Since the turn of the century there has been an increase in conflicts in Latin America, and in particular in the Amazon, related to oil and gas and to natural resources in general. Why? Patricia I. Vásquez, an energy practitioner with 15 years of experience in the region, points to ‘structural flaws’ in national governance systems and to the ‘transient triggers’ of local conflicts. In the making and escalation of conflict, the weaknesses of formal institutions combine with local stressors related to the quality of civil and business organisations. Vásquez's argument is built on a comparison of Colombia, Ecuador and Peru and draws on hundreds of interviews with actors directly involved in conflicts. The book helps to fill a notable gap in knowledge on contemporary resource conflict and indigenous peoples in the Andean Amazon.
The book starts with a historical overview of oil and gas-related conflicts. Today, of the studied cases, Peru and Ecuador have the larger number of conflicts and the most violent ones, according to the data gathered. These contemporary resource conflicts in the Amazon are directly linked to the expansion of the oil industry that took place in the 1970s. Old political conflicts concerned the foreign or national ownership of oil. New political conflicts, however, are linked to local communities, indigenous ones in particular, contesting resource development in general and oil development in particular. The development of oil in the Amazon coincided with the emergence of the question of the rights of indigenous peoples. As a consequence, the global political economy of extractives entered a new era.
However, the advancement of environmental and indigenous peoples’ rights in the Amazon is not only a product of changes in international conditions such as variations in oil prices or the influence of transnational movements. Vásquez identifies national contextual conditions common to the three Amazons. In chapter 3, she points to structural flaws in the national legal systems and in formal institutions. Although each country has specific characteristics, they share common problems including suboptimal decentralisation processes, the underdevelopment of local government capacities, the contradictions and flaws of the institutional system, and the corruption and ineffectiveness of the judiciary. The author examines each structural flaw but draws largely on secondary sources. Here the book lacks an ethnographically informed account of these institutional features: interviews with local actors could have been used to illustrate the claims based on the secondary sources.
A highlighted structural flaw is the contradictory institutional environment set by the state. The author borrows from Guillaume Fontaine the term ‘state schizophrenia’ to refer to the confusing policy that calls for environmental protection of specific areas while at the same time allowing for the expansion of the oil frontier within those zones. The emblematic examples of state schizophrenia were the seven oil blocks established within the borders of the Yasuní Park in Ecuador – but the Correa government appears now to have decided to get rid of state schizophrenia and to favour oil. As this suggests, the state is a non-monolithic social construct, where diverse public and private agendas are reinvented.
In relation to the failures of the national judiciary systems, the book stresses the growing importance of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Rulings by the Inter-American legal system are seen as instrumental in shaping domestic politics and ultimately influencing national legal systems. It is not the only international resource for legal action. Emblematic cases such as that of Texaco have also been litigated in the United States. Back in the domestic sphere, the author praises institutional innovations such as the Office of the Ombudsman in Peru for their positive role in the diffusion of conflict and the promotion of justice.
In chapter 4, Vásquez identifies four common local stressors of conflict: the level of radicalisation or cohesion of the organisations involved in the dispute, the extent and nature of civil society involvement, the availability and efficiency of institutional mediation, and the strategies of oil companies for incorporating safeguards or for delivering services to the affected communities. The development of this insightful characterisation is unsatisfactory: each subject deserved a chapter of its own. Again, more extended use of primary sources would have been desirable.
Can this situation be solved? Can the structural flaws be corrected and the local stressors managed better? Vásquez is optimistic with respect to dealing with the local stressors of group dynamics. The lessons, her research suggests, are that local stressors can be softened with the participation of legitimated ombudsman-type entities to facilitate dialogue, the expansion of participatory mechanisms for designing local development projects, the ‘optimisation’ of oil revenue redistribution and ‘the completion of social and environmental mappings of the areas to be developed prior to the granting of licenses’.
Vásquez is less optimistic about the ability to fix structural flaws, which are decades-old constructs. These sets of problems demand heavy lifting: the ill-implemented decentralisation, the weak local capacities, the widespread corruption and clientelism, and the weak presence of the central government and poor communication among state bodies are not easy to solve.
The author makes clear that her goal is to contribute to understanding conflict dynamics and to advance usable policy prescriptions. She argues that the development of contextual knowledge is needed for both the study of problems and the design of solutions. Investigations should delve into the particular socio-political and economic scenarios of each conflict, including the history of past disputes in the area: ‘it is primarily these particular and very contextual dynamics of the dispute that need to be addressed to reduce the risk of violence’ (p. xvii). But Vásquez maintains that resolving local conflicts will require a strong political commitment that goes beyond ensuring that oil and gas revenues are distributed in an equitable way. The solution will not be purely economic and of the one-size-fits-all variety. A new social contract is being rewritten ‘between indigenous communities and the rest of society’ (p. 138), she observes.
