The study of consumption has expanded exponentially in recent years. Indeed, it is now twenty-five years since consumer society was arguably born as a subject. In their hugely pioneering work, Neil McKendrick, John Brewer and J. H. Plumb proclaimed The Birth of a Consumer Society. McKendrick in particular was keen to be the father, mother and midwife to his new bouncing baby boy. It is worth recalling his opening words in the book and to explore what he meant by ‘the birth of a consumer society’:
There was a consumer revolution in eighteenth-century England. More men and women than ever before in human history enjoyed the experience of acquiring material possessions. Objects which for centuries had been the privileged possessions of the rich came . . . to be within the reach of a larger part of society than ever before, and, for the first time, to be within the legitimate aspirations of almost all of it.Footnote 1
McKendrick's metaphor of birth was extended such that his baby was not only rooted in his period and chosen case study – eighteenth-century England – but that its parentage was clearly wrested away from previous analysts of early modern commerce.Footnote 2 McKendrick wrote of embryos, false pregnancies and premature births prior to the eighteenth century, and of growth and maturity thereafter. He attempted to set the tone such that other historians would be forced to write of consumer society's adolescence in the nineteenth-century retailing revolution, its full flourishing into adulthood during the twentieth-century's world of mass consumption and its decadent old age in the post-1960s society of the spectacle when our eyesight has deteriorated so badly that we can no longer see beyond the image, the brand and the bright neon lights of our post-modern, late capitalist hyperreality.
How far can we run with this metaphor of birth so beloved by these three men and their baby? Having reached old age, can we now then proclaim its death as a reality for our twenty-first-century lives and perhaps even as a subject for scholarly attention? To do so would seem particularly ridiculous as we live in a world where it seems every need, pleasure and desire is packaged and sold to us, and where the freedom to choose – but never, be warned, the freedom not to choose – is heralded as the philosophy to guide us through the world and the few decades we are given on this planet to truck, barter and exchange. By death, then, its meaning cannot be taken too literally, just as with McKendrick's birth we cannot dismiss the centuries of interactions with the world of goods prior to his consumer revolution.Footnote 3 But death perhaps highlights the end of a particular type of consumer society and to understand this we need to appreciate just what McKendrick believed was being born in the eighteenth century. By consumer society, McKendrick meant a world defined not so much by choice – the watchword of our supposed consumer society today – but access. It was not more choice that is the phenomenon to emphasise in eighteenth-century England, but the fact that there was simply more stuff, for more people, for more of the time: ‘In fact, the later eighteenth century saw such a convulsion of getting and spending, such an eruption of new prosperity, and such an explosion of new production and marketing techniques, that a greater proportion of the population than in any previous society in human history was able to enjoy the pleasures of buying consumer goods.’Footnote 4
It is this birth – about standards of living, about higher rates of consumption, about participation, about more stuff – that will be explored below. Have we witnessed the death of this defining element of consumer society and its replacement with one that emphasises choice, and choice alone?
Certainly, a case can be made that consumer society is not just about the individual's right to choice but about the access society as a whole has to the world of goods. Orthodox economic theory itself speaks of hidden hands and trickle-down effects, such that wealth will ultimately be enjoyed by all. Such optimism about consumption can be detected from a variety of political perspectives. There is a rich tradition of leftwing, radical, progressive, liberal and mainstream thinking which has envisioned consumer society as a benefit for all. Early socialist writers distinguished between necessities and luxuries arguing that unproductive attention to luxurious consumption degraded workers as they were engaged in the production of goods which did not alleviate their own condition: better would it be if the rich spent their money on higher wages as this would increase the demand for food and manufactured goods and bring the benefits of greater trade to all.Footnote 5 Cooperative theorists especially wrote of the consumers' ‘cooperative commonwealth’, where, in the words of the French political economist, Charles Gide, the mutual aid principles of the organic and familial institution of the cooperative society would establish a ‘reign of truth and justice’.Footnote 6 And by the end of the nineteenth century and into the twentieth, consumer-oriented economists in the United States were advocating the gearing of market structures around the basic needs of consumers.Footnote 7
Activists were concerned with the rights of all to participate in consumer society, be these concerned consumers connected to the National Consumers Leagues of continental Europe and North America, the anti-sweating campaigns in Britain or the living wage campaigners of the US labour movement.Footnote 8 By the twentieth century it could be argued that consumerism had become a state project, the protection and defence of consumers' interests having become a legitimate and central aspect of a government's responsibilities to its citizens during an era of expanding democracy. Consumption, or the right to enjoy its pleasures, had become an entitlement to citizens who had made sacrifices in two world wars and expected a share in the societies being reconstructed in their name in the late 1940s and 1950s. The affluent society had to promise more choice for those who could afford it, but also more stuff for those who so far could not. In the United States, the ‘consumer democracy’ has been argued to have been at the heart of post-war planning, whereby consumers were able to exercise their citizenship not only at the ballot box but on a daily basis through their participation in the marketplace.Footnote 9 Consumer democracy might not capture the full range of consumer regimes which emerged in the latter half of the twentieth century, but there was clearly a widely expressed desire to improve standards of living and to ensure that all could participate in the good life. In Germany, Erhard declared a ‘social market’ economy; in Scandinavia, social democracy took account of workers' desires to share in the good life, and even amidst the apparent ascetism of 1950s Britain, there existed a sense of universal entitlement to affluence which surely emerged out of the ‘fair shares’ policies associated with the foundations of the welfare state.Footnote 10
Most dramatically, at the heart of the Cold War was an argument as to which political ideology best provided more goods to more people more of the time. While consumption arguably brought down many of the command economies of eastern Europe, in the affluent post-war decades even the communist party-state paid lip service to the needs of the consumer. Famously, in 1959, at the American Trade Fair in Moscow, Nikita Khrushchev and Richard Nixon got into a schoolboy spat about living standards, trading verbal blows as to which system, communism or capitalism, brought the greatest stuff to the greatest number for the greatest amount of the time. In the consumer societies built after the war – and in the protection regimes established to look over them – there existed a broad-ranging consumer politics which aimed to bring everybody within its grasp. This might have been challenged, coopted and even only half-heartedly followed through in practice, but in the diversity of voices seeking to speak for the consumer, consumption became an activity that was potentially democratic, universal and open to all.Footnote 11
In what follows, it will be argued that the meaning of consumer society has shifted such that the emphasis is no longer on participation for all but on more choice for the individual (that is, for those who can already afford it). This will be demonstrated through a focus on the activities of organised consumers since 1945. Organised consumerism enables the discussion of consumer society, consumer politics and consumer activism to take place at the global level, something which is so far missing from a literature largely dominated by national – and overwhelmingly western – case studies. Today, of course, it is easy and natural for us to consider the politics of consumption to be a global concern. But in the comparative testing consumer movement – that is, of the organisations which have produced Which? in the UK, Que Choisir in France, Test in Germany, Consumer Reports in the US – there has also been a global form of consumer activism. What will become apparent is that the consumer movement spread throughout the developed and the developing world. As it did so, consumer activists became leading players in global civil society, pioneering transnational advocacy networks on issues such as the inappropriate marketing of breastmilk substitutes, the dumping of dangerous and useless pharmaceuticals in the developing world and the use and ingestion of pesticides by farmers in the south and consumers in the north.
