Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T00:20:28.123Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Oblique-mode breakdown of the vertical buoyancy layer

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 December 2022

K.R. Maryada*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Auckland, Auckland 1010, New Zealand
S.W. Armfield
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace, Mechanical and Mechatronic Engineering, The University of Sydney, New South Wales 2006, Australia
P. Dhopade
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Auckland, Auckland 1010, New Zealand
S.E. Norris
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Auckland, Auckland 1010, New Zealand
*
†Email address for correspondence: kmar699@aucklanduni.ac.nz

Abstract

The O-type transition caused by a pair of small-amplitude oblique waves in a vertical buoyancy layer of a fluid with Prandtl number $0.71$ at a Reynolds number of $200$ is investigated using linear stability analysis and three-dimensional direct numerical simulation. The small-amplitude oblique waves experience linear growth and undergo nonlinear interactions to generate streamwise vortices/streaks, two-dimensional streamwise waves and harmonic oblique waves. The streamwise vortices/streaks and two-dimensional streamwise waves have twice the spanwise or streamwise wavenumber of the original perturbation, respectively. Unlike the O-type transition in isothermal flat-plate incompressible and compressible boundary layers where streaks dominate the transition, in the vertical buoyancy layer, either streaks or two-dimensional streamwise waves can dominate the flow field during the early stages of oblique transition. The growth rates of streaks and two-dimensional waves are dependent on the wavenumber of the initial oblique waves. Streaks dominate the flow for high streamwise wavenumbers, while two-dimensional streamwise waves dominate the flow for low streamwise wavenumbers. Analysis of the turbulent kinetic energy production and the Reynolds stresses reveals that the early stages of the transition differ depending on the wavenumber of the oblique waves. An increase in the initial amplitude of the oblique waves causes a faster transition from laminar flow; however, the growth rates of the streaks and two-dimensional streamwise waves are independent of the initial amplitude. Even though different modes are dominant during the early stages of the O-type transition, the onset of chaotic flow is caused by the breakdown of streak modes.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Illustration of the problem investigated in the current study. The red and blue isosurfaces represent a pair of symmetric oblique wave perturbations. The thick black curve represents the streamwise velocity profile of the laminar base flow. Here, $x_1, x_2$ and $x_3$ are the wall-normal, streamwise and spanwise axes, respectively. The fluid flows upwards, and the acceleration due to gravity $g$ is acting downwards.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic representation of the laminar vertical buoyancy layer showing the coordinate system and the boundary conditions. The region between the linearly heated wall ($x_1 = 0$), and the vertical dashed red line is the inner layer and the region between the vertical dashed red line and $x_1 = \infty$ is the outer layer.

Figure 2

Table 1.Simulation settings for DNS of oblique transition scenarios reported in the paper.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Marginal stability curves for the vertical buoyancy layer at $Re = 200$. (a) Contours of constant growth rate $\phi$; (b) contours of constant phase speed $c$; (c) contours of constant frequency $\omega$. The thick black curves represent the marginal stability curve.

Figure 4

Table 2.Growth rates predicted by linear stability analysis and growth rates observed in DNS during the early stages of transition for different combinations of $\alpha$ and $\beta$ at $Re = 200$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.(a) Mean streamwise velocity profile $\overline {u_2}$ and (b) mean buoyancy field profile $\bar {\vartheta }$ during the transition process for $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Wall behaviour when streamwise vortices and streaks dominate early transition. (a) Average wall shear stress and (b) average wall heat flux during the transition for $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves. The shaded regions represent the transition phase.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Amplitudes of the oblique waves and the first level of nonlinearly generated modes for $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique wave transition. Solid lines correspond to the amplitudes obtained from DNS. Thin dashed lines correspond to the amplitudes predicted by the nonlinear growth rate model (NM). Thick dot-dashed lines correspond to the amplitudes predicted by linear stability analysis (LSA). Only the modes observed in the streamwise velocity field at $x_1 = 0.785$ are shown.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Temporal development of $u_2$ and $\vartheta$ disturbance amplitude for different wavenumbers at a wall-normal distance $x_1 = 0.785$; $(1,1) = (0.4,\pm 0.4)$ and the rest are multiples of $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$. Thick solid black, red and blue solid lines represent the $u_2$ disturbance; thin dot-dashed black, green and magenta lines represent the $\vartheta$ disturbance.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Flow field at $t = 1600$ when perturbed by $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves. (a) Streamwise velocity field and (b) buoyancy field at $x_1 = 4.5$; (c) streamwise velocity field and (d) buoyancy field at $x_1 = 0.785$; (e) streamwise velocity field and (f) buoyancy field at $x_1 = 0.28$. Note that the contour magnitude is different in the figures.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Mean spanwise velocity at different times during the transition initiated by $(0.4,\pm 0.4$) oblique waves. The spanwise velocity field averaged along the entire streamwise length of the domain across an $x_1$–$x_3$ plane is represented using $\widetilde {u_3}$; (a) $t = 1600$, (b) $t = 1700$, (c) $t = 1800$, (d) $t = 1900$.

