In Gender and Violence in the Middle East, David Ghanim has written a structural rather than historical account of how gender oppression spurs the Middle East toward political violence, paranoia of the other, and authoritarianism. The book attempts to link the dynamics of family life to formal expressions of political authority and legitimacy, showing that socialization into an asymmetrical gender regime can have consequences for enduring political structures. Ghanim's main argument, which confirms orientalist views of the Middle East, is that authoritarianism and the ineptitude for democratic rule are the inevitable outcomes of pervasive gender inequalities. Gender conflict, Ghanim contends, has long characterized relations between men and women in the region and has led to persistent forms of domestic abuse including rape, underage marriage, genital mutilation, honor killings, corporal punishment, and sex segregation. The pervasive nature of this violence, in Ghanim's view, prepares the ground for political violence and the xenophobia displayed by the region's authoritarian regimes. As Ghanim puts it, “[a]n individual in Middle Eastern society is born in patriarchy and dies in authoritarianism” (p. 175). In this review, then, I aim to examine and critique the ways Ghanim constructs this deterministic view of life in the Middle East, exposing its polemical mode of argument and its leveling out of differences within the multiplicity of women's experiences.
Ghanim begins his discussion by citing a large number of survey studies conducted in Middle Eastern countries—Algeria, Bahrain, Lebanon, Libya, Pakistan, Palestine, Syria, Tunisia, Turkey, Qatar, and Yemen—to make his point that domestic violence is widespread in the region. The surveys taken together indicate that between 23 and 97 percent of women in these countries have been subject to direct physical or psychological abuse by family members (pp. 24–27). Ghanim also describes underage (younger than fifteen) minors being married to adults as well as into polygamous marriages in Turkey and Yemen (p. 28). We are told of unreported rape cases that are aggravated by forced marriages in the wake of rape and by the social confinement of rape victims. We are told of the commonplace nature of wife battering and the social value placed on a wife's obedience to her husband in Islam (pp. 173–78). Ghanim further reports genital mutilation in Egypt and Sudan (pp. 32–37) and honor killings in Jordan and the Palestinian territories (pp. 39–46). The stories of brutality are strung along one after another in gruesome detail throughout the approximately 250 pages of the book.
Given that such a broad range of studies with distinct methodologies, interview samples, and time frames point to incidents of violence, one cannot doubt that domestic violence exists in the Middle East as elsewhere. Yet it is far from clear that the causes of violence across this broad a range of contexts are the result of patriarchal attitudes with no relation to economic factors or historical antecedents. These decontexualized examples of violence are also problematic because the author gives little consideration to how they may be susceptible to the voyeurism of the reader. More worrisome, however, is Ghanim's contention that the cause of violence is cultural; violence is endemic throughout the Middle East, he asserts, because it is far more tolerated there than in other places. In arriving to this conclusion, Ghanim conflates patriarchy and violence as in the following quotation: “[t]he patriarchal construction of gender relationships is a process of dehumanization that creates violent social relationships between the sexes” (p. 73). Moreover, Ghanim counts a wide range of behaviors and mental states including “alienation and dehumanization” as examples of violence (p. 73). Alienation, Ghanim argues, is violence against the self.
In making the case that a culture of tolerance toward violence is to blame for the ills of the Middle East, Ghanim does not consider the multiple strands of women's experience across the lines of class, ethnicity, nation, and religious affiliation. There is also a tendency in the book to move from specific examples to global conclusions. Do Lila Abu-Lughod's ethnographic insights culled from fieldwork among Egyptian Bedouin tribes in the late 1970s hold true for all Egyptian women and, by extension, all Middle Eastern women? In addition to relying on these sorts of generalizations, Ghanim often uses fragments of a wider analysis—including Abu-Lughod's view that Bedouin women cannot achieve equal status with their male counterparts due to women's association with nature—as matters of fact.
