In her volume Citizenship, Belonging, and Political Community in Africa, Emma Hunter brings together a rich and diverse collection of essays interrogating the many meanings of citizenship in Africa. At the heart of any discussion of citizenship on the continent is the question of how Africans conceive of and relate to their political communities. As Hunter indicates in her introduction, this is a question that has long bedeviled scholars. But in seeking an answer to it, scholars almost invariably confront the prospect of privileging certain types of political communities over others. As a result, big concepts like the ‘nation-state’, ‘colonialism’, or ‘ethnicity’ often paper over the diverse ways in which Africans construct their political communities and, more importantly, how they maneuver and negotiate their ways into and through these entities. Hunter points out that this line of inquiry is further plagued by a deep-seated presentism, which tends to frame African encounters with citizenship as largely a postcolonial phenomenon.
In both the regional and temporal diversity of its chapters, Hunter's collection takes on the challenge of thinking through the issue of citizenship in Africa. Structurally, the collection is comprised of nine essays divided into three parts, plus an introductory chapter by John Lonsdale and a postscript by Frederick Cooper. Lonsdale, for his part, lays the intellectual groundwork for the collection as he traces the historical development of both African and Western ideas of citizenship and belonging. Part One, ‘Citizens and Subjects in African History’ features chapters by Nicole Ulrich, Cherry Leonardi and Chris Vaughan, and Aidan Russell, each of which interrogates the interplay between ‘citizen’ and ‘subject’ in the African past and, in Ulrich's case, delves as far back as the Dutch colonization of the Cape of Good Hope. Key to these essays is an analytical broadening of our ideas of ‘citizen’ and ‘subject’ beyond normative or legalistic definitions. Instead, each of these authors challenge historians and social scientists to understand these terms as dynamic and thus shifting in meaning and substance depending on time, place, and the intentionality of those employing them.
The book's second part examines citizenship in the postcolonial state. Its essays ask scholars to both broaden and narrow the lenses through which they examine ideas of citizenship. For instance, in a chapter on Félix Houphouët-Boigny's failed attempt to grant fellow francophone West Africans double nationalité (dual citizenship) in the 1960s, Henri-Michel Yéré explores the interaction between attempts to expand the idea of citizenship beyond the nation-state in postcolonial Côte d'Ivoire and the class anxieties of an elite group of Ivoirians seeking to limit it. In contrast, Samantha Balaton-Chrimes examines the liminal place of Kenya's Nubian population – tied to its history as a martial race – within the broader Kenyan state, while Ramola Ramtohul rounds out this section by outlining the ways in which Mauritius's histories of race, migration, and colonialism have shaped this island's multiethnic and multiracial social and political order. The book's final part, ‘Citizenship in Contemporary Africa’, details debates over citizenship in contemporary Africa with essays by V. Adefemi Isumonah, Solomon M. Gofie, and Eghosa E. Osaghae that reflect upon the role of ethnicity and citizenship in state efforts to govern multiethnic, democratic societies.
In all, it would be difficult to ask for a richer and more intellectually diverse collection of essays than Hunter provides in this volume. In terms of disciplinary perspectives, the volume contains reflections from such fields as history, political science, sociology, and international studies while, regionally, all of the continent's major regions (except North Africa, depending on how one counts Sudan) are represented in the collection. However, at the risk of embarking upon an unfair critique, the one absence from the text is a response from Mahmood Mamdani. Throughout the collection, nearly all of the volume's essays not only directly engage Mamdani's now classic Citizen and Subject, but, more importantly, they also seem to use Mamdani's 1996 book as a starting point for their particular analyses. The uniformity with which these essays turn towards Mamdani suggests that the collection could have benefited from a rejoinder from him. He could have used such a forum to reflect upon his ‘citizen’ and ‘subject’ framework, more than two decades later, as well as consider how each of the collection's chapters broaden and rework his model in fascinating and nuanced ways.
