This chapter tries to show that there is indubitable evidence for the claim that the Yoga philosophy of Patañjali can be said to be a philosophy as therapeia. For this reference will be made particularly to the Sāṅkhya school, whose ontology and metaphysics are presupposed by Yoga philosophy.Footnote 1 The Sāṅkhya school begins with the question about overcoming three kinds of ‘suffering’ that torment human beings, and Patañjali himself says that the implementation of yoga, is, among other things, for the sake of minimising the afflictions (kleśas, YS 2, 2). The second part of the chapter will be concerned with the philosophical activity referred to in Yoga itself, namely the active yoga, or yoga in the form of action (kriyāyoga, YS 2, 1), in order to show how this can be seen as advancing the case for Yoga as therapeia.
The beginnings of Indian philosophy, it is often said, go back to ideas contained in the Vedas, especially in the chronologically later parts of the Āraṇyakas (‘forest treatises’) and the Upaniṣads (‘secret teachings’), the earliest being composed perhaps before the sixth century bce. There seems to be a fundamental difference in the Vedic Weltanschauung before and after Buddha and Mahāvīra (who were contemporaries around the fifth–fourth century bce). The ancient view did not stress the idea of a recurrent cycle of existences as characterising the human situation. This emphasis might have come about through the influence of the ascetic tradition which seems to have been quite well established during Buddha's and Mahāvīra's times. With the exception of the materialist school of Cārvāka or Lokāyata, the idea of recurrent existences became one of the important presuppositions of all the schools of Indian philosophy.Footnote 2 It is well-known that in his first sermon the Buddha said that in life ‘everything is suffering’ (sarvaṃ duḥkham). It is also known that this characterisation is merely a starting point for his views on how to overcome suffering. He described many aspects of suffering common to life, including normal pain, be it physical or psychological, but sought a kind of final liberation from suffering as such, from a suffering which was seen as intrinsically linked to and a part of the human condition. What he wanted was a liberation from the cycle of existences as such, and not only from suffering in the form of birth, old age, sickness and death.Footnote 3 He said that he had himself achieved this liberation and that he wanted to share his method with his fellow human beings. This basic view of life as entailing suffering became an assumption taken over by all other Indian schools except Cārvāka school, including Yoga. Yogasūtra 2, 15 says ‘Because of the pains (of causing suffering) in the end, because of anguish, because of subliminal impressions and because of the contrary nature of the constituents of primeval nature (guṇas), to the discriminating, all is pain’.Footnote 4
Most Indian schools therefore provide pathways to liberation (mokṣa-mārga), each school offering its own way in the context of its own ontological presuppositions. It is Sāṅkhya which provides the basic metaphysical background for the Yoga school. The earliest work that presents the fundamental ideas of Sāṅkhya is the Sāṅkhyakārikā by Īśvarakṛṣṇa (before the fifth century ce). In good Indian style of the period, the beginning—here the first two stanzas—clearly establishes the programme of the undertaking:
On account of the infliction by a threefold suffering [there arises] an investigation (jijñāsā) into the means of counteracting it (tad-abhighātake hetau). If it is said that in being [already] known (dṛṣṭe), it (the investigation) is useless, then [we say] no, it is not so, because [what is known] is neither absolute nor eternal (SK 1).Footnote 5
The second line clearly implies that the means of counteracting the threefold suffering are relative and temporary, not absolute and eternal. This becomes clear when, as the commentary says, the threefold suffering refers: 1. to the infliction ‘proceeding from bodily and mental causes within one's self’ (the dictionary meaning of ādhyātmika); 2. the infliction ‘belonging or related to created beings’ (ādhibhautika), namely, the infliction caused by other beings, including people, animals and insects like mosquitoes, etc.; and 3. the infliction ‘relating to or proceeding from gods or from spirits’ (ādhidaivika). In the normal course of events, these inflictions are not eliminated once and for all, but recur over and over again.Footnote 6 What is sought, then, is a remedy that is absolute and eternal.