Finally, Ghanim's book ignores a body of scholarship (e.g., the work of Margot Badran, Saba Mahmood, Samira Haj, Farha Ghannam, and Lara Deeb) that is both feminist and engaged with Islam. Notably absent are debates within Islam around women's roles and rights in marriage, divorce, and property inheritance or around modesty (hijab) versus equality in the public sphere. Ghanim instead prominently features the testimonies of Middle Eastern feminists well known in the United States and Europe such as Nawal El Saadawi and Fatima Mernissi, as well as lesser known figures such as Sana al-Khayyat, to produce a Western-oriented and antireligious narrative of gender oppression. Writing within the vein of feminist thought of the late 1970s and 1980s, these authors take distinct positions with regard to Western feminism and religion that do not necessarily constitute a uniform indictment of Islam.
One point in the life cycle where women in “traditional” Middle Eastern societies do gain power, according to Ghanim, is during menopause, when they take up their roles as mothers-in-law. During this period, he argues, women turn a structure of abuse on its head; former victims now become abusers of their daughters-in-law, compensating for their own bad marriages and manipulating the loyalties of their sons. In short, Ghanim sees the figure of the mother-in-law as one who remedies her victimized status by victimizing others, feeding the “cycle of violent gender relations where the aspiration of the victim is not to achieve justice but to further injustices that will benefit her” (p. 154). This is the basis for Ghanim's contention that women “share equal responsibility to men for violence” (p. 13). Such assertions, however, are again based on Ghanim's expansive view of “violence”—including verbal and psychological abuse (p. 13)—which leads him to the dubious conclusion that male violence is physical and direct while female violence is subtle and subversive (p. 15).
The book then shifts dramatically from detailing the conditions of violence within the domestic sphere—for example, a mother in-law's interference, the unrealistic expectations of those entering marriage, and the alienation of self and other through sex segregation—to the political realm. Domestic conflicts lay the groundwork for authoritarian forms of rule, Ghanim argues. Just as women are made inaccessible in sex-segregated societies, so do authoritarian structures operate by political exclusion: “[e]xclusion, segregation and veiling ha[ve] led to the negation of the other, and a lack of diversity in society” (p. 199). For this reason, he contends, it is putatively easy for authoritarian regimes to fixate on outside enemies, manipulating the Palestinian question or playing up confrontations with the West (p. 184). If one is accustomed to policing women in society and finds it natural, Ghanim maintains, how will one rebuke an authoritarian regime for policing its citizenry (p. 203)? Just as suspicion and guilt surround women's actions, so too do they permeate authoritarian regimes and their treatment of political subjects (p. 204). In short, Ghanim blames authoritarian rule in the Middle East and the culture of fear that it cultivates on distorted gender dynamics. He quotes the turn of the century Egyptian juror Qasim Amin, often credited with originating the women's movement in Egypt, as saying that a Muslim should not believe that his traditions cannot be changed or replaced by new ones (p. 221). He then goes on to assert that no progress on gender inequality has been made since Qasim's time and that such inequality remains a key source of backwardness in the region.
Nowhere in the book is the eclipse of democratic aspirations in the Middle East ever tied to colonial regimes installed by the British or French or to later U.S. imperial intervention. The author likewise does not pay attention to the ways in which unequal gender relations have historically been exacerbated by colonial rule or by resistance to it (as when a “customary” realm was used as a site of anticolonial nationalist control). I therefore fault the book for its ahistorical manner of argumentation, decontextualized presentation of empirical evidence, deep-seated suspicion of Islam, and unyielding commitment to secular and Western forms of modernization. Ghanim's book is very much an internal critique of traditional norms, patriarchy, and authoritarian rule in the Middle East. I applaud Ghanim's attempt to champion the cause of women and ameliorate useless violence. However, I remain deeply concerned that given the wars now being waged in Iraq and Afghanistan and the ways the oppression of women, particularly in Afghanistan, has been used to justify these wars, that Ghanim's book condones continued “intervention” by the powers that be.