Consumer activism therefore has had much to say about needs and affluence, and as a case study it serves a useful purpose in exploring the meaning of consumer society more generally. What the second half of the essay will therefore focus on is the decline of the consumer movement's global, needs-based agenda, a trend which parallels the changing dominant definition of consumption such that it is not inappropriate to speak of the death of a consumer society. Two issues are particularly pertinent to this narrative. First, a brief section will examine the contradictions inherent to the consumer movement's advocacy of a rights-based policy. This opened it up to appropriation as others could pick and choose from the consumer movement's shopping list of rights: and here the right to choice could have very different implications from the right to basic needs. Related to this, a second section will then explore how the consumer movement lost a number of symbolic campaigns to a resurgent anti-regulatory movement increasingly prominent at global fora from the late 1970s. The implications here, it will be argued, have been profound, not least in the promotion of choice as the foremost defining element of consumer society. Basic needs, access and participation have therefore been sidelined as, arguably, have entire nations and consumers in the modern global marketplace. At one level, a glib conclusion could be that the death of consumer society is the death resulting from the oft-quoted figures of the hundreds of millions who live on less than a dollar a day and die from the resulting poverty. But the death for our purposes is really the death of one particular meaning of consumer society, the death of a participatory vision of consumption which McKendrick so eloquently claimed was born in the eighteenth century.
I
The origins of the modern comparative-testing consumer movement lie in interwar America. In 1929, Consumers Research began publishing its Bulletin in order to help consumers overcome their relative ignorance in the marketplace. It rode the wave of a developing consumer consciousness in 1930s America which saw the establishment of a consumer infrastructure within the New Deal bodies and the flourishing of several other consumer organisations.Footnote 12 Following a strike in 1936, Consumers Research was split as several disgruntled staff went off to form Consumers Union. Unsurprisingly for an organisation founded amidst a labour dispute, Consumers Union would pay close attention to the labour conditions of those who made the products featured in its reports, though for the many millions of shoppers who would read Consumer Reports over the course of the twentieth century, it was the quality tests themselves that explain the organisation's tremendous growth and popularity. By the turn of the millennium, the circulation figures of Consumer Reports topped 5 million.Footnote 13
The appeal of comparative testing consumerism was not confined to the United States. After the Second World War, consumer groups began to appear across western Europe as post-war economies shifted into a prolonged period of affluence. First, in France, the Union Fédéral des Consommateurs was formed in 1951. It was followed by Consumentenbond in the Netherlands in 1953, and then the Consumers' Association of the United Kingdom in 1956 and the Association des Consommateurs of Belgium in 1957. These private-testing bodies were joined by a range of state-assisted agencies such as the Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Verbraucherverbände in Germany (1953), the Norwegian Forbrukerrådet (1953) and the Swedish Statens Konsumentråd (1957).Footnote 14
By 1969 the comparative testing magazine had become a feature of most advanced capitalist economies. Consumer Reports led the way with sales of over 1½ million, though by this time sales of Which? by the UK Consumers' Association had topped ½ million also. In Belgium, there were 190,000 members of the two competing consumer groups (Association des Consommateurs and the Union Féminine pour l'Information et la Défense du Consommateur), over a quarter of a million subscribers to Consumentengids in the Netherlands (representing one in ten households), and while the number of actual subscribers to Test in Germany reached only 67,000, total sales of the magazine from the newsstands brought that figure to 190,000. Most impressive were the Scandinavian countries: although their consumer magazines were published by the state rather than by private testing organisations, subscriptions ran into six figures such that Norway could claim the greatest number of sales relative to households in the world.Footnote 15 While a comparative testing magazine had failed to establish itself in the mainstream in France, sales of Que Choisir took off in the early 1970s, such that there were 300,000 subscribers in 1975.Footnote 16 By 1969, there were twenty-two organisations engaged in comparative testing in all of the principal countries of the North Atlantic community. Collectively, they operated on a budget of $20 million (rising to $30 million just three years later), could claim a subscriber base of 3 million and a readership of many millions more.Footnote 17
For affluent consumers, enjoying the world of goods but nevertheless living in an age of post-war dislocation and insecurity, comparative testing offered a means by which they could escape from the alienation of the modern technocracy. It offered the opportunity to establish themselves as an elite who would be able to reconnect with the world of goods, leaving behind the massed ranks of consumers who continued to be uninformed and systematically duped on a daily basis. Marx argued that modern capitalism creates a fetish of the commodity, the product becoming a hieroglyphic which we seek to decode to understand the labour relations behind it.Footnote 18 The publication of endless statistics in comparable tables was precisely an attempt to break that code, though rarely to understand the labour theory of value. Rather, comparative testing consumerism enrolled the skills of the scientist and the engineer to help consumers to reconnect with goods. Testing stood in defiance of the promotional devices of advertising and literally stripped a product down to its constituent parts to render it knowable, understandable and meaningful. It was an attempt to establish consumer sovereignty, but it was a sovereignty never fully appreciated in these terms. Sovereignty meant control and participation in the forms of power that gave meaning to goods. It was always more than being free to choose and it is for these reasons that consumerism can be said to have provided an ideology of far wider significance than just assisting the acquisitive shopper.