It is clear that the author has a specific aim in mind, and in the second stanza of the work he makes explicit his reference to a permanent means of overcoming the afflictions, namely, a philosophical knowledge of Sāṅkhya ontology. The stanza starts by implying an objection from a putative opponent, someone who says, ‘All right, it might be so that these known means already talked about fail in their intent to cure human suffering for ever, but what about scriptural tradition?’ This scriptural knowledge, namely, what is derived from tradition or the Veda (anuśravika), must surely supply the eternal cure. With this objection in the background the text goes on to say:
What is derived from tradition is like what is [already] known (dṛṣṭavad); it is verily linked with impurity, destruction and excess; different from this and superior [to it] is [the means derived] from the discriminative knowledge (vijñānāt) of the evolved, the unevolved and the knower (SK 2).Footnote 7
The first stanza says that the known methods offer mere temporary respite from suffering; the fact that they are considered finally to be useless implies that there is a superior method, one that is quite different from the known ones, a method of overcoming suffering once and for all through a special kind of knowledge, known as ‘discriminative knowledge’ (vijñāna).
Revelant dictionary meanings of the word vijñāna are: ‘the act of distinguishing or discerning, understanding, comprehending, recognizing’. SK2 states that if one can distinguish between the terms ‘the evolved,’ ‘the unevolved’ and ‘the knower’ (vyaktāvyakta-jña), then one is in possession of the key which ends suffering for ever. This key, in fact, is nothing other than knowledge of Sāṅkhya ontology. Although three categories are mentioned, these reduce to two because ‘the evolved’ and ‘the unevolved’ refer to a single category in two states of its existence, namely, the unevolved state of equilibrium, and the evolved state that is brought about when the equilibrium is disturbed. Let us quote the definitions of these categories given in Īśvarakṛṣṇa's Saṅkhyakārikā. A summary of Sāṅkhya ontology is given immediately after what was said above, in stanza 3:
Primeval matter is not a modification; the seven, beginning with the the great one, Mahat, (or buddhi, intellect or ‘reason’)Footnote 8 are changed states/modifications of [primeval] matter (prakṛti-vikṛtayas); the sixteen, however, are [mere] modifications.Footnote 9 Puruṣa is neither matter (prakṛti) nor a modification [of it] (SK 3).Footnote 10
This statement clearly distinguishes pimeval matter and its evolutes or modifications from puruṣa, which is neither material nor has modifications. This stanza has to be read with stanzas 10 and 11, which deal with the evolved, the unevolved and the knower mentioned in SK 2:
The evolved is caused, non-eternal, non-pervasive, mobile, manifold, dependent, mergent, conjunct, and heteronomous. The unevolved is the reverse [of all these] (SK 10).
The evolved is [composed] of the three constituents, non-discriminated, objective, general, non-intelligent and productive; so is the unevolved (pradhāna). The Spirit (pumān), though similar, is [yet] the reverse of these (SK 11).Footnote 11
So Sāṅkhya ontology involves unevolved primeval matter (avyakta/pradhāna/prakṛti) and a principle of life (puruṣa/pumān/ātman). As ontological categories both are abstract principles and both substances. Stanza 11 states that ‘the Spirit, though similar’, that is, in also being a substance, ‘is yet the reverse of these’, insofar as it does not share the elements that serve to define primeval matter, which, among other things, is non-intelligent. The evolved is an altered state of primeval matter in which the three constituents become clearly distinguished because one or the other becomes dominant.Footnote 12
Yoga as Therapeia
The basic text of the Yoga school is Patañjali's Yogasūtra in 195 (or perhaps 196) sūtras, divided into four sections. The basic questions are dealt with in the very first chapter: What is Yoga? Where does it begin? What does it lead to? What psychological states are associated with the path of Yoga? What are its methods? What are the hindrances on the path? The eightfold Yoga discipline is dealt with in the second chapter, namely, the means which lead towards the minimisation of suffering. The third chapter describes important elements of the Yoga path given in Yogasūtra 2, 29; namely, dhāraṇa, dhyāna and samādhi, which Rukmani translates as ‘concentration,’ ‘meditation’ and ‘oneness with [the] object of meditation.’ The third chapter also describes what is achieved or the perfections attained (siddhi, vibhūti) as a result of successfully performing the yoga exercises. The fourth chapter, among other things, discusses and defines important philosophical terms like ‘psyche’ (citta), reason/intellect (buddhi), the ‘I-maker’ or ego (ahaṃ-kāra), and latent traces (vāsanā) in the psyche. It also gives a description of the ultimate state of liberation from suffering (mokṣa).
