Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:08:18.133Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulent and wave kinetic energy budgets in the airflow over wind-generated surface waves

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 June 2021

Kianoosh Yousefi*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USASchool of Marine Science and Policy, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USA
Fabrice Veron
Affiliation:
School of Marine Science and Policy, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USA
Marc P. Buckley
Affiliation:
Institute of Coastal Research, Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht, 21502 Geesthacht, Germany
*
†Email address for correspondence: kyousefi@udel.edu

Abstract

The momentum and energy exchanges at the ocean surface are central factors determining the sea state, weather patterns and climate. To investigate the effects of surface waves on the air–sea energy exchanges, we analyse high-resolution laboratory measurements of the airflow velocity acquired above wind-generated surface waves using the particle image velocimetry technique. The velocity fields were further decomposed into the mean, wave-coherent and turbulent components, and the corresponding energy budgets were explored in detail. We specifically focused on the terms of the budget equations that represent turbulence production, wave production and wave–turbulence interactions. Over wind waves, the turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) production is positive at all heights with a sharp peak near the interface, indicating the transfer of energy from the mean shear to the turbulence. Away from the surface, however, the TKE production approaches zero. Similarly, the wave kinetic energy (WKE) production is positive in the lower portion of the wave boundary layer (WBL), representing the transfer of energy from the mean flow to the wave-coherent field. In the upper part of the WBL, WKE production becomes slightly negative, wherein the energy is transferred from the wave perturbation to the mean flow. The viscous and Stokes sublayer heights emerge as natural vertical scales for the TKE and WKE production terms, respectively. The interactions between the wave and turbulence perturbations show an energy transfer from the wave to the turbulence in the bulk of the WBL and from the turbulence to the wave in a thin layer near the interface.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Summary of experimental conditions. The friction velocity, $u_{*}$, and 10 m wind speed, $U_{10}$, were obtained from the wind velocity profiles. The peak wave frequencies, $f_p$, were measured with single-point optical wave gauges, and other parameters with subscript $p$ were derived from linear wave theory. The dimensionless amplitude and roughness length were respectively estimated using $a_p^+=a_p u_*/\nu$ and $\zeta _0^+=\zeta _0 u_*/\nu$, where $a_p=\sqrt {2}a_{rms}$ is the peak amplitude, $a_{rms}$ is the root-mean-square amplitude, $\nu$ is the kinematic viscosity and $\zeta _0$ is the roughness length. The viscous sublayer thickness is estimated as $\delta _\nu u_*/\nu = 10$. The Stokes layer height was calculated as $\delta _s=(2 \nu /(k_p C_p))^{1/2}$, where $C_p$ is the peak wave phase speed. Finally, $Re_w = C_p / 2\nu k_p$ is the wave Reynolds number.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic representation of coordinate transformation from (a) the Cartesian physical domain $(x_1, x_3) = (x, z)$ to (b) the decaying wave-following, orthogonal coordinate system $(\xi _1, \xi _3) = (\xi, \zeta )$. Here, $(U_1, U_3) = (U, W)$ are, respectively, the horizontal (along $\xi$-axis) and vertical (along $\zeta$-axis) components of the velocity vector $\boldsymbol {{u}}$ in the orthogonal curvilinear coordinate system. The projected velocities $U$ and $W$ are aligned with lines of constant $\zeta$ and $\xi$, respectively. The $\zeta$ coordinate follows the wave shape close to the surface and tends toward a rectangular coordinate system farther away from the surface. The line $\zeta = 0$ represents the water surface. The constant $\xi$-lines are orthogonal to the constant $\zeta$-lines, and decay toward rectangular coordinates away from the surface. The colour denotes $U_1$ in $\textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of the normalized (a–e) TKE, ${\langle e_t \rangle }/{u^2_*}$, and (f–j) WKE, ${\langle e_w \rangle }/{u^2_*}$, where $e_t = {3(U_1^{\prime } U_1^{\prime } + U_3^{\prime } U_3^{\prime })}/{4}$ and $e_w = {(\widetilde {U}_{1}\widetilde {U}_{1} + \widetilde {U}_{3}\widetilde {U}_{3})}/{2}$, for all experimental conditions. The wave-phase-coherent fields are plotted above the mean water surface as a function of dimensionless distance $k_pz$. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Vertical profiles of the (normalized) mean (a) TKE, $\bar {e}_t/{u^2_*}$, and (b) WKE, ${\bar {e}_w}/{u^2_*}$, for different experimental conditions. The turbulent and wave kinetic energies are normalized by the friction velocity and plotted as a function of dimensionless height $k_p\zeta$. Solid grey lines denote computational results of Rutgersson & Sullivan (2005) for idealized water waves with $C_p/u_* = 7.8$ and $ak = 0.1$ obtained using Cartesian velocities (not a direct comparison with our measurements). The arrow at the top of panel (a) shows canonical values of TKE for atmospheric turbulent boundary layers with neutral stability (Panofsky & Dutton 1984; Pahlow et al.2001).

