The Science of Wealth: Adam Smith and the framing of political economy is divided into four chapters (The science of wealth; Competition, prices and distribution; Production and capital accumulation; Opulence and policy) plus an introduction and an epilogue.
Aspromourgos opens the preface of the book by citing Yen Fu, the first translator of The Wealth of Nations into Chinese: “When I read the text, in some places it is so moving that I cannot keep from crying. Alas! How touching Smith’s sentences are!” Aspromourgos comments, “I could say that Smith’s words have almost moved me to tears at times too, but perhaps for different reasons” (p. xvi). Reading through his book, one can see why. It was written by an economist for economists, and at the same time it was written by an historian of economics for historians of economics. It contains an excruciatingly detailed analysis of Smith’s system of political economy, as well as its intellectual origins, with both their correct parts and their mistakes.
Aspromourgos manages to handle multiple difficult tasks at the same time. He presents his analysis of Smith in its historical and cultural context, in relation to modern analysis, and also as part of a very long intellectual history. Aspromourgos takes a relevant concept in Smith—say, price or wealth or capital—and looks at how Smith understands it, at the differences from and similarities to today’s understanding, and at how the concept was understood in the time before Smith. The analysis that Aspromourgos offers is detailed and documented in every aspect. For example, he generally counts and lists the number of times Smith uses a word, but he does not limit himself to a word count. Aspromourgos reads and explains the context in which the words are used, and reads and explains that context well, untangling all the different meanings that a word or a concept may have. He then analyzes the development of the same concept from the very origins of the term to today’s usage. Aspromourgos does not shy away from using contemporary tools and language to explain, elegantly and respectfully, what Smith is trying to say. Smith is not modernized here. Rather, modern tools and language explain Smith, often in a clearer way than Smith himself was able to do. Additionally, Aspromourgos zooms in and out from small details to big picture, moving his analysis from, for example, net revenue to the idea of nature in Smith. The very rich footnote discussion allows Aspromourgos to maintain a smooth flow in the text without compromising his scholarship. To the contrary, the footnotes and the bibliography are a precious resource for any Smith scholar.
The picture of Smith that emerges from Aspromourgos’s book is of a man who is the product of his era. Smith is not a marginalist in any way, according to Aspromourgos’ account. His technical economics is therefore painfully different from ours. Aspromourgos notes the irony that the father of the discipline famous for supply and demand and price adjustment does not use the words “supply and demand,” nor the idea of price adjustment, relying instead on supply adjustment to a fixed demand and bargaining to determine prices. Smith is presented as regarding political economy as a separable, but not thereby autonomous, science, an idea which eventually made political economy an autonomous science. Smith is also presented as an acute observer (although one who nevertheless makes mistakes), capable of looking at the big picture. So big indeed is Smith’s picture that it requires the analysis of not just The Wealth of Nations but also Theory of Moral Sentiments, his Lectures on Jurisprudence, History of Astronomy, and all his other unpublished works and correspondence. Aspromourgos brings the whole corpus of Smith’s work together, forming a coherent system. Smith’s system is generally believed to work quite well by itself, even if imperfectly and with some occasional help from policy makers. Adam Smith is considered both a theorist and a pragmatist, unwilling to apply theories without regard to their context and unwilling to dispense with theory to look exclusively at temporary contingencies.
I believe this book will be valued by all Smith and eighteenth-century scholars for its vast scholarship, depth, breadth, and clarity, even though non-economist scholars may find the central part of the volume challenging because of its technical content.
