The standard of living debate, which investigates whether the working class benefited from the Industrial Revolution, has produced a large body of literature related to the long-run dynamics of wages, GDP, and, more recently, heights. This last concern, has motivated, at least in part, a more accurate study of how the human body has been transformed over the last three hundred centuries—via what we might call “technophysio evolution.” The present book goes one step farther as it tries to expand this concept to link the development of human bodies and economic growth, or, to use the authors' words, to link “nutrition status” and “standard of living.”
Two elements are at the heart of the theory of this technophysio evolution. First, there is a positive relationship between economic conditions during childhood and body size. Second, there is a positive relationship between body size and work capacity. If you add to that a generational perspective, you get a virtuous cycle: as a given generation is better fed, it can work more, both in quantity (number of hours and intensity of work) and in quality (better cognitive skills) and, as a result, it increases not only its own standard of living but also that of the next generation. Therefore, the next generation will have a higher body size which, in turn, will allow it to work more, increasing its own standard of living and that of the next generation, “and so on, ad infinitum” (p. 39, italics in the original).
This process is, in some way, the exact opposite to the Malthusian trap: instead of being caught in a vicious circle where every increase in the standard of living is wiped out by population growth in the next generation, here each generation benefits from the economic advances of its predecessors. How does this happen? The process works through various channels that influence the nutrition status—“the energy which has been used for growth once the demands of body maintenance, resistance to disease, play, and work have been satisfied” (p. 11)—during childhood and even within the womb. Therefore, one key contribution of the book is to recognize and assess the importance of cohort effects in exploring the long-term evolution of health. It also convincingly shows that poverty does not only result in higher mortality, as in a Malthusian world, but also in stunted and wasted bodies: body size is itself a variable of adjustment in the equilibrium between resources and population. In other words, “subsistence is not located at the edge of a nutritional cliff, beyond which lies demographic disaster. Rather than one level of subsistence, there are numerous levels at which a population and a food supply can be in equilibrium, in the sense that they can be indefinitely sustained. However, some levels will have smaller people and higher normal (noncrisis) mortality than others” (p. 124).
The whole process is then almost purely mechanical (the authors themselves refer to thermodynamics) and, as a result, it tends to set aside some important factors explaining both how to get into the virtuous circle and how to stay within it. One obvious limitation is that most collective organizations are left out of the picture. For instance, it is not clear that people started to work more hours simply because they had the physical capacity to do so; it may well be that other mechanisms induced them to do so. Of course, the authors often mention these other contributing factors (for example, the role of the state in opposing famines in Europe), but the whole picture tends to minimize, certainly more than is necessary, the role of institutional change in the global evolution of health and mortality, and, as a result, in the economic development. Education for instance, which would play a decisive role in most endogenous growth models, is rather neglected. The authors argue that taller individuals (better nourished) have a higher cognitive ability. What remains unclear however is to which extent this cognitive ability can develop without an efficient schooling system (an implicit idea seems to be that, if everyone is well-fed, and so has a high cognitive ability, an efficient schooling system will surely be designed but they never push the argument that far). So being well-fed is a condition for many things related to economic development to happen, but it seems to be merely a necessary condition and not a sufficient one.
This is all the more important when going back to the standard of living debate and the long-term predictions of the book. It has to do with both the spatial and temporal extension of the technophysio evolution. There are little doubts now that, on a long-term basis, the working class in the Western World benefited from the economic development. There is much less evidence that the lower class as a whole —the Chinese, South American, or Indian workers that have replaced European lumpenproletariat—have benefited from it. On the other hand, as the authors recognize, the level of economic inequality has direct implications for the health and nutritional status of the whole population. Inequality is now rising in most of the Western World which may somehow stop the virtuous technophysio process and, in the long run, even reverse it. The key question is thus to what extent is the changing body a human experience or one that is peculiar to the West during last three centuries. To answer this question, more is needed than simply computations of calories input and output.
Thus, the one major criticism of this fine piece of work is that the authors may be guilty of excessive optimism that is more or less implicit throughout the book and comes to a head in the final chapter. But that should not prevent readers from taking advantage of what is probably the most comprehensive survey of health and human development currently available. This is a clear and well-written book that not only complements but elegantly summarizes previous work by these four authors—all of them being leading authorities in the field.