There are important points to be made about the consumer movement. It should not be assumed that we are only concerned with the growth of a movement associated with disgruntled middle-class shoppers. What is clear is that the organised testing movement represented the vanguard of a heightened consumer consciousness after the Second World War. In the reconstruction of the post-war economies, politicians had to offer shoppers some protection in this unknown age of affluence. If consumers were to behave with confidence, providing the impetus for economic growth and making all the improvements in technology and productivity worthwhile, then they required assistance and support. They needed to know that in borrowing heavily to purchase a car, a house and all the furniture to arrange inside it, they would not lose everything if the house was found to be shoddily built, that the car broke down on every trip and that the appliances bought for the home harmed those who switched them on. Citizens needed to know that constraints and curbs would be placed on businessmen's behaviour, that capitalism would be kept in check and that, somehow, if not through the authority of choice but the authority of government, the market would still serve the interests of those for whom it claimed to exist.
There are important differences to be noted in the consumer protection regimes built in the 1960s and 1970s. Important work has been conducted comparing the different models of consumer protection pursued by various governments across the affluent capitalist world. For instance, in Germany and Austria a more corporatist set of consumer-producer mechanisms were adopted. In Japan the consumer had to fit in with a strong state and the existence of great producer political power at the centre. While France and the United States have regarded the consumer as a political entity, the US has sought, as with Britain, market-based solutions to their grievances, while France, though sporadically and through much experimentation, has mobilised statist mechanisms to protect the consumer.Footnote 19
But the overall point to emphasise is that states did respond: it is with good reason that many consumer activists look back on these decades as the time when they achieved many of their greatest successes. The growth in consumer protection measures was simply incredible. In Germany, there were just 25 new laws relating to consumer protection from 1945 to 1970, but there were a further 338 adopted by 1978. In France there were similarly just 37 laws and ministerial decrees before 1970, a total which had grown to 94 by 1978.Footnote 20 In Britain, major laws relating to consumer safety, hire purchase, resale price maintenance and trade descriptions appeared in the 1960s, followed by wider regulations on fair trading, credit and unsolicited goods and services in the first half of the 1970s.Footnote 21 In the United States, a flurry of consumer protection laws appeared in the late 1960s relating to the automobile industry, drug safety, meat quality, package labelling, credit reporting, product safety and a whole host of other trade practices.Footnote 22
What was witnessed in the post-war years was a global social movement of consumers that played a large part in the establishment of consumer protection internationally. Indeed, one can even go so far as to suggest that consumer protection straddled the iron curtain. Advocates of consumer protection emerged within economic planning departments of the communist bloc. In East Germany, leaders had to contend with the Soviet emphasis on production goods while acknowledging that many of their citizens looked favourably upon the new prosperity being enjoyed in the west. A distinct consumer lobby emerged in the 1950s in the Ministry for Trade and Provisioning, to be followed with similar lobbies in Poland, Hungary and Yugoslavia.Footnote 23 Indeed, such was the pressure for consumer protection in Poland, that once Solidarity took off, a grassroots consumer movement emerged in 1981, with tens of thousands of members and dozens of consumer clubs around the country.Footnote 24 Even today, for all that consumer protection institutes have been cynically exploited by authoritarian regimes to contain political opposition, consumer protection bodies have proved tremendously popular. In China for instance, one estimate has suggested that the total number of institutional and supervisory contact points for consumers from the village upwards amounts to over 150,000. By 2000, the number of complaints the China Consumer Association was receiving was approaching 1 million a year (by the end of 2001, it had dealt with a total of over 6 million). Because of such discontent, the State Administration for Industry and Commerce set up the ‘12135’ consumer complaints hotline. Within five years, this had managed to intervene on behalf of 2¼ million complaints and is today, after the emergency services, one of the most popular phone numbers in the country.Footnote 25
Following on from these examples, it must also be acknowledged that consumer activism was not just a western phenomenon. In 1960, the leaders of the main European and US groups came together to found the International Organisation of Consumers Unions (IOCU). Originally conceived as an institute to foster cross-national testing procedures for private, subscriber-based consumer organisations, the international body soon grew beyond this limited role.Footnote 26 In the 1960s, it first took on board the agendas of the state-sponsored consumer organisations of Scandinavia and northern Europe and then spread around the world. This growth was initially achieved in relatively prosperous post-colonial societies – New Zealand, South Africa, Hong Kong – but then more dramatically in the developing world.Footnote 27 By 1990, IOCU had extended well beyond the affluent west. The Council consisted of representatives of most western European states, but also of consumer organisations in Argentina, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Jamaica, Japan, Mauritius, Mexico, Poland and South Korea. An Executive had been formed which showed the domination of the founding members (excluding Belgium) though even here South Korea and Mauritius were represented and the Presidency was held by Erna Witoelar of the Yayasan Lembaga Konsumen, Indonesia.Footnote 28 Today, IOCU is called Consumers International, and in November of 2003 it held its Seventeenth World Congress in Lisbon, Portugal. Its headquarters are in London, but there are thriving regional offices in Africa, Asia and Latin America. At the turn of the millennium, it had 253 members from 115 different countries which ranged from all the states of the western world to post-communist eastern Europe and a whole collection of developing states (China, Chad, Guatemala, El Salvador, Gabon, Nigeria, Malawi and Burkina Faso) which, on first instinct, one might suppose had other interests that needed defending than those of consumers.Footnote 29