Figure 4

Figure 4.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of turbulence production, $\varPi _t$ (defined in (4.9)), normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ plotted with (a–e) linear and (f–j) logarithmic vertical scales. The linear and logarithmic wave-phase-coherent fields are plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional heights $k_p z$ and $k_p \zeta$, respectively. The heights of the viscous sublayer and critical layer are denoted by grey horizontal solid and dashed lines, respectively. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left. The existence of a thin layer of near-zero production close to the surface within the viscous sublayer can be observed even for high-wind-speed conditions. Intense turbulence production takes place just above the viscous layer.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of measured components of the turbulence production (a–e) $\varPi _{t,11}$, (f–j) $\varPi _{t,13}$ and (k–o) ${\varPi _{t,33}}$, defined in (4.5)–(4.7). The wave-phase-coherent production components are all normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ and plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional height $k_p z$. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left. Here, $\varPi _{t,33}$ is smaller by approximately two orders of magnitude than the two dominant components $\varPi _{t,11}$ and $\varPi _{t,13}$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of wave production, $\varPi _w$ (defined in (4.13)), normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ plotted with (a–e) linear and (f–j) logarithmic vertical scales for different wind-speed cases. The linear and logarithmic wave-phase-coherent fields are plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional heights $k_p z$ and $k_p \zeta$, respectively. The heights of the Stokes layer $\delta _s$ and critical layer are denoted by grey horizontal solid and dashed lines, respectively. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left. Intense wave production takes place below the Stokes layer.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of the measured components of the wave production (a–e) ${\varPi _{w,11}}$, (f–j) ${ \varPi _{w,13}}$ and (k–o) ${ \varPi _{w,33}}$, defined in (4.10)–(4.12), for different wind-speed cases. The wave-phase-coherent production components are all normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ and plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional height $k_p z$. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left. Here, $\varPi _{w,33}$ is smaller by approximately one and two orders of magnitude compared with the two dominant components $\varPi _{w,11}$ and $\varPi _{w,13}$ in the wave production, respectively.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of the measured components of the wave–turbulence interaction term (a–e) $W_{t, 11}$, (f–j) $W_{t, 13}$ and (k–o) $W_{t, 33}$, defined in (4.18)–(4.20), for different wind-speed cases. The wave-phase-coherent wave–turbulence interaction components are all normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ and plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional height $k_p z$. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Wave-phase-coherent distributions of the wave–turbulence interaction term, $W_t$ (defined in (4.22)), normalized by $u_*^3 k_p$ plotted with (a–e) linear and (f–j) logarithmic vertical scales for different wind-speed cases. The linear and logarithmic wave-phase-coherent fields are plotted above the mean water surface as a function of non-dimensional heights $k_p z$ and $k_p \zeta$, respectively. The 10 m wind speeds corresponding to each experimental condition are indicated on the left.

