In her book on law and cohabitation in England from the seventeenth century to 2010, Rebecca Probert states at the outset that ‘the central aim of this book is to investigate the relationship between law and behaviour, that is, between the different modes of legal regulation that have prevailed at different times and the extent and nature of cohabitation’ (p. 2, emphasis added). This is an ambitious agenda, doubly so since it is applied to three hundred years of history. To accomplish it, Probert marshals an impressive array of quantitative and qualitative data, ranging from analyses of parish registers and sociological surveys of relationships, through popular literature, films and TV series, to legislation and case-law. For all its conscientious research, I wonder whether the project is somewhat misconceived, however, for two reasons.
First, although the author, and the series in which this book appears, are to be congratulated on their commitment to study law in a social context, thereby utilising evidence from a range of relevant disciplines, the notion that ‘law’ can be separated from ‘behaviour’ is surely misguided. Indeed, Probert concedes that ‘beliefs about the law are likely to be far more important in shaping behaviour than the actual law’ (p. 179), but she does not draw the appropriate conclusion: that ‘law’ is an artificial category of social analysis, which obscures the messy interpenetration of popular culture, ‘the media’ and social ordering. This conceptual mistake is not merely theoretical in its implications, because it is reflected in the organisation of some parts of the book, where long sections of abstract social analysis are followed with separate discussions of relevant case-law.
Second, after reading this study I am not persuaded that ‘cohabitation’ (defined on p. 5 as ‘sexual relationships outside marriage … that involved the parties living under the same roof’) has a history which predates the twentieth century, because Probert admits that the practice was ‘vanishingly rare’ before 1800 (p. 35), and confirms its ‘extreme rarity’ in the nineteenth century (pp. 53 and 57). Indeed, the author's primary motivation for studying this non-practice appears to lie in the construction of a myth among social historians dating from the 1980s that informal marriage was very common among working-class people. While it is important to demolish historical myths – and Probert amply demonstrates the importance of this particular myth in late twentieth-century Britain – perhaps it was inappropriate to devote two substantive chapters of detailed analysis to the virtual non-existence of cohabitation before 1900.
These conceptual doubts are not meant to detract from the book's substantial contributions to legal-historical studies relating to the family, sex and marriage in England, however. Even Chapter 3, on the ‘long nineteenth century, 1770s–1900’, which is certainly overlong and somewhat incoherent, has useful discussions about the decline of individualised moral judgment in the courts during the nineteenth century, and the underlying reality that legal rules operated to deter cohabitation outside marriage. It also reiterates the essential point that litigated cases were hardly representative of relationships generally because so many were filtered out by the rules. Moreover, once she has left the centuries between 1600 and 1900 firmly behind, Probert constructs a complex and meaningful narrative whereby legislative changes and social trends are shown to have interacted variously to advance or impede the ability of cohabitees to live together without social stigma and to secure their respective interests ‘as husband and wife’. In the process she illuminates well-studied areas, such as divorce and domestic violence, and more generally the law and justice relating to marriage and real property rights, from a fresh perspective. Also, while the book represents a commitment to studying social ordering over the long durée, Probert is nevertheless sensitive to the danger of imposing anachronistic labels on the past, and understands that paying close attention to contemporary language can help to reveal social attitudes. Thus the chapter on seventeenth- and eighteenth-century experiences discusses ‘fornicators’, while later chapters address ‘living in sin’, ‘common law wives’, ‘live-in lovers’ and ‘partners’, thereby mapping a long-term but non-linear shift towards toleration.
Chapter 4, on ‘“Unmarried wives” in war and peace, 1900–1927’, shows that the history of regulating cohabitation really began with World War I. Here, Probert continues to argue that the extent of cohabitation in British society was very low, but notes the introduction of legislated allowances for the ‘unmarried wives’ of soldiers, in addition to other dependent family members. She accounts for this partly by a new attitude towards legislation – that it should reflect reality, rather than seeking to change behaviour, and to the pressing reality of war, being a realisation that men would be deterred from joining up if their dependants were rendered destitute. It is true that these provisions were discontinued after the postwar emergency of unemployment ended, but she demonstrates that the war had acted as a catalyst for some coincident changes in attitudes towards illegitimate children and cohabiting couples that recognised the desirability of liberalising the law of divorce in the interest of minimising cohabitation. This story of the interrelationship between the law of divorce and concern tending to moral panic about the spread of ‘living in sin’ becomes an important theme of the book.
Indeed a substantial portion of this book is about opinion tending to myth, and the scholarly importance of myth-busting through detailed empirical study. As suggested earlier, Probert easily dismisses the arguments of historians that in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century England large numbers of working-class people cohabited under the cover of ‘informal’ marriages. She returns to a similar theme in Chapter 7, when she considers the so-called ‘common law marriage myth’. This chapter is important because, rather than being based primarily on social surveys, legal texts and case reports, like the other chapters discussing near-contemporary times it utilises newspapers, magazines and popular television sources to provide the reader with an impression of the way cohabitation was represented. In doing so it constitutes an acknowledgment that in a ‘mediatised’ society it is not so much the facts of legislation and legal process that influence the public, but rather the way they are portrayed by the popular media. Certainly this is exemplified by Probert's account of popular opinion about cohabitation in the 1970s: she argues that the extension of some new rights to cohabitees and exaggerated and simplified accounts of individual legal cases created the myth that couples who lived together had the same legal rights as those who were formally married. As she suggests, this is important because it was the myth as much as the reality of state recognition which helped to make cohabitation more popular. Moreover, in a subsequent chapter she argues that it was the consolidation of the common-law marriage myth in the 1980s that informed the creation of a historical truism that cohabitation without marriage was common in the past (pp. 225–226). So here we have a neat demonstration of contemporary social trends determining historical interpretation.
Not surprisingly, given their currency, the last two substantive chapters of this book become more narrative in style, and their titles imply that the changing conditions of cohabitation and divorce were directly related to the agendas of particular administrations, first the Conservative governments of 1979–1997, and second the ‘New Labour’ governments of 1997–2010. Indeed, the history of cohabitation during these two periods is teasingly linked with a shift in popular labelling from the semi-alarmist ‘live-in lovers’ to the more neutral ‘partners’. But the political periodisation is a little misleading, since the Tories did not crack down on cohabitation (although there was a revival of media-led moral panic about living in sin during the 1980s), and New Labour failed to achieve systematic legislative reforms bringing the rights of informal cohabitees into line with those enjoyed by married couples. Certainly, by the end of the twentieth century cohabitation had achieved broad social acceptance, although Probert's complex account of cohabitees' transformation from ‘fornicators’ to ‘family’ shows that there is no simple and constant relationship between social trends, ‘policy’ and the administration of justice.