It is perhaps of no surprise that the consumer movement first took off outside the capitalist west in Asia. In the first part of the twentieth century, consumption was a central tactic of Chinese and Korean nationalists in their struggle against the Japanese, while the swadeshi movement politicised homespun cloth for generations of Indian nationalists inspired, in particular, by Mahatma Gandhi.Footnote 30 In 1956, the Indian Association of Consumers was created, predating many equivalent organisations in Europe. It was followed by equivalent organisations across Southeast Asia. The first was set up in 1963 as the Consumers Federated Groups of the Philippines which emerged out of the women's movement and, around the same time, several other consumer movements appeared in the region, most notably the Consumer Association of Singapore and the Philippine Consumers Movement in 1971, and the Indonesian Consumers Organisation in 1973.Footnote 31
In order to understand this growth of organised consumerism across the developing world it is illustrative to focus on a specific country and on one organisation in particular, the Consumers' Association of Penang. Undoubtedly, consumer activists in Malaysia have been instrumental in promoting an alternative type of consumer politics and pushing for the inclusion of basic needs as a fundamental consumer right. From the 1960s, Malaysian consumer activists have been some of the most prominent in the global south and many of its leaders have gone on to play key roles in IOCU, not least because IOCU's first regional office was based in Penang. However, although there is much that is specific about Malaysian consumer history its attention to questions of poverty make it also representative of policy shifts inspired by consumer movements across Asia, especially India, Indonesia and the Philippines and, subsequent to that, to developments in Latin America and Africa.
The Consumers' Association of Penang (CAP), was set up immediately after the ethnic-based riots of the 1969 general election. CAP soon turned its attention to basic consumer goods and to the issues of adulteration, fraudulent sales, pesticide use and inappropriate marketing, all of which were rife in a country missing the same consumer protection mechanisms enjoyed by western consumers. But as a civil society organisation tolerated by an at times oppressive regime for its supposedly non-radical nature, it soon found itself entering upon questions of social and economic injustice as few other NGOs were in existence to tackle them. Thus by the end of the 1970s, CAP had extended its definition of consumerism to include women's rights, the plight of fishing and farming communities threatened by development projects, the land rights of the Orang Asli (indigenous) community, environmental destruction (CAP has gone on to set up Friends of the Earth Malaysia), and the appropriate direction to take for an expanding economy which at times has seemed more concerned with prestige projects than promoting the standard of living of the majority poor.Footnote 32
By the mid-1980s, CAP had developed a consumerism which posited consumers as the expert commentators on the whole nature of economic development. CAP has gone on to outline a general critique of global economic policy which champions the rights of developing nations to enjoy the profits of their own resources. Indeed, to this end, CAP has established Third World Network, now a leading player in global civil society and whose economist, Martin Khor, still an officer with CAP, has achieved a prominence at events organised by the European and World Social Forums. At the heart of this politics is an assumption that development projects should be focused on providing the majority of the population with access to a basic standard of living, rather than assuming a trickle-down effect from the high profits granted to a few well-positioned rent-seekers.
Here then lies a wider critique of economic globalisation which offers the chance for the consumer to fight for the right to basic needs as the main platform of a human rights manifesto which places as much importance on economic and social rights as political and civil rights. Indeed, this is precisely what has occurred, especially through individuals such as Anwar Fazal, one of the founders of CAP, who went on to become the regional director for IOCU from 1974 to 1990 and who, from 1978 to 1984, also served as the international movement's president. During this time, when he served as both figurehead and employee, IOCU's centre of gravity shifted firmly from its supposed headquarters in The Hague to the regional office in Penang, and IOCU came to be articulating an agenda more in line with other development agencies than with the concerns of affluent shoppers who purchased the testing magazines of Que Choisir, Which?, Test and Consumer Reports.
By the late 1970s, then, the consumer movement had been revitalised by its developing world initiatives. This, in turn, meant it had come to adopt a far wider social and economic agenda at the global level than is usually assumed, and it resulted in the consumer movement becoming something of a leader among the global community of international non-governmental organisations by the 1980s. Most importantly, for the argument of this essay, it meant that consumer activists themselves were articulating a vision of consumer society far removed from one that emphasised the satisfaction of individual acquisitiveness.
