risks, associated with sex selection procedures indicates a strong belief that important differences attach to having a child of one sex rather than the other. This belief is not adequately captured by differences in physiological sex and can only be explained in terms of assumptions about the different social roles, including behaviors, interests, and practices, that are considered appropriate for boys and men and for girls and women. In other words, part of what is expected from sex selection techniques is a child that will conform to assumed (and desired) gender roles.
Implicit in these gender expectations, we suspect, is likely to be conformity to a desired sexual orientation. Anne Bolin observes that there are four gender markers: physiological sex, gender identity, social identity, and sexual orientation.11
Bolin A. Transforming transvestism and transsexualism: Polarity, politics, and gender. In: Bullough B, Bullough VL, Elias J, eds. Gender Blending. New York: Prometheus Books; 1997:26.
McKinnon C. Feminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and Law. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press; 1987:50. In other societies, there is acceptance of a third gender, such as the guevedoche in the Dominican Republic, the hijra in India, and the kwolu-aatmwal in the highlands of Papua New Guinea. Nataf Z. Whatever I feel [pseudo-hermaphroditism]. New Internationalist 1998;300(April):22–25.
In fact, the relationship between sexual orientation and gender expectations seems to be dialectical: each is framed by assumptions about the dichotomous nature of the other. Underlying the choice for a baby girl, then, is very likely an unexamined presumption that their daughter will eventually get married and have children or, for a boy, that their son will eventually find a nice girl to settle down with. Indeed, where there is confusion regarding the sex of a child, the concern that the child will grow up to be homosexual is often expressed as a dominant concern by mothers.13
Weiss M. Fence sitters: Parents' reactions to sexual ambiguities in their newborn children. Semiotica 1995;107:33–50.
Clearly, then, sex selection, whether by sperm sorting or PGD, is not a guarantor of gender, with all the complexities that gender entails. The implicit (or explicit) gender promises of fertility clinics cannot be relied on because all that can be “virtually guaranteed” in the implantation of PGD embryos (and the nonguaranteed promises of sperm sorting) is that the resultant child will have the desired sex chromosomes; there can be no guarantees that the gender role the child comes to identify with will correlate with the sex of his or her chromosomes, especially as he or she grows up. Although parents may attempt to raise their child in conformity with a certain gender role, as the child passes through adolescence and into adulthood, his or her gender identity—defined as one's psychological or emotional identification as male or female—may diverge from his or her sex of rearing. Experience with intersexuals, transsexuals, and transvestites, for example, has shown that there is no simple one-to-one correlation between sex and gender. In intersexuality, chromosomal sex is not even sufficient for determining physiological sex, let alone gender. What, we must ask, will be the response of parents who have gone to a great deal of time, trouble, and expense to ensure a baby of a chosen gender if that child ends up failing to meet standard gender norms or rejects the prescribed gender identity entirely? Will medicine continue to play an active role in trying to ensure conformity?
It is clear, though seldom publicly discussed, that children do not always develop gender identities that match the gender roles in which they were raised. “Tomboys,” for example, may conform more to the male gender role than the female stereotype would typically allow, whereas “sissies” may resemble female gender norms more than stereotypical male behavior. Despite these modest deviations, however, children who display such behaviors are still mostly accepted in society—especially because it is commonly assumed that they will “outgrow” these tendencies after puberty. Other forms of behavior that deviate more significantly from traditional gender roles are less accepted in society. Many transvestites, for instance, obtain a great deal of pleasure from conforming to the gender role of the opposite sex in the form of cross-dressing. This phenomenon covers a wide range of behaviors from wearing a few items of clothing to full-scale impersonation, either in jest or as an expression of personal identity.14
Bullough V, Bullough B. Cross-Dressing, Sex, and Gender. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1993:vii.
Most transsexuals—a condition that was originally recognized as an extreme version of transvestism15
King D. The Transvestite and the Transsexual. Avebury, UK: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.; 1993, esp. chapter 2.
