I Introduction
On 3 May 2017, the UK’s House of Lords’ Energy and Environment Sub-Committee of the European Union Committee published a report entitled Brexit: agriculture (hereinafter, the report).Footnote 1 According to the report, the UK’s agriculture and food sector will face “enormous challenges” following Brexit, both in relation to trade with the EU and within its own borders. A regulated area where non-tariff barriers might occur is the area of plant protection products (often just referred to as “pesticides”) and their residues in food. Brexit could, however, also present opportunities, as the report notes, with the country moving away from the EU’s “one size fits all” policies on food and farming. In particular, in the area of pesticides, there could be a shift from the EU’s current arguably more “precautionary approach” to regulating chemicals, which emphasises the hazards of a given substance, to a more “risk-based approach”.
II Background
The UK House of Lords is the second chamber of the UK Parliament. It is independent from, and complements the work of, the elected House of Commons. The Lords share the task of making and shaping laws, and of checking and challenging the work of the UK Government. Members of the House of Lords are the 26 bishops of the established Church of England (ie the Lords Spiritual), plus the Lords Temporal, 90 of whom are hereditary peers elected among themselves and two peers who are ex officio members, but the majority of the Lords Temporal are life peers who are appointed by the monarch on the advice of the Prime Minister, or the House of Lords Appointments Commission.
The UK House of Lords’ EU Committee is a Select Committee and is appointed “to scrutinise documents deposited in the House by a Minister, and other matters relating to the EU”. The EU Committee, along with its Sub-Committees, scrutinises the UK Government’s policies and actions with respect to the EU, considers and seeks to influence the development of policies and draft laws proposed by the EU institutions, and, more generally, represents the UK House of Lords in its dealings with the EU institutions and other EU Member States.
The UK House of Lords’ report states that “[o]nce outside the EU, the UK must develop its own external tariffs, and may find itself subject to the high external tariffs applied by the EU to agricultural products – to the detriment of UK farmers and food manufacturers”. In addition, the report warns that “[t]he UK may also face non-tariff barriers when exporting agriculture and food products to the EU, resulting in delays at ports and additional administrative costs.” In Chapter 2 of the report, which addresses “Withdrawing from the Common Agricultural Policy”, the report recalls that, in order to facilitate the functioning of the EU Single Market in agricultural products, the EU has set standards for food, farm animal health and welfare and plant protection products – what is called “coherent farm-to-table” measures.
This regulatory framework also includes plant protection products (or pesticides) and the EU rules regulating the maximum level of traces of pesticides (ie “residues”) allowed in food or feed. Before any plant protection product may be placed on the market or used, it must be authorised in the EU Member State(s) concerned. Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 of 21 October 2009 concerning the placing of plant protection products on the market and repealing Council Directive 79/117/EEC and 91/414/EECFootnote 2 lays down the rules and procedures for authorisation of such products and the approval of active ingredients (ie the chemicals in plant protection products that kill, control, or repel pests).
Before a plant protection product (or pesticide) can be used in the EU, it must be scientifically evaluated by its manufacturer. The European Food Safety Agency (hereinafter, EFSA) then conducts an assessment of that evaluation at the EU level, on the basis of which the European Commission (hereinafter, Commission) proposes the approval or non-approval to the relevant section of the Standing Committee on Plants, Animals, Food and Feed (hereinafter, SCPAFF). EU Member States within that section of the SCPAFF must ultimately vote on the approval of the active ingredients at the EU level. In the UK, authorisations for pesticides containing the EU-approved active ingredients are then granted by the Chemicals Regulation Division (CRD) of the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) according to the Food and Environment Protection Act 1985Footnote 3 and Control of Pesticides Regulations 1986,Footnote 4 which provide the overall legal framework for the control of pesticides in the UK.
