Art of Empire: The Roman Frescoes and Imperial Cult Chamber in Luxor Temple is at once a deep investigation into the archaeology of a particular site and a broad survey of late Roman cultural dynamics. Edited by Michael Jones and Susanna McFadden, the lavishly illustrated volume features an introduction and seven chapters that move readers from the greater context for Roman Thebes to a close and nuanced reading of the imperial cult chamber at Luxor Temple. The volume's title, in other words, is reflective of the intellectual topography that the editors traverse.
Art of Empire aims to achieve two objectives. First, the volume, which collates and publishes the results of fieldwork from 2005 through 2008, aims to use historical, epigraphic, archaeological and conservation data to provide the most comprehensive reading to date of the tetrarchic frescoes at Luxor Temple. In so doing, however, the editors provide a depth of insight that allows for a better appreciation of the complexity of local and ‘global’ identities in the Roman Empire. The idea of ‘identity’ has been a central concern of late Roman scholars for more than a decade, but the ‘cultural juxtapositions and interconnectedness’ (2) that complicate monolithic notions of identity are as well attested to here as they are in any earlier contribution.
The volume begins broadly, with an introduction to the Luxor site and the existing scholarship related to it. Perhaps most notably, J. and McF. situate their work as a sort of ‘culmination’ of a nearly two-centuries-old project, begun in 1856 when John Gardner Wilkinson executed several watercolours of the frescoes, here reproduced in an appendix. Successive chapters progressively narrow the reader's focus, beginning with Giovanni Ruffini's account of Roman Thebes, stitched together from relatively few sources. Ruffini does an admirable job providing a rounded picture, all the while acknowledging the limitations imposed by the paucity of evidence. Ch. 2 moves from the broader region to the specific site and convincingly argues for an early date for the frescoes (a.d. 298–302) on the basis of the ‘armature’ of the complex. Ch. 3 dives deeper into the structures on the site, focusing on the architectural modifications to suggest the continued practice of native Egyptian religion. The attempt is valiant, but ‘the fact that most Roman levels around the temple remain unexcavated’ (39) leaves the attempt feeling rather speculative.
Chs 4 and 5 pivot the focus from the built environment to the conservation of the frescoes. A rather extraordinary amount of sleuthing allowed the research team not only to preserve the paintings in situ but also to document the history of preservation (or lack thereof). The diligence of the research is matched in laudability only by the thoughtfulness of treatments and the transparency provided on the decision-making processes taken by the conservation team. It is in these chapters that one can appreciate what true interdisciplinarity can look like at its best.
The volume concludes with two chapters that together offer the key theoretical contributions to the project. Both written by McF., the chapters situate the frescoes stylistically and iconographically within the visual tradition of the adventus, which, given the paintings’ tetrarchic patronage, would been intended to be understood as a panegyric. The idea of visual rhetoric has been advanced considerably of late, notably by the work of Jaś Elsner, but what differentiates McF.’s approach is that her reading is not prescriptive. Elaborating on the integration of post-modern and post-colonial theories into late Roman (art) history, McF. allows for multiple interpretations of these frescoes and questions the extent to which the original intent of the patron would have been intelligible to a local audience. As she puts it: ‘But did the portrait of the emperor actually inspire loyalty among a wider audience, namely, a local Egyptian population that had, in fact, recently protested Rome?’ (151). McF. contrasts the iconography of the frescoes with the papyri of Panopolis in the Thebaid to suggest that the local population's interaction with the emperor may have been more focused on pragmatic concerns such as how to navigate the Roman imperial hierarchy than on articulating Diocletian's glory.
Art of Empire subverts the format of a field report to demonstrate a reality that every scholar of antiquity knows but seldom articulates: the narratives that we construct tend to favour a single reading. Historically our interpretations have favoured the ‘author's voice’; more recently, local, ‘subversive’ voices have been privileged. J. and McF. continue this trend with a level of rigour that should serve as a model for us all.