Some studies posit that the number of male to female transsexuals is about 1 in 100,000 and of female to male transsexuals is about 1 in 130,000; Eichler M. Sex change operations: The last bulwark of the double standard. In: Nelson ED, Robinson BW, eds. Gender in the 1990s: Images, Realities, and Issues. Nelson, Canada: International Thomson Publishing; 1995:30. Bullough and Bullough, however, estimate that the incidence of transsexuality is approximately 1:50,000 in both men and women; see note 14, Bullough, Bullough 1993:314.
Wilson B, Reiner W. Management of intersex: A shifting paradigm. In: Dreger AD, ed. Intersex in the Age of Ethics. Hagerstown, Md.: University Publishing Group, Inc.; 1999:121.
Sexual orientation also seems to develop independently of both sex and gender identity in many cases.18
Milton Diamond argues, for example, that sexual orientation is partially predisposed prenatally and develops independently of sex of rearing and the appearance of the genitals; see Diamond M. Sexual identity and sexual orientation in children with traumatized or ambiguous genitalia. The Journal of Sex Research 1997;34(2):199–211.
See note 14, Bullough, Bullough 1993:294.
Pauly I. Gender identity and sexual orientation. In: Denny D, ed. Current Concepts in Transgender Identity. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.; 1998:237–48.
Furthermore, it is not even guaranteed that chromosomal constitution predetermines physiological sex. Although in the majority of births, a quick genital inspection can determine the sex of the infant, this is not always the case. In approximately 1.7% of live births,21
Blackless M, Charuvastra A, Fausto-Sterling A, Luzanne K, Lee E. How sexually dimorphic are we? Review and synthesis. American Journal of Human Biology 2000;12:161.
See note 17, Wilson, Reiner 1999:123.
For a comprehensive survey of all the variations from the dichotomous ideal of male and female, see note 21, Blackless et al. 2000.
Not even the correlation between chromosomal sex and genetic sex is automatic, although it is extremely rare for them to come apart. Genetic sex is determined by the genetic sequencing that governs testicular development, thought to be the SRY gene. Although this gene is usually found on the Y chromosome, it may be found on a different chromosome and sometimes even on the X chromosome. Such an individual would have an XX karyotype despite having testes and a male apparent sex. It is possible, therefore, for even genetic sex to fail to reflect chromosomal sex.24
They might also have an X0 karyotype, where “0” marks the absence of the second chromosome; see note 17, Wilson, Reiner 1999:120.
The medical field has been involved in the identification and medical control of “deviations” from stereotypical gender ideals for more than a century. Surgical interventions to “normalize” the genitalia of intersexuals have been undertaken since the 1950s, including myriad procedures such as vaginoplasty, peotomy, castration, hysterectomy, clitorectomy, hypospadias surgery, mastectomy, and penile reconstruction, many of which require repeated surgeries. Hormonal therapy usually begins just before or at puberty, to be continued throughout the individual's life. These interventions are all performed with the motivation of helping the child develop a stable gender identity and live a “normal” and well-adjusted life as a girl/woman or as a boy/man. Similar procedures are followed in sex reversal surgeries for transsexuals, who also began to receive medical treatment of their bodies in the second half of the 20th century; although the condition was regarded as pathological prior to this time, the only available “treatment” was psychiatric. Before being approved for the surgery, transsexuals must pass a sexological examination, a full psychiatric examination, prove that they are not homosexual,25
The motivation for this requirement seems to be that the transsexual must “truly” fit the gender role of the opposite sex, namely being attracted to members of the opposite sex (postsurgery) in a heterosexual relationship. If an individual is homosexual, there would be no need to undergo the surgery because they can engage in sexual activity without it.
See note 15, King 1993:51–8.