This is seen no more clearly than in the campaigning tactics adopted by the global movement. IOCU brought a number of issues to international prominence through the creation of networks; that is collections of pre-existing organisations prepared to work together on a specific issue. Although campaigning networks had clearly existed at the national level for some time, and more general networks – or federations – existed within the labour and women's movements, the creation of single-issue, international campaign networks in the late 1970s was an important precedent which in many ways still has a fundamental influence on the nature of global civil society today.Footnote 33 Most prominently, IOCU initiated the International Baby Food Action Network (IBFAN) in 1979, Health Action International (HAI) in 1981 and the Pesticide Action Network (PAN) in 1982. Led and administered by IOCU, the networks brought together a variety of NGOs and enabled many smaller groups to have a say in which issues should be brought to the attention of the UN. They overrode any more fundamental and political differences that might have existed within the different branches of the international NGO community and constituted an agreement by diverse entities to set aside their more general agendas in order to focus specifically on one particular problem.Footnote 34
Moreover, the networks emerged out of the direct experience of developing world consumer activists. Recognising the limited resources of consumer groups in various national contexts, leaders such as Anwar Fazal urged greater collaboration among diverse civil society groups: ‘the value of such partnerships is that while you are sharing costs and manpower you are also obtaining entré into other elite and important groups in the community and enlarging their consumer consciousness’.Footnote 35 As president of IOCU, he was aware of the mutual benefits to consumer and non-consumer groups alike in coming together in networks. Following his establishment of IBFAN he realised he had created a model for other international campaigns that would be copied not only by the consumer movement but global civil society as a whole: today, networks are generally recognised as a key campaign tactic of global activism.Footnote 36 According to Fazal, IBFAN had ‘brought together a variety of social and development action groups, each independent and yet acting in complete empathy and concert’.Footnote 37 It connected the consumer movement to a number of NGOs, while these in turn were able to unite beneath the outwardly respectable umbrella of organised consumerism.
By the 1980s, therefore, the consumer movement had achieved a global prominence not generally recognised in existing accounts of the history of consumer society. Through the logic of networking, the consumer movement presented itself as a neutral entity, to which other NGOs could attach themselves without invoking wider divisions based on broader value frameworks. As such, networks would enable socialists and Christians and conservatives and radicals to come together on specific subjects, just as the global consumer movement contained elements from across the political spectrum within its own national organisations. In addition, it enabled consumer politics to become directed by the concerns of the world's poor rather than those of the world's rich. Pesticides, breastmilk substitutes and pharmaceuticals were products far removed from those that filled the pages of western consumer testing magazines, yet they – and other such basic necessities – came to dominate the global consumer movement's agendas, creating a politics of consumption as much attuned to the interests of those excluded from consumer society as those already benefiting from its packaged pleasures.
II
So far, then, we have a story of relative success, global expansion and even political influence, at least within the internal dynamics of a global civil society of non-governmental organisations. Consumer activism had spread all around the world, creating an international body with a reach many other more prominent NGOs could only admire at the time. Through its networks, it had begun to take a lead in global civil society, combining the respectability it enjoyed in the global north – which gave it a foothold at the United Nations – with the radicalism that drove its campaigns from the global south. In addition, it could claim for itself some notable successes. Not only had consumer protection been established as a mainstream political principle and a reality for many millions of consumers, but it could claim some victories on the global stage. It had helped develop in 1982 a UN ‘Consolidated List of Products whose Consumption and/or Sale have been Banned, Withdrawn, Severely Restricted or Not Approved by Governments.’Footnote 38 It enjoyed constant representation at various UN agencies and it had long been an active discussant on the Codex Alimentarius Commission which dealt with food standards. At ECOSOC it was asked to provide written statements on a number of issues, from science and technology, to disability rights, to education programmes and the legal aspects of consumer protection.Footnote 39 Finally, in 1985, it achieved one of its greatest successes with the passing of the UN Guidelines on Consumer Protection which have become the model law for countless consumer protection regimes subsequently implemented in countries all over the world.Footnote 40
The question that therefore remains is what happened? Today, the influence of the consumer movement has been eclipsed by many other activist groups and by huge gatherings such as at the World and European Social Forums. IOCU does not enjoy the same name recognition as NGOs such as Amnesty International, and nor has it been able to attract the same level of media attention and public fascination in its campaigns as those initiated by Greenpeace, Médecins sans Frontières or Oxfam. In addition, its attention to basic needs and standards of living represents a form of consumer politics which has arguably been eclipsed by other visions of consumer society. Indeed, it has been some time since ‘consumerism’ itself was generally understood to refer to its original meaning of organised political action: nowadays, it has become a cultural term used to describe the symptoms rather than the cures for consumer society's ills.Footnote 41
In order to understand the relative decline of the consumer movement and the attendant shift in the meaning of consumer society, it is necessary to pay attention to two particular issues. First, we can detect a retreat of the consumer movement from some of its more radical undercurrents and a consolidation of its core philosophy. On 15 March 1962, President John F. Kennedy made a speech to the US Congress in which he acknowledged the responsibility of government to respond to the key concerns of consumer activists. Most crucially, he listed four consumer rights which he took to be the heart of the political philosophy of the consumer. These were the right to safety, the right to be informed, the right to choose and the right to be heard.Footnote 42 These four consumer rights were adopted as the central pillars of IOCU policy and the date chosen for the World Consumer Rights Day was the anniversary of Kennedy's coming out into the consumerist fold. Moreover, this rights-based perspective became the basis for political consumerism as a whole. They can be found at the heart of national consumer protection systems the world over. They form the basis of European Union consumer policy and they have been replicated in the UN Guidelines on Consumer Protection.Footnote 43
However, over the decades the consumer movement has also added incrementally to these four rights. Particularly as it has embraced the concerns and interests of developing world consumers – attuned to the needs of the poor as much as the affluent – it has incorporated other consumer rights into its operating rationale such that by the end of the 1970s IOCU had begun to campaign for a list of eight. In addition to Kennedy's original four, IOCU added the right of redress and the right to consumer education. More challengingly, it had also added the right to a healthy environment; and the right to basic needs. The emphasis placed on needs reflected the agendas of figures such as Fazal. Symbolically, in a publicity poster from the 1980s, the Penang office deliberately excluded the right to choice from its published list of eight rights. Few people at the time noticed, but nothing could have more clearly expressed the reorientation of the world's consumer movement to the needs of the poor rather than to the desires of the affluent.Footnote 44 For those consumer activists in the developing world this message was that choice was the privilege of the affluent. They did not deny that choice in itself was a good thing and that it was intimately bound up with notions of freedom, it was just that, for them, it was simply not a priority. Fazal and others believed that the rights to basic needs were far more important concerns for the majority of the world's consumers.