The UK House of Lords’ report refers to the regulation of pesticides as an area where the opportunity for change exceeds the risks in a post-Brexit era. However, although there may be significant opportunities to review the legislative framework underpinning agriculture in the UK, the UK House of Lords, in its report, notes that the scope for deregulation may be limited. Potential improvements have been reported to the UK House of Lords by, inter alia, the Crop Protection Association and the National Association of British and Irish Flour Millers: “A recurring theme was for the UK to move to a more risk-based approach to plant protection product regulation. The EU takes a ‘precautionary approach’ to regulating chemicals, which emphasises the hazard of a given substance to human and animal health.”Footnote 5 The report states that it had been argued that “the principle of risk, backed up by good science, is just as good a principle to adhere to”. The UK Crop Protection Association agreed: “[t]he use of hazard criteria for regulation of pesticides should not be retained by the UK following exit from the EU as it limits the range of pesticides available to growers and farmers without any concomitant improvement in protection of either human health or the environment.”Footnote 6 The UK House of Lords also quoted opponents of a deregulation of pesticides in the UK. The UK Pesticides Campaign stated that “[t]he only real solution to eliminate all adverse health and environmental impacts of pesticides is to take a preventative approach and avoid exposure altogether”,Footnote 7 while the Soil Association pointed out that “[o]n something like endocrine disruptors, where effectively there is no safe threshold that can be defined, a hazard-based approach is the same as a risk-based approach.”Footnote 8
III Comment
The EU process for active ingredient approval under Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 is, in fact, lengthy. Arguably, there is scope for the UK to be considerably more rapid. Therefore, priorities for the future regulation of plant protection products include using a risk- rather than a hazard-based system of approval and the acceleration of the approval process. The question is what this will mean in practice.
1 The glyphosate controversy
The re-evaluation procedure of the herbicide glyphosate may serve as an example. The EU’s approval of glyphosate was set to expire on 30 June 2016. It was originally authorised until 31 December 2015, but the authorisation was extended by six months in order to provide for enough time for a comprehensive and thorough re-evaluation of the active substance. The approval of active substances may always be re-assessed as soon as there are indications that an active substance is no longer safe. At the request of the Commission, the EFSA reviewed a report of March 2015 of the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), an agency of the World Health Organisation, which classified glyphosate as “probably carcinogenic to humans” and caused some controversy. It can be observed that both the EFSA and IARC are blamed for disregarding studies and being opaque as to the origin of the scientific findings included in their respective reports. The IARC considered in its assessment the extent of possible damage (hazard potential), while the EFSA goes beyond this approach and assesses how likely it is that this damage may occur (ie the extent of the risk). The latter is, for example, dependent on the extent to which someone is exposed to a potential “hazard”. Accordingly, “hazard” includes anything that can potentially cause damage, while the ’risk’ assessment aims at determining the actual “risk”.
The uncertainty over the renewal of glyphosate, the UK’s most widely used herbicide (better known by the Monsanto brand name “Roundup”) was reportedly one of the reasons that many British farmers voted to leave the EU in May 2016. Reportedly, withdrawing glyphosate from the market would be devastating to British farmers, who rely on the herbicide to fight weeds. More than 2 million hectares of land were treated with glyphosate in England and Wales in 2014. Without it, winter wheat and barley production would likely decline by about 12% and would reduce the cultivation of oilseed rape (used for oil and animal feed) by about 10%, according to the National Farmers Union. Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/1056 of 29 June 2016 amending Implementing Regulation (EU) No 540/2011 as regards the extension of the approval period of the active substance glyphosateFootnote 9 established a new deadline of “6 months from the date of receipt of the opinion of the Committee for Risk Assessment of the European Chemicals Agency by the Commission (hereinafter, ECHA) or 31 December 2017, whichever is the earlier”. On 15 March 2017, the ECHA’s Committee for Risk Assessment (hereinafter, RAC) agreed to maintain the current harmonised classification of glyphosate as a substance causing serious eye damage and being toxic to aquatic life with long-lasting effects. The RAC concluded that the available scientific evidence did not meet the criteria to classify glyphosate as a carcinogen, as a mutagen or as toxic for reproduction. The extension of the authorisation was, therefore, extended until 15 September 2017.