Transvestism and homosexuality have also been heavily pathologized. In the 18th and 19th centuries both were considered to be “crimes against nature”; they later became defined as mental disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) of the American Psychiatric Association. Whereas transvestism remains recorded in the DSM IV as a sexually deviant behavior (along with such activities as pedophilia, exhibitionism, and voyeurism), homosexuality was removed in 1973, possibly due to the fact that it has been more closely studied than transvestism and because homosexuals are better politically organized than transvestites. Homosexuality is still regarded by some people as a “disease” to be cured, however, and therefore remains in the sights of the medical field. Various physiological bases for homosexuality have been proposed over the years, including a difference in brain size between homosexuals and heterosexuals, but none have ever been proven. The most recent—and, arguably, the most insidious—attention directed toward homosexuality is in efforts to find a homosexual “gene”; such chromosomal association would allow prospective parents to select against the “condition” in prenatal testing and in PGD.
Given the history of medical involvement with phenomena such as homosexuality, transsexuality, and intersexuality, the medical establishment should be well aware of the fact that there are significant variations in the combinations of sex, gender, and sexual orientations in the human population. Practitioners should also be aware that medicine, historically, has not always been successful in “normalizing” everyone to fit heterosexual gender norms, with the possible exception of transsexuals. Homosexuals rally against judgments that they are abnormal or deviant and they are currently struggling to be recognized as equals in law and in society. Members of the intersex community have also taken the initiative in recent years to speak out against the medical treatment that they received, usually as infants and therefore without their consent.27
See, for example, the autobiographical accounts in Dreger AD, ed. Intersex in the Age of Ethics. Hagerstown, MD: University Publishing Group, 1999; and in Carlisle D. Human Sex Change and Sex Reversal. New York: Edwin Mellen Press; 1998. Visit also the web site of the Intersex Society of North America at http://www.isna.org and the web site of the United Kingdom Intersex Association at http://www.ukia.co.uk/voices/index.htm.
It is important to recognize that none of these forms of classification is itself straightforward. Even on their own, gender, sexuality, and even sex do not fit neatly into two exhaustive and complementary categories; each admits of variations and gradations. When sex, gender, and sexuality are interpreted as simple dualisms, each side of the traditional pair carries with it problematic stereotypes. Feminists have routinely challenged these traditional conceptions and objected to the behavioral expectations they generate on the grounds that such interpretations are deeply entwined with patterns of gender and sexuality oppression.28
See, for example, Frye M. The necessity of differences: Constructing a positive category of women. Signs 1996;21(4):991–1010; Bartky SL. Femininity and Domination: Studies in the Phenomenology of Oppression. New York: Routledge; 1990; Butler J. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York: Routledge; 1990.
The provision of sex selection services by the medical field is therefore socially, ethically, and morally problematic because it involves accepting simplistic notions of sex, gender, and of the connection between them when each of these categories has been demonstrated repeatedly to be far from clear. Using the terms “sex selection” and “gender selection” interchangeably, as do so many fertility clinics, is not only misleading but may well be harmful to society, to individuals who do not fit well within the available dichotomous categories, and to children produced through sex selection techniques. The assumption that gender is easily characterized and reducible to sex is problematic for society in the sense that it may serve to make people in general less tolerant of diversity; this intolerance can have a significant impact on matters of social justice.29
In Nazi Germany, for example, homosexuals were the second largest group targeted after the Jews, and it is estimated that more than 220,000 were killed; see McNeill JJ. The Church and the Homosexual. Kansas City: Sheed Andrews and McMeel Inc.; 1976:82.
Promises that sex selection will “virtually guarantee” the gender of choice may also make parental acceptance of children who do not fit traditional gender norms particularly difficult, which can only negatively impact the children produced by these technologies. Although having a child who reveals that she is a homosexual or a transsexual may create strain in many families—and the occurrence of intersexuality is particularly difficult to cope with because it must be faced immediately upon birth30
A cross-cultural, long-term study by Meira Weiss shows that parents of newborns are much more likely to reject a baby with external defects than internal ones. Because of the importance of sex in categorizing a child, ambiguity of sexual genitalia is particularly traumatic; see note 13, Weiss 1995:37.