Yet by the end of the 1980s there was a retreat from this prioritisation of the right to basic needs over the right to choice. The consumer movement had always been made up of those committed liberal internationalists of the post-war decades who remained optimistic about the potential of such intergovernmental organisations as the United Nations. They embraced the basic needs approach of the developing world activists and allowed these agendas to dominate their international body, particularly as the UN launched its development decades and the New International Economic Order seemed to give a priority to developing world nations. But by the 1980s, many of these early activists were reaching retirement and many of the western private testing bodies had suffered under the economic recession of the 1980s. This meant more commercially oriented management structures were set in place to help ensure the testing magazines continued to thrive. This resulted in a retreat into testing which, at the international level, meant there existed a renewed pressure to cater to the interests of magazine subscribers, rather than the needs of the world's poor consumers.
Moreover, for many moderates in the global north, many of the core aims of the consumer movement had been achieved, especially through the consumer protection regimes that had been put in place in various national contexts across the capitalist west. These activists shunned the radicalism emanating from the developing world and, since they held the trump card of providing most of the finance for the international organisation, they began to reign in the consumer movement from its more aggressive tactics. It meant, at the national level, that prominent consumer leaders such as Ralph Nader would no longer ally themselves with bodies such as Consumers Union and, at the global level, that radicals such as Malaysia's Anwar Fazal would be ousted from the movement. Alongside this, IOCU also disassociated itself from the networks thereby cutting off its links with broader sectors of global civil society. Instead, the concerns of the affluent began to predominate once more and here the notion of rights becomes crucial. The consumer movement has not given up on basic needs and environmental activism – it still does incredibly interesting work in these fields. But what a list of rights does is create essentially a shopping list upon which different emphases can be placed on each item. So, while basic needs topped the list in the 1970s and 1980s, the right to choice has slowly crept back up the agenda. In 1981 Anwar Fazal had deliberately excluded choice. After he left the movement, choice would return with renewed energy and importance.
The danger is, though, that anyone can be in favour of choice, and this has enabled other spokesgroups for the consumer to emerge: they too can pick from the shopping list of consumer rights and be seen to be promoting the consumer cause. This brings us on to a second and perhaps more important reason for the decline of the consumer movement and the attendant redefinition of the dominant meaning of consumer society. This is a narrative not so much of decline or retreat, but of defeat.
To understand this defeat, our narrative must return to the United States. In the 1960s, organised consumerism had been revived by the ascendancy of Ralph Nader's public interest movement. This had resulted in a whole raft of legislation introduced by Presidents Johnson and Nixon which substantially altered the regulatory character of American politics and American business. In just a few years after the publication of Unsafe at Any Speed, a flurry of legislation was introduced on behalf of consumers, including the Fair Packaging and Labelling Act 1966, the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act 1966 and the Wholesome Meat Act 1967. It was bolstered by the strengthening of existing regulatory agencies, such as the Food and Drug Administration, and the establishment of new federal bodies such as the Environmental Protection Agency and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.Footnote 45
It was precisely because of these successes that public interest activism, organised consumerism and Naderism were soon matched by an anti-regulatory backlash that would seek to rein in the perceived encroachment of the state upon the free market. By the early 1970s, the downturn in the global economy meant far fewer US corporations were prepared to tolerate the perceived luxury of government regulation. Beginning with attacks on Nader himself, business groups, journalists, politicians and intellectuals began to react against the consumer protection measures introduced by Johnson and Nixon. Within a few years, an assertive, well-financed and well coordinated assault on regulation as a whole had been launched.Footnote 46
This anti-regulatory movement was strongly associated with the organisations of American big business such as the Business Roundtable and those rightwing think-tanks which would later be described as ‘neo-conservative’ (for example, the American Enterprise Institute and the Heritage Foundation).Footnote 47 In the 1970s, they engaged in a symbolic battle with Nader and the organised consumer movement over a proposed Consumer Protection Agency which would have meant America's model of consumer protection would have more closely resembled the social democratic principles implemented by European governments. The Consumer Protection Agency Bill was ultimately defeated but it is the nature of the defeat that was most impressive. It involved a massive mobilisation of corporate interests against the consumer movement, the influx of corporate lawyers into Washington, the establishment of numerous political action committees and sustained assaults on the media, public opinion and Capitol Hill legislators. Tip O'Neill, Speaker of the House from 1977, claimed that in twenty-five years he had ‘never seen such extensive lobbying’ and subsequent studies by political scientists have concluded that, along with the Labour Law Reform Bill and the Economic Recovery Tax Act, the Consumer Protection Agency Bill assumed a symbolic importance for both the consumer and the anti-regulatory movements.Footnote 48
The implications of the ‘corporatisation’ of US politics did not end in Washington. It constituted a more general victory of free market principles which would result in the export of an anti-regulatory and pro-big business agenda on to the world stage. Ronald Reagan came into power on the back of a resurgent right and supported by a number of key neoconservative think-tanks which capitalised on the anti-regulatory mood they had helped foster among the US public. The American Enterprise Instititute turned its attention to the perceived problems of regulation at the international level. It attacked the ‘global straitjacket’ imposed on business by bodies such as UNCTAD while it accused WHO and the NGOs which lobbied it of ‘biting the hand that cures them’.Footnote 49 In the attempts to impose codes of conduct on the marketing of pharmaceuticals and baby foods, the American Enterprise Institute accused bodies supporting the consumer movement's campaigns of an implicit ‘colonialism’ since they assumed that indigenous peoples – now operating as independent states – were ‘incapable of governing themselves’.Footnote 50