Patañjali begins his Yogasūtra with these six sūtras:
1. Now an exposition of Yoga [is begun].
2. Yoga is the restriction of the modifications of the psyche.
3. At that time the seer abides in itself.
4. At other times it has the same form as the modification [of the psyche].
5. The modifications are of five types and they are afflicted and non-afflicted [painful and non-painful].
6. Correct knowledge, misapprehension, mental construction, sleep and memory [are the five kinds of modifications].Footnote 13
The first sūtra announces what is being undertaken in the work, namely, an exposition of Yoga philosophy. The second sūtra then defines what Yoga is, namely, a restriction, an arrest of the modifications or changes which take place in the psyche, changes which in the final analysis are reducible to the activity which takes place in primeval matter, prakṛti. When the psychical activities are under control then, as the third sūtra says, the seer abides in itself; this is a reference to the puruṣa which in a sense can be seen as the defining characteristic of human beings, or as consciousness as such. When this does not happen, when the modifications of the psyche are not under control, then, as the fourth sūtra says, ‘it has the same form as the modification [of the psyche]’. ‘It’ refers to puruṣa which takes on the psychical change.
What are these modifications and how many of them are there? The text says that there are five such modifications, and defines each of them in subsequent sūtras: correct knowledge refers to the means or instruments of cognition or knowledge, namely, perception, inference, and the utterance of a trustworthy person (YS 1, 7:); misapprehension is the ‘false knowledge [of a thing] which does not correspond to its [real] form’ (YS 1, 8); mental construction ‘is devoid of a corresponding object and is conjured by knowledge which arises from words’ (YS 1, 9); sleep is that modification of the psyche based on the absence of any knowledge content’ (YS 1, 10); and memory ‘is non-loss [or, not losing] or not stealing of the objects in the psyche which have been once experienced’ (YS 1, 11).
We have seen that according to Sāṅkhya the absolute and eternal cure, namely, the means of removing or counteracting suffering in any of its three forms, is by way of discriminative knowledge of the evolved, the unevolved and the knower. We also saw that this meant a knowledge of puruṣa and prakṛti. Now, here in the Yoga view, the seer (draṣṭu = puruṣa) abides in itself only when there is a restriction or an arrest of the psychical modifications (citta-vṛtti = prakṛti); otherwise the seer takes on the form of the modification. For the removal of suffering, according to Yoga, what is needed is a clear knowledge of the difference between the intrinsic natures of puruṣa and prakṛti. Whereas Sāṅkhya merely recognizes the problem and theoretically points at the solution, Yoga now says that the remedy rests in the restriction of the modifications of the psyche through ‘practice and through detachment’ (YS 1, 12: abhyāsa-vairāgyābhyāṃ tan-nirodhaḥ). Practice is ‘the effort to stay in the restricted state’ (YS 1, 13: tatra sthitau yatno ’bhyāsaḥ) and detachment is the ‘absence of greed towards objects seen and heard of’ (YS 1, 15: dṛṣṭānuśravika-viṣaya-vitṛṣṇasya vaśīkāra-saṃjñā vairāgyam). The point becomes even more explicit in the next statement: ‘That is the highest detachment which results in the absence of greed towards the guṇas, on account of discernment of puruṣa’ (YS 1, 16: tat-paraṃ puruṣa-khyāter guṇa-vaitṛṣṇyam).
The definition of Yoga as being ‘the restriction of the modifications of the psyche’ is a short and clear statement. However, when one learns that these modifications entail cognition, misapprehension, mental construction, sleep and memory (as given and defined in YS 1, 6ff.), and that all of them have to be restricted (according to the definition in YS 1, 2), one wonders whether and how these common and natural human activities can be brought to a standstill. All one can say is that the Yoga view is that this can indeed be achieved, when certain obstacles are overcome. YS 1, 30 enumerates nine hindrances:
The distractions (vikṣepa) of the mind are [these nine:] sickness, idleness, doubt, negligence, sloth, lack of detachment (avirati), misapprehension (bhrānta-darśana), failure to attain any stage [of concentration, alabdha-bhūmikatva and] inability to stay [in the stage of concentration attained, anavasthitatva] (YS 1, 30).Footnote 14
If the modifications of the psyche cannot be restricted because of the distractions or hindrances, then these hindrances are responsible for suffering: ‘Pain, dejection, unsteadiness of the body, inhaling and exhaling exist along with distractions’ (YS 1, 31). How is one to get rid of these hindrances: ‘In order to remove these [there should be] practice on a single entity’ (YS, 1, 32), namely, one-pointedness. By this is meant exercising the psyche to concentrate ‘on a single entity as support’, as the commentary says.Footnote 15
