This book offers a legal discussion of the rise of resilience in the recent years as a framework to prevent and respond to disasters. The editors, Alexia Herwig and Marta Simoncini (two legal scholars), argue that resilience challenges the well-established notion of risk management since the latter, relying on risk analysis and cost-benefit analysis, is not well suited for low probability, high consequence events, that are becoming more and more frequent. Hence, the need for another approach, such as the one advanced by the notion of resilience, that would account for the interrelations between ecological, economic, social and political systems and the ways in which they produce risks and amplify disasters. The analysis is moving from the narrowly-defined risk factors to examining their interactions with their environment, which eventually aims at improving prevention and the ability to overcome shocks. The authors rightly point out that resilience, now widely used in policy-making, is “in need of legal framing” (p 2) since it relies on less strong evidence (being new and fuzzily defined), and risks excesses (“danger of arbitrariness and curtailments of individual rights” – although one may note that this was already said about risk management long ago). Legal framing, in the authors’ view, means providing sound argument and guiding principles on which to ground political and legal decisions related to resilience (since there is no evidence yet). This would strengthen resilience policies by reducing the risk of court cases and challenges to decisions.
The editors therefore propose to structure the concept of resilience from a legal perspective – a challenge for such a multi-disciplinary concept, but a relevant one, since resilience has so far been more discussed in ecology, geography or sociology. This requires answering the following questions: How can law, a rigid tool in essence, be flexible enough to regulate complex, interdependent and adaptative systems? How to enable the development of “reflexive regulation” able to continuously self-reflect on the consequences of political interventions and the risks manufactured by social systems? These are important questions, relevant for the creation of resilient systems, although not easy ones to answer. On the one hand, law can provide a legal basis to resilience (a fuzzy concept so far) and promotes further its enforcement through behaviour modification and regulatory standards (“enabling and controlling tools”). On the other hand, law may lack the flexibility called for by the concept of resilience and its advocates, as it can never fully adapt to actual disasters, or optimise concerns in light of future uncertain events.
Resilience is defined by the editors “as a process through which legal orders aim at absorbing and minimising the impact of risks of potential catastrophic impact” (p 15). The book is organised around the disaster cycle: preparedness (risk assessment), prevention (risk regulation), response (relief) and recovery. A first remark is that preparedness does not equate to risk assessment, any more than prevention may be reduced to regulation (prevention might include regulation, mitigation, risk reduction). In addition, adopting this linear understanding of disaster is problematic since resilience, rather than focusing on events, centres on the adaptability and resistance of systems. From this point of view, the book is likely to fail to provide an understanding of how law might tackle the properties and complexity of a resilient system rather than the specific risks for which responsibilities, duties and rights can be more easily defined. Nevertheless, the advantage of such perspective is to render legal activities clearly defined, and eventually able to provide structure to resilience.
Although the book is framed around law, it comprises chapters from different disciplines: law, geography, political science, practitioners, and will be of interest outside legal academia. It focuses mainly on Europe and international law. Although the multi-disciplinary perspective sheds light on the concept of resilience, and in particular its political and environmental dimensions, it does not help provide a coherent legal understanding of resilience. As pointed out in the conclusion of the book, the authors work with different understandings of resilience, shaped by their own disciplines. In addition, the use of concepts is sometimes fuzzy. Resilience, prevention, mitigation, vulnerability tend to be used interchangeably, whereas each term refers to various strategies, instruments, and understanding of what is to be done. For example, in the disaster literature, vulnerability is understood as incorporating inequalities and fragilities, whereas resilience refers to the ability of systems to absorb shocks, and is often associated with neoliberal governance. Each concept understood that way would have very different legal implications: how can law protect individuals who are more likely to lose their livings or their life in case of an adverse event versus how can law be flexible enough to enable systems to prevent and resist any shocks. A more detailed discussion of these various concepts and their legal implications would have taken the book to another level.
