When Rains Became Floods is the translation of Memorias de un soldado desconocido: autobiografía y antropología de la violencia (Lima and Mexico City: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos and Universidad Iberoamericana, 2012), an autobiography by a former child soldier of the Shining Path who, when still a child, was integrated into the Peruvian military, and then later became a Franciscan priest, and finally a PhD candidate in Anthropology at the Ibero-American University in Mexico. The Spanish original instantly received much acclaim in Peru, in academic circles and beyond, because despite there being many testimonies by perpetrators, held in a government archive, none had been publicly circulated: Gavilán's was the first book of its kind to be published. It is now commonly paired with José Carlos Agüero's memoir-essay, Los rendidos: sobre el don de perdonar (Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos, 2015).
In a country where the experience of political violence between 1980 and 2000 is still a contentious issue, often hung between polarised and simplified view points, the book's novelty is to offer a detailed and personal view of the conflict that does not allow for stereotype or generalisation about either the Shining Path or the Peruvian military. It also offers insights into topics shrouded, in the public imagination, with an air of mystery, such as how ordinary people could have been willing to perpetrate violence and risk their own lives for the Shining Path's cause. Gavilán joined the organisation as an illiterate, Quechua-speaking, monolingual 12 year-old from rural Ayacucho (where the violence originated and was most intense) in 1983. He did so out of a combination of enthusiasm for what seemed then to be an imminent future of social justice, to be brought about by an organisation whose wanton violence had yet to become evident to all; and admiration for his elder brother, who had joined the organisation before him, leaving behind a life of few opportunities for change or self-realisation. Gavilán was with the organisation for over two years; he narrates the overwhelming violence he witnessed and participated in, as well as experiences of extreme hunger and precariousness. He was captured by the military and could have been killed, as so many Shining Path prisoners were, but his life was spared. He was given lodging at the military base and provided with a school education. He remained with the army, witnessing many terrible crimes perpetrated at their base, until 1995, when he joined the Franciscans.
During his time with the order, he began to write his story. He continued to add to it as the years passed, and turned his manuscript into its published form as a doctoral student, with the collaboration of his supervisor, Yerko Castro. Divided into four chapters, one for each phase of his life, it is written in a plain style tinged with a romantic pantheism which evokes an Andean appreciation of an intimate relationship between nature and the human. Only at the worst moments of his experience does this connection of human and nature seem to fail: ‘Sometimes hills do not speak, they are so far removed from us, like insensitive humans or our compassionless leaders’ (p. 36). The text keeps to the narration of events and depictions of surroundings, restraining from self-reflection except in the first few paragraphs and the final chapter, where the author and the person narrated come together in the present.
The overall thrust of the text is towards a liberal humanism; after spending most of his life in institutions that organise individuals’ lives around a collective cause, Gavilán wants to ‘live in the world like any ordinary person’ (p. 85). The text does not, however, fall into the standardised accusations against Shining Path or the state. His gratitude towards the military is evident. On the other hand, he continues to uphold the desire that led him and others to take on the Shining Path's ideology, a desire that reappears in his decision to leave the army for the Church, namely, a desire to participate in the creation of a better world.
The original is written in Andean-Spanish (which carries traces of Quechua syntax), combined at times with learned references and even Latin; moreover, the temporality of the narration is complex, as Gavilán frequently uses the discourse he upheld at the time of his life that he is narrating. It is, therefore, a challenging text to translate. My impression is that this translation has prioritised ease and accessibility, and the text flows well as a result. However, by moments, this translation is literal where it perhaps need not be, and by others, when Gavilán has narrated something in a complex and intriguing way, the translation is to Standard English. Thus, at times, the rich suggestiveness of the Andean-Spanish Gavilán uses is lost.
This edition includes the original Foreword by the late Peruvian anthropologist Carlos Iván Degregori, which gives some insight into what such a text means for its Peruvian readership. The original introductory essay by Yerko Castro has been replaced by an Introduction by Orin Starn, which explains the history of the Shining Path insurgency in Peru for an international readership unfamiliar with it, and overviews the narrative's highlights. Its footnotes provide useful bibliographical orientation to readers who would like to expand their understanding of the context. This edition also adds a helpful index, and includes the photographs present in the original edition, plus a few extra, in a larger format, allowing more details to be seen.
All in all, the book is of great relevance for those interested in political violence and cultural memory in Peru, and the experience of child soldiers and young militants anywhere. It is accessible to those who do not have previous knowledge of the context, such as students, and indeed could be recommended as a first read for those who would like to learn about it, in conjunction with texts such as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Final Report (Lima: CVR, 2003). Perhaps, also, its availability in English could serve to promote its study in comparison to similar texts from other places. If, however, readers are interested in interpreting how it represents at the level of language or style rather than solely what is being represented, then they would be best advised to refer to the Spanish original.
