For over two decades now, Mohammad Ali Amir-Moezzi has produced a number of short studies that have challenged us with a radically different picture of Twelver Shiʿi Islam. Past scholarship tended to portray the Twelvers as an oppositional, alternative spiritual movement rooted in an esoteric vision of reality in which the everlasting countenance of God, the Imam, is present. Amir-Moezzi, however, has forced us to reconsider how we analyze the contestations of Islam in the classical period. The present book under review represents the second collection of his articles. Unlike the first collection, which was more thematic constituting a series of studies on the Twelver doctrine of the Imam (imamology), this one introduces us to his readings of five classical Shi‘i texts that exemplify the nature of this esoteric tradition. Crucially, as before, the author develops an argument about the very method by which we ought to study the history of Islam as it evolved from early conflicts through the redaction and canonization of Muslim scriptures, both the Qurʾan and the hadith. He argues that the emergent “orthodox” picture of early Islam that became the Sunni tradition is rather partial and too “neat” a description of how revelations were received. That tradition held that the Qur'an we have today was redacted by a committee during the caliphate of ʿUthmān, and it considered all the companions of the Prophet to possess probity and respectability and to be beyond reproach. The Sunni tradition also posited the authority of the community led by the caliphs against the authority of the family of the Prophet. Both of these key positions in the formation of the Sunni tradition (under the pretense that it was also the “Islamic” tradition), ought to be rejected, Amir-Moezzi argues, if we take the early Shiʿi texts seriously. This is primarily because these texts categorically affirm the falsification of the revelation by the “orthodox” caliphs and point out the shortcomings of such a romantic vision of a concordant early generation. He further suggests that it is by focusing on the early controversies that we can understand the multiple interpretations among communities of believers that led to the different Islamic confessions.
The first text that Amir-Moezzi explores in support of these arguments is Kitāb Sulaym ibn Qays (also known as Kitāb al-Saqīfa), arguably at its core the earliest extant work of Shi‘i literature, and the subject of recent studies by Robert Gleave and the late Patricia Crone. This work demonstrates for the author the violence of what became the normative Muslim (read: Sunni, caliphal) history and the early articulation of a Shi‘i counterhistory that identifies the usurpation, injustice, and evil of a Sunni-minded history. Amir-Moezzi emphasizes the popularity of this counternarrative, briefly examines the debate on the reliability of its ascription, translates some key passages, and provides the full table of contents of the ninety-eight traditions given in the text. However, this critical endeavor is just an introduction. I would have liked to see further analysis of what this text reveals about the very notion of Shi‘i history, of the nature of transmission of texts, especially written transmission of which this is a prominent example, and what the reception history of this text tells us about issues such as the importance given to taqiyya (religious dissimulation) in different periods of history including today.
The second text is the Kitāb al-qirāʾāt or Kitāb al-tanzīl wa-l-taḥrīf of al-Sayyārī from the 3rd/9th century; this chapter is a version of the introduction to the edition produced by Amir-Moezzi and Etan Kohlberg. As the editors say in their introduction to the text, the history of prophecy is also one of the falsification of the prophetic message (45); once the scripture and the prophetic teachings were received, elements in the milieu of the prophet began the process of changing and falsifying the message. The author uses this text to show how exegesis can serve to reveal a history of this very process of falsification. However, it should also be noted that the arguments presented by revisionist scholars on the codification of the text that point towards the role of al-Ḥajjāj ibn Yūsuf and the Umayyad caliph ʿAbd al-Malik (as presented in the work of Alfred de Premare among others) is not quite that of the early Shi‘i accusations of falsification. The revisionists are not talking about an Ur-text that was later changed, but an “orthodox” text produced by a historical process that emerged from the sectarian milieu and conflicts of understanding, while the Shiʿi accusers insisted that there was a pristine revelation collected in a book (but that remained with ʿAlī) that was tampered by the caliphs. Some comment would also be pertinent on the relative obscurity of the text in Shiʿi scholarly circles (by comparison to the others discussed in this book). While the accusation that the caliphs had tampered with the text of the revelation was well known in the classical Shiʿi tradition, the particular exegetical work of al-Sayyārī was not well attested.
The third text is the (probably Zaydī) exegesis of al-Ḥibarī, again derived from the 3rd/9th century. Here Amir-Moezzi highlights the early necessity for a hermeneutics of the text so as to reveal the historical processes at work, such as the names of the Imams and their enemies, which are absent from the Qurʾan. Early leaders of the community themselves engaged in this hermeneutical process. To recall one early polemical exchange, the Qurʾan as text was itself not enough for the community of Muḥammad. One can see this process of reading in a number of the classical Shi‘i exegeses but once again one wonders about the actual importance of al-Ḥibarī for the scholarly tradition as a whole.
In the fourth text, Baṣāʾir al-darajāt of the 3rd/9th century Qummī tradition, al-Ṣaffār raises the key thematic issue of imamology: the gnosis of the Imam and the need for believers to recognize this quality as central to a leader's status. For al-Ṣaffār, like other early works from the Isma‘ili and what became the ʿAlawī-Nusayrī tradition, his collection shows how the early Shi‘i community was a gnostic one with a strong initatic tradition in which the community deliberately separated itself from the commonality and cleaved to the charismatic person of the Imam who explained the esoteric truth of the revelation. In fact the “anomalies,” as Amir-Moezzi puts it, in the text, may provide further evidence for this as only the initiated would be able to distinguish what is correctly transmitted from what is intended to deceive. But this does not seem so convincing. The author similarly does not discuss directly some of the recent scholarly and seminarian debates on the authenticity of the ascription of the text (raised, for example, by Hassan Ansari and Sayyid Kamāl al-Ḥaydarī).
The final chapter—co-authored with Hassan Ansari—addresses Abū Jaʿfar al-Kulaynī (d. 329/941), the fourth century traditionist, and represents the first major contribution in a European language on his import in the early exegesis of the Qur'an (there is already an extensive highly useful academic literature on him in Arabic and Persian). One sees the hand of Ansari in the historically sophisticated contextualization of the work in this chapter. The main point that the authors wish to present is that this first of the classical four books of the Shiʿi hadith tradition (al-Kāfī of al-Kulaynī, Man lā yaḥḍuruhu l-faqīh of al-Shaykh al-Ṣadūq, al-Istibṣār and Tahdhīb al-aḥkām of al-Ṭūsī) represents the sufficient source to establish Shi‘i Islam as an independent religious tradition. This point is again taken up in the epilogue, where Amir-Moezzi emphasizes that because those who had most vehemently opposed Muhammad became the guardians of imperial (Sunni) Islam, it was necessarily the case that the propaganda, censorship, and falsification of true Islam would have to be opposed by articulating an alternative vision of Shiʿi Islam, a religion which placed at its center the Imam as the countenance and revelation of the divine.
Amir-Moezzi's work fits within the broad efforts to rethink both the sources for the early period and the pivotal points of conflict amongst the evolving community of believers so as to show how the master narrative of Sunni historiography (then taken up by Orientalist scholarship) must be questioned and “decolonized.” While many might criticize whether the author deploys a sufficient hermeneutics of the texts he is examining, there is little doubt that those studying early Islam will profit from reading this work.
