Environmental history is quickly becoming one of the most interesting and innovative subfields in the study of Latin American history. Mark Carey's In the Shadow of Melting Glaciers is an excellent example of why this is the case. This book is ostensibly a history of climate change and local, national and international responses to glacier disasters in the last 60 years or so in the Cordillera Blanca or Callejón de Huaylas in Huaraz, Peru. However, Carey's book should also be read as one of the most original contributions to the history of modern Peru to have appeared in some time, as a brilliant illustration of how historians and social scientists may approach the study of ‘natural’ phenomena, and as a major intervention in current debates over the management of one of the world's key resources: water. Drawing effortlessly on a number of literatures, including, perhaps most interestingly if subtly, science and technology studies, Carey explores in compelling fashion the ways in which a number of human (mestizo urban residents, indigenous peasants, foreign and local scientists, bureaucrats) and non-human actors (glaciers, glacial lakes, outburst floods, avalanches, earthquakes, hydroelectric projects, multinational corporations and the supernatural) have shaped the history of this region. He shows that this history is best understood as resulting from the interplay of these human and non-human actors, an interplay that has often resulted in tragic outcomes.
The history of glacier disasters in Huaraz reflects, and is integral to, economic policy and social development strategies in Peru in the second half of the twentieth century. Carey shows that the response to glacier disasters by the national state apparatus, local elites and the scientific community, as well as by local people, and the attempts to ‘manage’ glaciers as both a threat to humans and property and as a valuable resource changed in ways that mirrored broader changes in state–society relations that occurred in Peru, both at the national and local levels. Beginning in the 1940s, glaciers and the dangers that they represented to populations that lived in the path of avalanches and glacial lake outbursts began to preoccupy a number of Huaraz- and Lima-based scientists and government officials. Between the 1950s and 1990s, glaciers became objects of state intervention. Prompted by the atrocious human costs of glacier disasters (5,000 human casualties in 1941, when large parts of the city of Huaraz were destroyed; 4,000 in 1962; and 15,000 in 1970, when an avalanche caused by a massive earthquake buried a whole town), but also by their material costs (the destruction of a hydroelectric plant in 1950, and also of countless bridges, roads, farms, livestock and pasture), the state directed new resources to disaster prevention and management from the dictatorship of Manuel Odría (1948–56) onwards.
The state entered the Cordillera Blanca through scientists and engineers, pioneers of a local or ‘creole’ glaciology who, often in conjunction with foreign experts, identified, classified and named glaciers, sought to mitigate disasters by damming or draining glacial lakes, and, more generally, introduced a new, specifically ‘scientific’ knowledge about glaciers and glacial lakes to the region. But the state, or rather its representatives, also saw the region as a valuable resource, and its glacier prevention strategies, Carey suggests, owed more to the perceived economic benefit of harnessing the hydroelectric potential of the region than to a sense of responsibility towards safeguarding the lives of the local population. It was only following the destruction of the Cañon del Pato hydroelectric plant in 1950 that the state began to take seriously the problem of avalanches and glacial lake outbursts and set up a Lakes Commission to oversee a coherent and relatively well-funded project of disaster mitigation. This state intervention profoundly shaped the region. One perhaps unintended consequence of the scientific study of glaciers, and its opening up of new roads and corollary infrastructural development, was the reframing of the region as a destination for tourism and mountaineering. More generally, the state sought to impact directly upon the region by introducing hazard zoning and attempting to relocate populations away from the path of avalanches and glacial lake outbursts.
To his credit, Carey is careful to highlight the ways in which multiple ‘agencies’ shaped the processes he describes. The hazard zoning attempts, in the 1940s as in the 1960s and 1970s, were opposed by local populations who refused to move. Carey resists seeing this as simple subaltern resistance to hegemonic power and argues, instead, that while such opposition to zoning reflected an understandable desire for local autonomy, it also made local populations dependent on the state's ability to reduce the risk of disaster through its glacial lake monitoring and drainage programmes. Similarly, Carey sees the deployment of an authoritative, scientific knowledge of glaciers in the region in a more subtle way than much of the literature on the so-called ‘politics of expertise’, emphasising how glaciologists and other scientists drew on both local and ‘scientific’ knowledges in making sense of the threats that glaciers posed. In a final chapter, Carey looks at how the arrangements developed over several decades to mitigate glacier disaster have been radically altered in the last couple of decades as a consequence of the ‘neoliberalisation’ of nature – that is, as a consequence of the privatisation of the Cañon del Pato hydroelectric plant by President Alberto Fujimori (1990–2000), with all that this implies for the management of glacial water. This process has created new conflicts over water use, while the state's retrenchment has reduced its ability to manage glacier disasters. Again, Carey shows, local people have played a key role in shaping the outcome of this new development.
In the Shadow of Melting Glaciers is, in short, a major contribution to a number of literatures. Historians and social scientists of Peru will find much of interest in Carey's book, but so will environmental historians, development economists, sociologists and anthropologists who work on other parts of the world.