The Heritage Foundation likewise launched a comprehensive critique against the institutions of global governance. From 1982, it systematically monitored the work of the UN, seemingly seeking to undermine the entire infrastructure.Footnote 51 It published a series of reports attacking the policies of the World Bank, UNESCO, the World Health Organisation and UNCTAD as well as the intellectual underpinnings of regulation as a whole. They claimed the UN was persistently ‘anti-West, anti-American, and anti-free market’.Footnote 52 It too turned its attention to the consumer movement. It argued that multinational corporations were becoming ‘the first victim of the UN war on free enterprise’. This was being directed behind the scenes by ‘an assault from a growing and potentially dangerous, internationally based, and self-styled “consumerist” movement that already is helping set the agenda at various UN agencies’. Specifically, IOCU was identified as the source of an ‘anti-capitalist and anti-free enterprise bias, which in the past decade has grown to alarming proportions within UN documents and literature’.Footnote 53 IOCU had developed a campaigning style based around networks which placed consumers in alliance with trade unions, church-based groups and less developed countries in order to promote codes of conduct which attacked specific industries. The pamphlet amounted to a broad-ranging swipe against the UN, the New International Economic Order and the Commission on Transnational Corporations but which eventually homed in on ‘the extremist wing of the interational consumerist movement’, especially IOCU.Footnote 54 Heritage identified Anwar Fazal as the main cause of the problem, due to his spawning of a new wave of consumer organisations such as IBFAN, PAN, HAI and Consumer Interpol and his supposed ‘distortions designed to undermine the MNCs and private sector approach to development’.Footnote 55 It concluded by urging the Reagan administration to ‘become more aware of the dangers posed to US-based multinational firms by the internationalist consumerist movement’ and to oppose all efforts to implement codes of conduct.Footnote 56 This should be achieved, it was argued, by increasing industry participation in UN negotiations and within the US Mission, proposing weak counter-proposals and by forging international alliances with other states even if this meant making it ‘abundantly clear to those countries that the US does not look favourably upon their support for the anti-free enterprise, restrictive initiatives’.Footnote 57
The consequences of this new international anti-regulatory agenda were soon apparent. American government opposition to the codes of conduct proposed by IOCU at the UN was both consistent and out of line with majority opinion. Often, only a handful of countries opposed consumer measures: the United States was always one of these and frequently the sole dissenting voice. In the early 1980s, the consumer movement was still able to mobilise global civil society and government missions at the UN around its key demands and it achieved notable successes: the UN Guidelines on Consumer Protection were perhaps the culmination of a series of codes of conduct (e.g., on the marketing of breastmilk substitutes) which had been drawn up in the years previously. However, the new international agenda meant that the consumer movement's next campaign, a Code of Conduct on Transnational Corporations, was doomed to fail. This initiative had its origins in the early 1970s following the investigation by the UN's Group of Eminent Persons into the role of multinational corporations in the Chilean political process. By the 1980s, the consumer movement was leading the campaign to restrict the activities of these companies and the Code of Conduct, although voluntary, was to be the first stage in achieving this. However, the opposition the consumer movement faced from both US diplomats and advisors, many of whom had direct links with the exact same business and neoconservative groups that had defeated the Consumer Protection Agency Bill in the 1970s, meant that the Code of Conduct never stood a chance. The campaigns persisted, eventually petering out in the early 1990s when the US State Department was able to claim, in a telex to all US embassies, that the Code was ‘a relic of another era’, supported only by those countries that held to outmoded notions of foreign investment.Footnote 58
The consumer movement was clearly defeated on this matter, but the nature of the defeat needs to be emphasised. Because just as the consumer movement was seeking a regulatory system through the UN Economic and Social Council, the entire structure of global trade was being renegotiated through the Uruguay Round, which would ultimately culminate in the creation of the World Trade Organisation and the renewed emphasis placed on the World Bank and the IMF in determining the rules and consequences of trade and opened markets. If we are to insist, therefore, that the consumer movement was defeated by big business in negotiations over a Code of Conduct, then this was not simply a defeat on a level playing field. But neither was it a defeat because the goal posts had been moved, as they repeatedly were, during the various stages of the Code's progress. Rather it was a defeat in which the consumer movement looked to be playing alone on the field provided by the UN, unaware that there was no longer an opposition. Multinational enterprise and advocates of de-regulation, meanwhile, had joined a game being played in another stadium. For them, and for governments supporting the system of trade liberalisation being promoted by the US, the real action would come to take place at the World Trade Organisation and not the UN. Here was a new arena for governing world trade in which the consumer movement would have some considerable difficulty in both understanding the rules and finding either a role to play or a seat from which to spectate.
The comparison of the influence of NGOs at the UN with their influence at the WTO is quite spectacular. NGO influence at the UN was ruled by a complex system of category status recognition which determined how much of a say NGOs could have in intergovernmental debates. Many hundreds of NGOs, often spearheaded by the consumer movement, had access to the seats of power. At the WTO, however, that access was reduced to nothing. Over the years, NGOs have managed to negotiate some sort of relationship with the WTO, but it still remains minimal and much was perhaps lost for NGOs in the meantime. For instance, it became clear in 1996 that the WTO was not going to allow NGO participation and would restrict publication of most of its documents for six months.Footnote 59 Indeed, it would take until May 1997 for the WTO to actually listen to NGOs: a year earlier, at a symposium on trade and the environment, government ministers at the WTO meeting simply failed to turn up. The contrast with the 1980s, when IOCU had a prominent impact on global institutions, could not have been more stark.