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a) Mean streamwise velocity profile $\overline {u_2}$ and (b) mean buoyancy field profile $\bar {\vartheta }$ during the transition phase for $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Wall behaviour when two-dimensional waves dominate the flow. (a) Average wall shear stress and (b) average wall heat flux during the transition process for $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves. The shaded regions represent the transition phase.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Amplitudes of the oblique waves and the first level of nonlinearly generated modes for $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique wave transition. Solid lines correspond to the amplitudes obtained from DNS. Thin dashed lines correspond to the amplitudes predicted by the nonlinear growth rate model (NM). Thick dot-dashed lines correspond to the amplitudes predicted by linear stability analysis (LSA). Only the modes observed in the streamwise velocity field at $x_1 = 0.785$ are shown.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Temporal development of $u_2$ and $\vartheta$ disturbance amplitude for different wavenumbers at a wall-normal distance $x_1 = 0.785$ at $t = 1413$. Here, $(1,1) = (0.2,\pm 0.4)$ and the rest are multiples of $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$. Thick solid black, red and blue solid lines represent the $u_2$ disturbance; thin dot-dashed black, green and magenta lines represent the $\vartheta$ disturbance.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Flow field at $t = 1413.6$ when perturbed by $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves. (a) Streamwise velocity field; (b) buoyancy field at $x_1 = 0.785$; (c) streamwise velocity field (d) buoyancy field at $x_1 = 0.28$. Two-dimensional waves are present close to the wall and away from the wall. Note that the contour magnitude is different in the figures.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Mean spanwise velocity at different times during the transition initiated by $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves showing the presence of a longitudinal vortex system. The spanwise velocity field averaged along the entire streamwise length of the domain across an $x_1$–$x_3$ plane is represented using $\widetilde {u_3}$; (a) $t = 1800$, (b) $t = 2000$, (c) $t = 2200$, (d) $t = 2400$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Variation of TKE and $\langle \hat {\vartheta }\hat {\vartheta } \rangle$ during O-type transition: (a) TKE $1/2 \langle \widehat {u_i}\widehat {u_i}\rangle$ and (b) buoyancy variance $\langle \hat {\vartheta }\hat {\vartheta } \rangle$ during the transition process for $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$. (c) The TKE $1/2 \langle \widehat {u_i}\widehat {u_i}\rangle$ and (d) buoyancy variance $\langle \hat {\vartheta }\hat {\vartheta } \rangle$ during the transition process for $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$.

Figure 18

Figure 17.The TKE production during O-type transition. (a) Shear production and (b) buoyancy production during the transition initiated by $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves. (c) Shear production and (d) buoyancy production during the transition initiated by $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Integral Reynolds stresses during the transition initiated by (a) $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves and (b) $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Growth rates of oblique waves and the first level of nonlinearly generated modes during the early stages of transition for different initial amplitudes of oblique waves: (a) $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves; $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 21

Figure 20.(a) Values of $t_N$, $t_T$ and $t_D$ when $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves cause a transition; (b) $t_N$, $t_T$, $t_D$, $t_{N2}$ and $t_{D2}$ when $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves cause a transition. Amplitude $A = 10^{-3}$. Note that the average wall shear stress $\tau _w$ shown here is the same as figures 5(a) and 11(a).

Figure 22

Figure 21.(a) Time when nonlinear effects start to become dominant $(t_N)$, (b) time when transition occurs $(t_T)$ and (c) time taken from when nonlinear effects start to dominate to transition ($T_D$).

Figure 23

Figure 22.Values of $t_{N_2}$ and $t_{D2}$ during transition dominated by $(0.2,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Temporal development of $u_2$ and $\vartheta$ disturbance amplitude for different wavenumbers at a wall-normal distance $x_1 = 0.785$. Here, $(1,1) = (0.3,\pm 0.3)$ and the rest are multiples of $(0.3,\pm 0.3)$. Thick solid black, red and blue solid lines represent the $u_2$ disturbance; thin dot-dashed black, green and magenta lines represent the $\vartheta$ disturbance.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Streamwise velocity at $x_1 = 0.785$ when perturbed by $(0.3,\pm 0.3)$ oblique waves. Note that the contour magnitude is different in the figures; (a) $t = 1400$, (b) $t = 1750$.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Wall behaviour observed in two domains (D1 and D2) with different wall-normal domain sizes. (a) Average wall shear stress and (b) average wall heat flux during the transition process for $(0.4,\pm 0.4)$ oblique waves.

Figure 27

Table 3.Growth rates $\phi$ of the initial oblique waves and the nonlinear modes observed in DNS while using D1 and D2 domains.

Figure 28

Figure 26.Phase-space plot of the Oblique-mode breakdown in the vertical buoyancy layer at $Re = 200$. Black circles and grey squares correspond to the parameter values investigated in the current study. A black circle represents a parameter combination where transition was observed. A grey square represents a parameter combination where transition was not observed. Thick black curve represents the neutral curve.