The question still remains as to how exactly a ‘clarity of the psyche’ can be attained. The answer is given in YS 1, 33:
The psyche attains clarity by cultivating friendliness, compassion, joy and indifference towards happiness, pain, virtue and vice (that is to say, towards those who are happy, those who are miserable, those who are virtuous and those who are evil-minded) (YS 1, 33).Footnote 16
Then follow other suggestions for attaining a stability of the psyche, through proper breathing (YS 1, 34), meditation (dhyāna, YS 1, 39), etc., and the first chapter of the Yogasūtra ends after briefly mentioning various kinds of intense meditation (samādhi).Footnote 17 Chapter Two begins with the statement: ‘Self-discipline, study [of the scriptures and] devotion to Īśvara [the lord] are yoga in the form of action’, and they are ‘for the sake of bringing about samādhi and for the sake of minimising the afflictions’.Footnote 18 Apart from distractions such as sickness, idleness and doubt, mentioned in YS 1, 30 above, the afflictions which torment human beings are: ‘misapprehension, the sense of I, attachment, aversion and clinging to life’.Footnote 19 After briefly defining each term in subsequent sūtras, YS 2, 11 then says: ‘Their modifications are to be destroyed through meditation’.Footnote 20 YS 2, 28 and 29 not only say what is achieved through the help or aid of yoga, but also give the eight limbs which make up the essence of the yoga discipline:
By the practice of the different aids to yoga, when there is destruction of impurity, there arises the light of knowledge culminating in discriminate-discernment (YS 2, 28).
Restraint (yama), observance (niyama), posture (āsana), regulation of breath (prāṇāyāma), withdrawal of the senses (pratyāhāra), concentration (dhāraṇā), meditation (dhyāna), and oneness with object of meditation (samādhi) are the eight limbs (of yoga) (YS 2, 29).
Each of these limbs is then defined. Various restraints and observances are listed which have to do with conduct and behaviour in general and should be observed throughout one's life, unlike breathing and concentration exercises which are practised for a specific time. The restraints are given in YS 2, 30: abstinence from injury (ahiṃsā), truthfulness (satya), abstinence from theft (asteya), continence (brahmacarya), and abstinence from avariciousness (aparigraha); these make up the ‘great vow’ (mahāvrata, YS 2, 31). The observances are given in YS 2, 32: cleanliness (śauca), contentment (saṃtoṣa), austerity (tapaḥ), study (of the scripture, svādhyāya) and devotion to the lord (īśvarapraṇidhāna).
The last four of the eight ‘limbs’ are: the withdrawal of the senses (pratyāhāra), concentration (dhāraṇā), meditation (dhyāna), and oneness with the object of meditation (samādhi). They are described as follows in the Yogasūtra:
When the sense-organs do not come in contact with their [respective] objects and appear to be imitating the nature of the mind it is called withdrawal of sense-organs (pratyāhāra, YS 2, 54). From that [is achieved] the highest control of the sense-organs (YS 2, 55). Concentration (dhāraṇā) is fixing the mind in one place (YS 3, 1). With reference to the same place, when there is continuous flow of the same knowledge, it is called meditation (dhyāna, YS 3, 2). When the same dhyāna shines as the object alone [in the mind] appearing to have lost its reflective nature, it is called oneness with the object of meditation/ intense meditation (samādhi, YS 3, 3).Footnote 21
With an intensification of concentration a deeper state of the psyche is reached, ending with the state of becoming one with the the object of concentration. In other words, a withdrawal of the sense-organs from their respective objects enables one not only to concentrate better but also to learn to intensify this concentration through proper exercise. The state of oneness with the object has two main stages, one with the aid of an object of meditation and the other without such an aid (YS 1, 17 and 18 mention two broad kinds of intense meditation, saṃprajñāta and asaṃprajñāta-samādhi). The first of these has four kinds: savitarka, nirvitarka, savicāra and nirvicāra, translated respectively as ‘deliberative,’ ‘super-deliberative,’ ‘reflective’ and ‘super-reflective’ (YS 1, 42–44).
The ‘deliberative’ is a kind of logical thinking as an aid for meditation. This exercise involves an intensive internal argumentation and presupposes a preparation for it, so as to enable the psyche to experience the object in ‘its essential or intrinsic whole.’ In a sense, this intense meditation is a state based on what is ‘gross’ (sthūla; Rukmani vol. 2, p. 213; solid, thick, compact). Further, as YS 1, 17 says, the state entails the sense of ‘I’ as in ‘I recognise this object,’ or ‘this object of meditation is mine.’ The ‘super-deliberative,’ a state without such internal deliberation, though arising out of it, is no longer concerned with what is gross and is without the sense of ‘I’. It is a condition in which the object which serves as an aid is seen in its essence, without a name and without its previous form (YS 1, 42–43).