III
It is these two aspects of the organised consumer movement's recent history – retreat and defeat – that enables us to reflect more broadly on the changing meaning of consumer society. I began this essay with birth. The death I therefore conclude with is the growing irrelevance of the consumer movement to the global regulation of the marketplace. At the same time, its earlier vision of the meaning of consumer society – based as much upon necessity as affluence – has become increasingly sidelined for reasons as much to do with its own operating logic as the criticisms made from it by outside forces. Nevertheless, it has meant that other aspects of consumer society – and especially individual choice – have assumed a greater prominence which has eclipsed the older social welfare aspects of living in an age of consumption and mass affluence. The decline of the global consumer movement therefore parallels and partially explains the death of this older meaning of consumer society.
Death, of course, is a common pessimistic trope of critiques of consumer society. It lurks in the supposed emptiness of our souls, in the decay of our sensibilities, in the ‘malaise’ of our values that President Carter even castigated his fellow Americans for in his famous ‘crisis of confidence’ speech of 1979 when he warned that ‘We've learned that piling up material goods cannot fill the emptiness of lives which have no confidence or purpose.’Footnote 60
It is tempting to conclude on a similar pessimistic note, as so many other historians have found themselves doing. But in the decline of the organised consumer movement it is better not to see in its changing fortunes a shift towards an inevitable consumerist dystopian end point marked by individual acquisitiveness and the collapse of the social fabric, but further evidence of the constant re-politicisation of consumption that has taken place whenever people have identified themselves as consumers. Prior to the movement studied in this article were the millions of free traders, cooperators, cost-of-living campaigners and fair wage advocates. Subsequent to the events examined here have been the growth of ethical and green consumer movements, the explosion of fair trade and the widespread politics of consumption emerging out of the latest trends within anti-globalisation protest. The point is that although individual choice may well have replaced the standard of living as the benchmark for measuring the success of consumer society, this is just one phase in the evolving history of consumer society which will continue for many decades to come.
It therefore seems pertinent to finish by returning to another classic text on consumer society, the fiftieth anniversary of which occurs this year, the same year as the hundredth anniversary of the author's birth. In The Affluent Society, published in 1958, John Kenneth Galbraith left us in no doubt as to the real choices facing us as consumers. In a famous passage he pointed to the problems lurking behind America's newfound prosperity in its new affluent age. He described a family out for a picnic in the countryside supposedly living the American dream, but ‘Just before dozing off on an air mattress, beneath a nylon tent, amid the stench of decaying refuse, they may reflect vaguely on the curious unevenness of their blessings. Is this, indeed,’ Galbraith asked, ‘the American genius?’Footnote 61
Galbraith's commentary seems as pertinent today as it did in 1958. His point is not that we should criticise or condemn consumer society as a whole. Indeed, it has actually done much to improve people's lives and is undoubtedly a good thing, especially for those consumer activists who flocked to the comparative testing organisations in the 1950s. Rather, the point is that we should question its meaning and remember that there is more than one consumer society. So Galbraith's passage actually reminds us of one of the real choices facing consumer society: between more private or more public goods. The choices that we are confronted with today are not actually choices: they are preferences, they are not the choices which we must face when trading off climate change against higher rates of consumption; when balancing the needs of the world's poor with the needs of the world's rich. Instead, we are faced with an impoverished set of choices: and there is evidence that these are choices which we do not actually want.
The choice is not between equally attractive pre-packaged commodities and services: remember, Buridan's ass starved to death when confronted with two equally attractive piles of hay. The choice is between the competing demands of affluence and necessity. These two competing aspects of consumer society are embodied in the problems faced by affluence by rapidly expanding economies such as China's, and the problems faced by those who cannot even achieve a most basic quality of life, as in so many countries in Africa. But in the death throes of consumption, where will the consumer voice be heard? As the global economy rushes headlong to embrace the consumer society of China, what of Africa and the problems its consumers face which, for so long, had been the central concern of both consumer activists and those planners and bureaucrats who helped shape the post-war international consumer society?
To return to our opening text, there was an optimism about The Birth of a Consumer Society. McKendrick's consumers might have been concerned with status and conspicuous consumption. But like Mandeville's bees in The Grumbling Hive, there was the expectation that greed and self-interest – our private vices – would lead to the greater public benefits of economic growth and greater prosperity for all. For many consumer activists over the next three centuries, this has simply not been the case. Too many consumers have been left behind in the long-run perspectives provided by the invisible hand. This is why basic needs have been so central to the creation and the politics of consumer societies around the world. Standards of living and meeting basic consumer interests do not quite face the challenge of the environmental concerns of many of today's ethical shoppers, but if they are left behind then what we are witnessing is the deletion of a basic goal of consumer society, shared by consumer activists such as America's Ralph Nader and Malaysia's Anwar Fazal, but also by politicians such as Nixon and Krushchev who, by arguing in the kitchen, demonstrated the very real links between the politics of the housewife and the politics of the entire world's development more generally. The deletion, now, though is not like Fazal's deletion of the right to choice, but it is the deletion of the right to basic needs. Of course, to proclaim the death of consumer society is absurd. But if we allow the insertion an indefinite article such as in McKendrick's Birth of a Consumer Society, then perhaps it is valid to conclude now with a Death of a Consumer Society. There is a degree of pessimism here, but it is by no means the end of the story.