The widespread social understanding of sex as determining gender suggests that the problem is not likely to be removed even if advertisers could be persuaded to resist the temptation to promise “gender selection” when they are in fact selling choice of sex chromosomes. Despite the wording, prospective parents would still be likely to assume that by choosing a male or a female child they are choosing one of two possible genders. These cultural expectations are deeply entrenched and are surely being reinforced by the growing market in sex selection services. Why else would prospective parents go to the trouble, risk, and expense of such services unless they had certain expectations about the difference attached to having a child of a particular sex?
Moreover, because the traditional expectations that attach to standard gender norms—which are uncritically promoted by sex selection technologies—are implicated in existing patterns of gender and sexuality oppression, they are problematic even for those who do seem to fit within their traditional boundaries. Gender expectations have historically been used to restrict the life prospects of men and, especially, of women; the entrenchment of such expectations can only serve to perpetuate this limitation of life choices even for those who seem to conform to traditional conceptualizations of sex and gender.
Of course, the problems of assuming dichotomous categories of sex, gender, and sexuality, and the harms attached to pervasive social efforts to enforce “gender-appropriate” behaviors that rest on these assumptions long predate the availability of sex selection services. These attitudes and problems are deeply entrenched within prevailing social norms. Our argument is not that the marketing of sex selection services is the source of such expectations but that it accepts them unquestioningly and provides them with a scientific and medical veneer that makes them appear biologically based and unproblematic. The continuous focus on conformity to gender stereotypes that is supported by the implied correlation between sex and gender in sex selection bypasses urgent questions about whether the dichotomy on which our gender stereotypes are based is even desirable.31
Many feminists argue, for example, that heterosexism, perpetuated by ideals of the traditional family, has been associated historically with spousal violence, child abuse, rape, inequality of domestic chores, and the perpetuation of male dominance. The effects on women as a result of this patriarchal structure include the physical and emotional separation of women from other women, exploited labor in the home and in childbearing, forced sexual submission, and the exclusion from cultural and professional pursuits. Gender roles based on this model, therefore, may not be worth perpetuating. See Seaville V. Catholicism and the Moral Status of Homosexuality. Master's thesis. Calgary, Alberta: University of Calgary; 2002:99.
Thus, the serious ethical implications involved in the use and promotion of sex selection services cannot be overlooked. It is morally irresponsible to promise delivery of a child of a chosen gender when that is clearly beyond the power of reproductive technology. In addition, there are social concerns about the ways in which these technologies entrench social expectations about the virtual correlation between sex and gender and reinforce without question traditional gender role expectations. The variations and combinations of types of sex, gender identities, and sexual orientations discussed in this essay should sound warning bells to enthusiastic supporters of sex selection services, to parents who wish to make use of this technology, and to champions of social justice.
What, then, is to be done? We can make efforts to educate individual consumers about the problematic assumptions underlying these technologies, even though education about the complexities of gender as a social construct is likely to be difficult to digest and act on within a marketplace promising a technological fix to all sorts of gender hopes and dreams. As well, we can—and should—try to educate fertility experts about their moral and professional responsibilities to avoid participating in, and thereby legitimating and perpetuating, desires for access to these technologies on the part of consumers. Professional societies for physicians engaged in fertility treatments should take a moral stand opposing such activities on the part of their members.32
For example, the Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada has taken this stance.
Nonetheless, change in societal understanding of sex and gender is unlikely to be achieved simply by appeal to individual actors. Until society does revise its understanding of the complex and diverse nature of sex, gender, and sexuality, there will be many reasons for individuals to choose to participate in the existing social patterns and stereotypes. Therefore, it is important to seek change at the level of policy as well where prohibitions on sex selection services can be enforced more readily on behalf of the social interest, especially where the social interest conflicts with individual preferences. Hence, we encourage more governments to take the choice out of the hands of individual consumers and practitioners through restrictive legislation, such as that introduced in Canada. We believe the arguments regarding the social and personal hazards of conflating gender with chromosomal sex, together with society's interest in social justice, are weighty enough to justify legislative efforts to prohibit sex selection and to belie its portrayal as a simple expression of reproductive freedom.
