Understanding Disability Policy is a sophisticated and elegant book which engages with inherently complex and contested issues with conceptual clarity. The book is also timely given recent policy developments around the personalisation agenda and the Conservative−Liberal notion of the ‘Big Society’. Each chapter weaves historical and transcending policy issues with insight and scope, containing useful boxes of key points, a conclusion, a summary and suggestions for further reading. All of these are helpful learning aids for students, lecturers and other readers interested in both policy and disability.
Chapter 1 gives context to what's to come, beginning with Drakes’ typology of disability policy (Reference Drake1999) outlining the drivers of segregation, compensation, welfare rights and citizenship. In addition, personalisation, paternalism and the categorisations of disabled people are also touched upon but returned to in detail in chapter 5. Chapter 2 critically explores at a systemic level the influence of the contrasting medical and social models of disability on the development of policy. The social model of disability is a main reference point for the entire book but the work also engages with wider policy trends around education, training, employment and welfare. This chapter goes on to contend that disabled people have been the direct focus of numerous social policy initiatives since the 1970s and indirectly many more before then. Roulstone and Prideaux assert that the Beveridge Report's (Reference Beveridge1942) main focus was not ‘disease’, ‘ignorance’, ‘squalor’ or ‘idleness’ but ‘want’ expressed in terms of the restructuring of the labour market. They write: ‘Social normality, active citizenship and social inclusion was thus conceived as participation in the paid labour market (PLM) while working contributions into social insurance’ (p. 24). Therefore, the proposed conceptualisation of the ‘citizen’ did not fit disabled people so they were denied active and full participation within the mainstream.
Chapter 3 examines community care and the growth of marketisation drawing importantly on the voices of disabled people and in particular the work of Colin Barnes at Leeds University. Disabled children and inclusion in terms of welfare, social and health care and education since 1997 is the focus of chapter 4 where the link between disabled children and poverty is emphasised. Chapter 5 in turn looks to New Labour and examines in detail one of the book's key themes, that of the potential shift in categorisation of disabled people. It states that the proposed review of the Disability Living Allowance currently represents a real threat to the legitimacy of disabled people within society as they may be reclassified as able to work, thus challenging their very identity as disabled. The subsequent stigma attached to welfare is also discussed with sensitivity. Chapter 6 explores new policy paradigms and in particular how personalisation, individualism and collectivism are shaping the lives of disabled people, for example the direct payments scheme not having the attached stigma of traditional welfare transfers. This chapter, as with all, gives an important historical context to policy drivers, in this case the partial roots of personalisation in Person Centred Planning some ten years ago. Roulstone and Prideaux take the opportunity to highlight the uncritical use of terms such as choice, control and self-direction. In particular, they contest the assumption that the demise of collective services for disabled people is unproblematic. They draw on the significant example of some disabled people's loss of community and sense of purpose through the closure of day centre services.
Chapter 7 looks to older disabled people and policy, exploring assumptions around impairment being inevitable in old age and the risk of medical and social neglect for this group. Chapter 8 examines the effects of non-disability targeted policy on disabled people, including those aimed at poverty, worklessness and social class. Chapter 9 is of particular use to social work and other students as it impressively unpacks the current benefit system which has moved recently to put disabled people under the searchlight of legitimacy. The final chapter 10 examines the relatively new Conservative−Liberal Coalition drivers and therefore again it makes a highly useful contribution.
This is both a timely and engaging book which highlights the historical lack of involvement of disabled people in the planning of policy. As mentioned earlier, the ongoing paradox that exists of disabled people's increased freedoms being counterbalanced by reductions in public services is vital. Roulstone and Prideaux write on this subject: ‘While many disabled people benefit from good protection and from some self direction, many are being pushed out of the disability category. The same government that once deemed them disabled is now redefining them as able to enter paid work or as ineligible for disability benefits’ (p. 181). We wait with apprehension to see what the knock on effect of this may be in terms of increased poverty and disablist hate crime.
The book critically examines with comprehensive evidence the so-called ‘problem’ of disability by engaging with the social model of disability, giving a well-balanced argument located between social policy and disability studies discourses. Roulstone and Prideaux have produced here an essential read for those from social work, disability studies and all policy backgrounds.
