The year 2008 was a productive one for the study of the Roman Republican army, especially in the Spanish provinciae, for it saw not only the appearance of the book by François Cadiou reviewed here but also Michael Dobson's The Army of the Roman Republic: the Second Century BC, Polybius and the Camps at Numantia, Spain. Both are based on doctoral theses (respectively of the University of Rennes in 2001 and the University of Exeter in 1996) and both respond critically to the fundamental archaeological work of Adolph Schulten, most notably at Numantia, undertaken in the first quarter of the twentieth century. That apart, the two books are very different. Dobson's approach is primarily as an archaeologist and an historian of archaeology, using Polybius’ account of the Roman camp as a comparator, while C. focuses his attention on the literary sources, deploying archaeological evidence where required by his argument. As is to be expected in a revised and expanded version of a French thèse, that argument is expounded at length, and is central to the whole book.
C. begins by noting the place which has traditionally been given to the role of the Spanish wars in the history of the armies of the mid- and late Republican army. The distance from Italy, the continuity of the warfare, and the problems with terrain and the nature of the enemy have all been invoked to explain the peculiarities of the Roman experience in the Iberian peninsula and the need for adaptations which allegedly resulted. C. will have none of this, or at least believes that the picture has been drawn far too starkly to show a discrepancy between what happened in Spain and elsewhere. With a combination of the subtlety of argumentation familiar from the earlier work of his supervisor at Rennes, Patrick Le Roux (who has provided a typically elegant preface to this book), and a determinedly minimalist approach to the interpretation of the literary sources more often found in anglo-saxon historians, he works through the evidence of the army's involvement under three heads, providing the focus for the three sections of his book: armies at war; armies and territories; and armies and the provinces.
In his first section C. makes the point that the Roman wars were not, as sometimes presented, a continuous conquest of the peninsula over two centuries but a series of unconnected campaigns against a succession of enemies who, though different from those the Romans confronted in the eastern Mediterranean, were to a large extent based on urban settlements of various sorts. Although the distance between Italy and the Spanish provinces precluded the return of armies every year, the regular sending of supplementa of troops for which Livy gives evidence in the early second century suggests that excessive periods of service by Roman and Italian soldiery were not frequent and the form of fighting described in the sources indicates that the pattern of warfare employed by indigenous armies was based on ordered battles rather than the guerrilla tactics imagined by many modern writers. Indeed C. goes so far as to suggest that, insofar as guerrilla warfare appears at all in our sources, it may have been introduced into Spain by Sertorius in the 70s B.C. (221–7). In the matter of armament, he argues that the short sword (despite the name gladius hispaniensis) was a development already in process in the late third century and that in terms of military formation the cohort was gradually introduced through the second century in parallel with the manipular formation and owed little if anything to conditions in Spain. In the second section, he argues that the Romans did not develop a systematic coverage of territory with garrisons and that the praesidia mentioned in literary accounts are temporary establishments, designed to watch or protect positions and routes of importance for particular campaigns. He is also sceptical of either the upper town of Tarraco (Tarragona) or the area which became the Roman forum at Emporiae (Empúries) being originally substantial military encampments, preferring to assume that when during the second century commanders moved back to such places, the troops encamped further away from the urban settlements. On several of these specific points there is room for debate (Dobson, for instance, believes that the camps at Numantia show a change from a manipular to a cohort-based structure to the army in the late 130s, op. cit., 407–14), but the essential argument, that the Roman armies of the late third and second centuries in Spain, and down to the period of the Civil Wars in the 40s, were engaged in continuous but ad hoc military activity rather than the establishment of an army of occupation is well made.
The third section of the book, on the effects of the army on the development of the provinces, raises more difficulties. C. argues that the supplies for the troops, foodstuffs and other equipment, came mostly from Italy, but that grain in particular was sometimes shipped from other provinces and also gathered locally. This may be the case; but his insistence that the stipendium for the basic pay of the soldiers was invariably brought from Italy is much more problematic. Although it is clear, as C. points out, that it was normal for the stipendium to be sent from Rome through the early part of the second century, it does appear that on some occasions a returning commander might claim credit from the Senate for not needing to draw on such funds (thus Q. Fulvius Flaccus in 180 B.C., Livy 40.35.4); and in the early years of the second half of the second century, when the stipendium was paid in silver denarii, there is a remarkable lack of such coins from sites is Spain. The most probable reason for this is that the stipendium was being paid with the silver coins, minted on the denarius standard, which were being produced at this time by indigenous communities (see M. H. Crawford, Coinage and Money under the Roman Republic (1985), 95–102). C.'s insistence that only Roman coins brought from Italy would adequately fulfil the symbolic needs of the stipendium seems unnecessarily dogmatic.