The other two kinds of intense meditation which are aids to concentration are the reflective and super-reflective. Whereas the first two states are based on what is ‘gross,’ these two are based on what is ‘subtle’ (sūkṣma, Rukmani vol. 1, p. 230–1). In the first of these states time and space are realised in their subtle forms, and take on a qualitatively different relevance from the one they have in daily experience. The super-reflective state, one ‘without or beyond’ reflection, is literally beyond anything that can be reflected upon; the practitioner ‘sees’ the subtle object which serves as an aid to meditation in its ‘ideal form’. It is a state in which thoughts are in their ‘pure form’. Feelings such as sadness, happiness, violence and sloth are no longer present.
The aim of these exercises is, step by step and with practice, to arrive at a balanced state (samāpatti) of the psyche. The idea is to become adept—thoroughly proficient and skilled—in entering any state at will. The four states of intense meditation or oneness with the object of meditation that help concentration are a preparation for a second kind of samādhi, which is a state without such an aid. All the four states involve controlled modifications or fluctuations of the psyche because an attempt is being made through these exercises to arrest or restrict the activity of the psyche. When the practitioner has mastered the fourth state, then even this activity will have to be restricted and arrested in order that the practitioner continue steadfastly and maintain the state of concentration. In the state of intense meditation without a meditation aid, the practitioner is devoid of any help to limit or support the psyche. Then the true nature of the psyche is ready to be manifested. A manifestation of the true nature of the seer, or observer (drastu, YS 1, 3), goes in tandem with it. In other words, with a knowledge of ‘the evolved, the unevolved and the knower’, as Sāṅkhya puts it, and an arrest or restriction of psychical activity, as Yoga says, the goal of both schools is arrived at.
The eight limbs of Yoga, and within these the successive stages or states of meditation constitute a discipline based on ascetic exercises. There are practical instructions to help the practitioner on the path of yoga in several places of the text. So, for example:
When perverse thoughts oppose [the restraints and the observances] (YS 2, 31–32]) there should be the cultivation of opposite [thoughts] (YS 2, 33). Perverse thoughts such as causing injury, etc., whether done by oneself or caused to be done or approved, preceded by greed, anger, and delusion which is mild, moderate, or intense, result in endless pain and ignorance—this [kind of thought] is an opposite thought (YS 2, 34).Footnote 22
Following the restraints and observances, the practitioner proceeds in logical sequence. He or she learns to practice a steady and comfortable posture (āsana, YS 2, 46); to regulate the breath, that is, to suspend the movement of inhalation and exhalation (prāṇāyāma, YS 2, 49); and to withdraw the senses from their respective objects (pratyāhāra, YS, 2, 54). The last three stages belong together very closely and are a more subtle kind of control of and mastery over the modifications and fluctuations of the psyche. Beginning with concentration, each step involves a further intensification and together they make up the final stages of the path to self-knowledge in which the seer then abides in his or her self.Footnote 23
Conclusion
We have seen that Yoga is defined as the restriction or arrest of the modifications or fluctuations of the psyche, and that its aim is to show how suffering may be minimised, if not completely eradicated. YS 2, 15 says that everything is indeed suffering (duḥkham eva sarvam), a point emphasising what was said in YS 1, 31, namely, that if the modifications of the psyche, which cause distractions, are not steadied or stabilised, then there is pain, dejection, and so forth. Suggestions for stabilising the psyche are given. Afflictions and distractions are a sign of an uncontrolled, erratic psyche and they need to be overcome. YS 2, 29 gives a summary of the eight limbs of Yoga, which, in fact, constitute an ascetic discipline requiring meditation exercises in order to control the psyche. Two main types of intense meditation—one involving an object of meditation as an aid, and the other without such an aid—are distinguished. The latter is seen to be the aim of Yoga. This state of intense meditation without an aid or a support leads finally to an arrest or restriction of psychical activity, as Patañjali says, and a knowledge of ‘the evolved, the unevolved and the knower’, as Sāṅkhya puts it. Thus both schools set out to arrive at the goal of overcoming suffering and pain, and the means to this end is philosophy as therapeia par excellence.