Furthermore, not all authors really work with the concept of resilience, but rather build on their own research, whether it be tort law, government insurance, multi-risk analysis, hazardous industries, smart cities. Most of these issues constitute interesting and relevant aspects of resilience, but these chapters either do not really tackle the legal dimension, or do not make it clear if resilience is more than new wine in old bottles. Some chapters are too general and little connected to the topic; in particular the one on Fukushima (by Downer), which focuses on how narratives obfuscated the consequences of the disaster, whereas there would have been a lot to say on the (non) resilience of the nuclear system at the moment of the incident, and subsequent legal responsibilities. Chapters are not always well articulated to the book project, and between themselves. For example, it is not clear what the (critical) chapter by Joseph on resilience as a tool imposing good governance and contributing to redefine EU’s global power – interesting per se, even if the idea that resilience is specific to EU modes of governance might be disputed – brings to the discussion at the heart of the book; in addition, its analysis is fundamentally divergent with the following chapter (by a practitioner) that consists of an apology of resilience in the US disaster policy. All in all, the chapters gathered are patchy and unfortunately do not sufficiently deal with the promising and stimulating questions raised in the introduction.
The most interesting chapters are those that work with a precise understanding of resilience and law. In particular, the chapter on international quasi-judicial bodies (by Ambrus) explores well the tension between the need for adaptability and legal certainty, and attempts to define the characteristics of a resilience regulation regime: flexible, holistic, preventative, and with forward-looking approach – a challenge since these bodies normally deal with past events and torts. The authors provide interesting empirical cases, even if the reader might be surprised to discover that the World Bank’s practices are resilient: it might have adopted the resilience discourse, but many scholars have pointed out that its large scale projects lead to displacement and social inequality – which again raises the question of what is exactly understood by resilience and from which point of view.
Some chapters adopt a theoretical, normative view on resilience, which might help structure the concept but at the risk of being disconnected from political issues that constrain resilience. Notably, the chapter on resilience in the EU (Simoncini) offers an attempt to characterise how public law in Europe deals with disasters and how it might enhance resilience. The analysis is detailed and stimulating, but such generalisation remains problematic since there exists no comprehensive strategy to deal with disasters in the EU, only very different types of regulations. For example, the existence of EU infringement procedures is only relevant for chemical accidents, not for general civil protection activities that remain a Member State competence. The solidarity clause inscribed in the Treaty on the EU cannot be general because of the subsidiarity principle and varying modes of regulation: stringent regulations facilitate cooperation, while guidelines do not. The author rightly argues that subsidiarity is at the heart of resilience, which is coherent since resilience focuses on local adaptation and autonomous cooperation, but that raises the question of a more stringent role for EU law to tackle Member States’ free-rider behaviour and enforce prevention.
The chapter by Herwig on the Sendai framework for disaster reduction and climate change provides a detailed discussion of how law might enhance resilience and how national and international systems might support each other in achieving this goal. The focus of the chapter is surprising, since the Sendai framework is distinct from the IPCC and the COP on climate change; hence, it is not meant to deal with climate change. It is a relevant question whether “silo-ing” disasters into two different sets of international norms constitutes an efficient strategy. Nevertheless, as long as they exist, they constitute different frameworks, with various degree of political and legal implications that cannot be equated (Sendai is a framework, whereas climate change is regulated by binding agreements). Herwig rightly points out that the Sendai framework cannot achieve its aims since it fails to take into account the global drivers of disaster vulnerability. However, negating the role of states is problematic given that states systematically rejected international binding treaties on disasters, and therefore remain the prime responders to disasters; also, there are specific drivers of vulnerability at national level that states are responsible for. To come back to an earlier point, it is exactly on those kinds of issues that a debate about law and resilience should be conducted: how would it be possible to articulate various legal regimes, at different scales, and take into account the various aspects of resilience (risk, vulnerability, mitigation, prevention, etc)?
In conclusion, this edited volume opens up important and relevant questions on resilience and law, and the extent to which resilience replaces or transforms risk regulation – as clearly put by the editors in the introduction. Each chapter only provides relevant insights and partial answers to these questions, and after closing the book, the reader is left with a sense that there is still a lot to say on this topic.