Figure 10

Figure 10.(a) Vertical profiles of the mean TKE production $\overline {P}_t$ scaled by $u^3_*k_p$ for different wind-speed cases as a function of the non-dimensional height $k_p \zeta$. For comparison purposes, the results of Hsu et al. (1981) for mechanically generated waves with $U_{10} = 2.4\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and $C_p/u_* = 18.2$ are also indicated by grey circles. Most of the shear production is concentrated close to the water interface, below $k_p \zeta \approx 0.2$, in all cases. (b) Comparison of TKE production over wind waves with those in wall-bounded turbulent flows. The profiles of the law-of-the-wall turbulent production $\overline {P}_t^+$ (defined in (4.32)) are plotted against wall coordinates $\zeta ^+$ for wind waves with low–moderate wind speeds of 2.25, 5.08 and $9.57\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and the smooth water surface case with ${U}_{10} = 0.89\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$. For comparison, the results of El Telbany & Reynolds (1982), Papadimitrakis, Hsu & Street (1986), Wei & Willmarth (1989) and Antonia et al. (1992) in a fully developed turbulent channel flow, and those of Kim, Kline & Reynolds (1968), Spalart (1988) and Krogstad & Antonia (1999) in the turbulent boundary-layer flow over a flat plate are also shown. Finally, the theoretical value of $1/\kappa \zeta ^+$ is also shown with grey solid lines.

Figure 11

Figure 11.(a) Vertical profiles of the mean WKE, $\overline {P}_w$, scaled by $u^3_*k_p$ for different wind-speed cases as a function of the non-dimensional height $k_p \zeta$. For comparison purposes, the results of Hsu et al. (1981) for mechanically generated waves with $U_{10} = 2.4\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and $C_p/u_* = 18.2$ are also indicated by grey circles. The mean WKE is positive (slightly negative) in the lower (upper) portion of the WBL representing energy transfer from the mean flow (wave-induced field) to the wave-induced field (mean flow). (b) Vertical profiles of the mean WKE production, ${\overline {P}_w}$, scaled by $(a_p k_p C_p)^2 u_* k_p$ plotted as a function of the non-dimensional height $\zeta /\delta _s$. The maximum production is located within the Stokes layers. The grey solid line shows the ${\sim }\exp {(-\zeta /\delta _s)}$ decay curve.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Vertical profiles of the mean (a) wave–turbulence interaction term ${\overline {W}_t}$ (b–f) along with the measured components ${\overline {W}_{t,11}}$ (– – –), ${\overline {W}_{t,13}}$ (—) and ${\overline {W}_{t,33}}$ (— - — - —) scaled by $u_*^3 k_p$ for different wind-speed cases as a function of non-dimensional height $k_p \zeta$. For comparison purposes, the results of Hsu et al. (1981) for mechanically generated waves with $U_{10} = 2.4\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and $C_p/u_*$ = 18.2 are also indicated by grey circles.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Profiles of the terms in the WKE budget, defined in (5.8), plotted above the mean water surface as a function of dimensionless height $k_p \zeta$ for all experimental wind-wave conditions with wind speeds varying from 2.25 to $16.59 \ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$. All terms are scaled by $u_*^3 k_p$. The pressure transport term $\overline {T}_w^p$ is derived as a residual. Here, the production and pressure transport terms dominate near the surface for all wind-speed cases.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Profiles of the terms in the TKE budget, defined in (5.12), plotted above the mean water surface as a function of (a–e) dimensionless height $k_p\zeta$ for wind waves with wind speeds varying from 2.25 to $16.59\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$ and (f) dimensionless law-of-the-wall height $\zeta ^+$ for the case of the smooth water surface (scale shown at the right) with wind speed of $0.89\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$. The TKE budget terms are scaled by $u_*^3 k_p$ for experiments with wind waves (a–e), and they are normalized using wall variables $u^+ = U/u_*$ and $\zeta ^+ = \zeta u_* / \nu$ for the experiment over the smooth water surface (f). All terms in the TKE budget are measured directly except $\overline {T}_t^p$ and $\bar {\epsilon }_t$, which are derived as the residual, $Res = \overline {T}_t^p + \bar {\epsilon }_t = - (\overline{\mathcal{T}}_t + \overline {P}_t + \overline {W}_t)$. However, we expect the pressure transport $\overline {T}_t^p$ to be negligible such that $Res \approx \bar {\epsilon }_t$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Instantaneous fields of (a,b) the turbulent production term $P_t$, (c,d) the wave–turbulence interaction term $W_t$ and (e,f) the total transport term $\mathcal {T}_t$, defined in (5.13)–(5.15), over non-separating (a,c,e) and separating (b,d,f) wind waves for the wind-wave experimental condition of $U_{10} = 5.08\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-1}$. All terms are scaled by $u_*^3 k_p \times {10}^{3}$.