Over the span of about 15 years (1980–1995), rap records were first excluded from radio, fought their way onto the airwaves, reached cultural dominance, and were subsequently ghettoized on the radio because of their undeniable popularity. The saga of rap on the radio is the topic of Amy Coddington’s insightful and primary-source-rich new book, How Hip Hop Became Hit Pop: Radio, Rap, and Race. Coddington focuses not on artists and insiders, but on the main medium through which many listeners across the United States interacted (or did not interact) with rap in the 1980s and 1990s: commercial radio.Footnote 1 Foregrounding the voices and decisions of radio programmers, and the ramifications of those decisions, Coddington shows how rap came to be played on stations aimed at mainstream audiences and how “this exposure had profound consequences for the genre and the radio industry” (2). It’s a story, Coddington explains, about sounds, but also about money and structural racial prejudice. The commercial radio business model demanded a relentless urgency from radio staffers to serve up profitable audiences to advertisers—the very advertisers who only paid half rates to Black-oriented stations as compared to white or Crossover stations (2). In support of her argument, Coddington processes and summarizes a huge number of primary sources, chiefly reporting found in music industry magazines from the 1980s and early 1990s such as Radio & Records and Billboard, and her interpretations reflect her impressive control of the industry discourse during this time.
In Chapter 1, Coddington describes how rap was considered “too Black” to play even on Black-oriented radio stations in the first half of the 1980s.Footnote 2 Black-oriented radio stations were pressured to deliver affluent audiences to advertisers. Black artists were pressured to follow the example of Lionel Ritchie, Michael Jackson, and Prince to produce records that crossed traditional genre boundaries and widened their audience base. This formula avoided rap and other styles coded as Black in favor of ballads and other pop styles. To pursue a more favorable revenue situation with advertisers, some Black-oriented stations rebranded themselves using the more race-neutral term “Urban,” or “Urban Contemporary.” In this chapter, Coddington makes starkly clear the extent to which advertisers drove the choices made by radio programmers. Rap was seen as too young and too low class to warrant attention. In other words, “rap’s audiences weren’t valuable” (30). By the mid-1980s, rap still had a scant presence on radio, and had been largely rejected by Black-oriented formats.
Chapter 2 describes the development of a new Crossover format, which opened a place for rap on the radio.Footnote 3 In 1986, the radio station Power 106 in Los Angeles burst on the scene with a new format which targeted a multiracial audience: Black, white, and Hispanic listeners. It quickly became the number one station in Los Angeles and led to an avalanche of similar stations across the country, eventually named Crossover for their multi-ethnic audience and for their ability to launch records into the Top 40. Notably, Crossover stations were white-owned and largely featured white DJs, which allowed the stations access to higher advertising rates. And as Black-oriented stations continued to resist playing rap, the result was a further decrease of Black influence in the radio industry, and on the trajectory of rap, specifically. “Rap,” Coddington writes, “at least on the radio, was out of the hands of Black consumers, Black-music-focused record labels, and Black DJs, and was now controlled and consumed by white corporations eager for profits and a multiracial population eager for new sounds” (61).
By 1990, the landscape had changed. In Chapter 3, Coddington chronicles three strands of rap’s development. The first strand included rappers who produced singles that bent their styles to be more appealing to white, adult, female audiences—in other words, to be more “pop.” The second strand was the rise of New Jack Swing, a genre which seemed to combine R&B with the edginess of hip hop. Enter the third strand of rap, consisting of rappers who “disavow[ed] rap’s popification” (87), and who sparked a durable debate over “realness” in rap. In this chapter, Coddington captures the industry triumph of rap in the early 1990s. She paints a picture of rap’s cultural omnipresence—from Fresh Prince to MC Hammer to Vanilla Ice and beyond—while also delineating the nature of radio’s sonic and commercial influence on the genre.
In Chapter 4, Coddington describes the rise of fear-based reactions to rap’s success, and the subsequent demise of the Top 40 as a monolithic format. As listeners of some stations expressed their dislike of rap, radio programmers tried multiple strategies to recapture their audiences’ attention. The short-lived “Rock 40” format promised a space free from “disco” sounds (rap and other Black-influenced records). As Coddington points out, the shift from playing all the hits—no matter the style—to playing a subset geared toward a desired audience eroded the diverse, coalition audience that had been a unique and powerful feature of the format. The Top 40 subformat frenzy was not only racially motivated; advertising revenue also played a key role. Radio consultants armed with reams of data on listener preferences promised access to ever more precise audiences to serve up to advertisers. Predictive modeling, narrowcasting, and the rising popularity of Country and Adult Contemporary formats spelled the end of the Top 40 format as it had operated up through 1985. Listeners were ultimately harmed, Coddington argues. In the scramble to sequester rap, radio programmers closed their listener’s minds and ears to diverse musics.
The conclusion explores developments in music listening and consumption since 1995. The radio business changed when the Telecommunications Act of 1996 led to the consolidation of radio stations into the hands of a few media conglomerates like Clear Channel. Although Napster and subsequent disruptions in digital media didn’t hit the radio industry as hard or as quickly as they did the record industry, streaming platforms have steadily eaten away at the power of radio stations to capture listeners and deliver them to advertisers. As Coddington points out, streaming platforms like Spotify have combined the traditional roles of radio: new music discovery and delivering listeners to advertisers with a precision and reaction time unimaginable to radio consultants of the mid-1990s. In the end, Coddington sees these developments as hurting marginalized communities: “even as artists continue prompting us to address systematic inequality, listening to these songs in our contemporary world participates in the very economy which has long contributed to social and economic marginalization” (132).
Because Coddington’s argument relies so heavily on primary sources from Billboard and Radio & Records, more discussion about the conflicts of interest and biases of those magazines would have helped put the industry reporting in context. In the book’s introduction, Coddington describes the unreliable and biased nature of industry reporting. Nevertheless, I found myself wanting to read her takes on specific conflicts of interest throughout the narrative. What, for example, were the advertising revenues and considerations in these magazines? What audience were they trying to serve up to their own advertisers? Or what does Coddington make of Radio & Records’ introduction of their own targeted, data-driven custom playlist for stations, when their reporting was often critical of other consultants offering the same service (discussed in Chapter 4)? How did this conflict affect their reporting? Some of these lines of inquiry may rightly have been left on the cutting-room floor, but including them might have helped the reader better understand how Coddington approached source criticism in her argument.
Coddington’s book is a significant contribution to rap historiography, especially from an industry context. Although it is aimed primarily at a scholarly audience, How Hip Hop Became Hit Pop is written in an accessible style that is appropriate for undergraduates, and certainly will be of interest to hip hop fans of all types. To this point, it is worth noting that How Hip Hop Became Hit Pop is available as a free eBook from www.luminosoa.org. The fragmentation and segregation of rap and Top 40 radio in the 1980s and 1990s did not just happen. It was fragmented and segregated by people—people driven by fear, selfishness, and ultimately, advertising revenue. With the benefit of hindsight, the current dominance of rap might seem like an inevitability. As Coddington has shown, however, rap traversed the rough road of radio on its way to becoming a pop phenomenon.
Dr. Mark C. Samples is Professor of Music and Coordinator of Music History at Central Washington University. His current research examines how practices of promotion such as marketing, branding, and PR have influenced musical behavior since 1850. His forthcoming book project, Sway: How Marketing and Promotion have Shaped American Music, is under contract with the University of Michigan Press’s Tracking Pop series.