On 16 May 2017, the Commission agreed that the discussions with EU Member States regarding the possible renewal of the approval of glyphosate could restart. The Commission’s proposal was published in mid-July and discussions with EU Member States restarted on 20 July 2017. The Commission is proposing a renewal of the approval of glyphosate for 10 years. The Commission also included in its proposal the following aspects: (1) specific provisions that EU Member States have to take into account when considering applications for glyphosate-products (ie protection of groundwater and terrestrial animals and non-target plants); (2) certain elements that EU Member States must ensure during the assessment and decision making for authorisation (eg minimise the use in public areas); and (3) the ban of POE-tallowamine (a co-formulant previously used in glyphosate-based products) put in place in 2016. The Commission aims to finalise discussions in the last quarter of 2017 before proceeding to vote on the re-approval. However, many EU Member States have yet to adopt a position on the matter, meaning the Commission’s attempt to achieve a qualified majority of countries supporting the proposal in the SCPAFF is not yet assured. The SCPAFF was expected to vote on the renewal of glyphosate during its meeting in the first week of October 2017, but the vote was postponed until later in the year.
2 The way forward in the UK
The UK will continue to be required to meet its EU obligations while it remains a Member of the EU. The regulations that implement EU health and food safety laws will stay in place. Health and food safety regulations will be decided as part of the exit negotiations. Only when these negotiations are finished, will the UK actually leave the EU and will it no longer be bound by its rules. Until then nothing will change in practice. On 11 September 2017, the UK adopted the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill 2017–19,Footnote 10 earlier often referred to as the “Great Repeal Bill”. The Bill repeals the European Communities Act 1972, by which the UK acceded to the then European Economic Community. It also converts all existing EU legislation into UK law. Then, the UK will undertake a likely lengthy review-and-revision process. In the meantime, negotiations with the EU on Brexit and the future (trade) relationship between the EU and the UK will continue. The future relationship remains largely uncertain and a number of options exist. The options include a UK membership in the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), a customs union for the trade in goods (as currently in place between the EU and Turkey), a comprehensive free trade agreement or, finally, a trade relationship without any special agreement and only governed by the WTO trade and customs rules.Footnote 11 The UK Government currently appears to favour a full dissociation from the EU, generally referred to as a “hard Brexit”, meaning that the future relationship would probably be governed by a free trade agreement or the WTO rules. However, until the negotiations have further progressed and more specific information becomes available, any outlook on the UK’s future relationship with the EU remains pure speculation.
The placing on the market of plant protection products will therefore continue to be regulated by UK law which is equivalent to Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009. However, it cannot be ruled out that in the future, a different approach with respect to the scientific assessment (ie a risk- rather than a hazard-based system of approval) may be taken, which is arguably more permissive. In practice, this could mean that re-assessed active ingredients or newly-developed active ingredients that are not approved in the EU may be approved in the UK. This will also have an impact on trade in plant protection products containing such active ingredients. However, agricultural produce may also be affected if, for example, UK farmers apply such plant protection products on their crops, which leave residues in the products, for which there are no maximum residue levels (MRLs) in EU law (or the MRL is set at the limit of detectability, LOD) and goods cannot be traded with the EU because of non-compliance with its residues legislation.
Should the UK develop its own procedures and assessment criteria for the approval of plant protection products, non-tariff barriers would likely occur in trade with the EU and vice versa. Moreover, international standards, for example those set by the Codex Alimentarius Commission on maximum residue levels for pesticides, and WTO agreements, such as the WTO Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS Agreement) and the WTO Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT Agreement), apply to trade with any third country, and will thus constrain the UK’s regulatory freedom to a certain extent. If glyphosate, for example, were to be still authorised in the UK, but banned in the EU, crops treated with it could only be used on the domestic UK market. Farmers would need separate storage facilities for exports to the EU and for supplies to the domestic market. This would likely not be the only concern for farmers under a distinct UK policy on pesticides. The report of the House of Lords notes, in a paragraph on “Supply chains and agricultural inputs”, the Agriculture Industries Confederation’s (AIC) statement that, as regards crop protection products, such as pesticides, “some 85% of the market is supplied with products manufactured elsewhere in the EU”.
IV Conclusions
There are strong calls in the UK, from farmers’ unions and the Crop Protection Association, to reform the current system of approval of pesticides, which is currently based on EU law. Arguably, the system may shift from the current EU hazard-based approach to a more risk-based approach, but significant consequences should be evaluated and taken into account. Discussions on the future regulation of plant protection products in the UK are already ongoing and should be closely monitored by stakeholders, as formal Brexit negotiations continue to advance during the coming months.
