I tend to think of economics as a science of two rigors. The first rigor, which I propose to call ‘choice–theoretic’ rigor, includes the logic of individual choice and the logic of interpersonal interaction. The second rigor is technical—it is the mathematical and statistical language that economists often use to convey their ideas pertaining to the first type of rigor. While the two rigors of economics are, in principle, separable, the present collection of some of the major papers of Robert Lucas illustrates the unifying tendency between them. Lucas himself is conscious about the unification, and he highlights the related progress in the technique of general equilibrium analysis; he considers it to be one of the most important improvements in economics over the last hundred years (pp. 515–516).
In conjunction with the emphasis that Lucas puts on the technique itself, the collection of papers raises a number of related themes. The first theme is an inquiry about the place of money in general equilibrium analysis. Frictionless versions of general equilibrium models make money redundant, and, although money can be introduced into such models by assuming frictions, different frictions lead to different interpretations of respective models. Lucas, referring to Clower (1963), repeatedly chooses the friction of cash-in-advance constraint, which dictates that goods can be purchased in the current period only with money received beforehand (cf. chs. 3, 6, 8, 10, and 12). Models with the cash-in-advance constraint have two important interpretations. First, money in these models approximates Lucas’ view of money in the real world, where he considers it to be a “second-rate” asset that people use to overcome transactions costs of market exchanges. Second, Lucas points out that since we often use models of barter economies as approximations of monetary economies, we also have to believe that the two types of models tend to correspond to each other. Models of monetary economies with cash-in-advance constraints are consistent with this belief because they can replicate the tendency of monetary economies towards equilibria of corresponding, frictionless, barter economies. The two interpretations of the role of money in cash-in-advance models contrast, for example, with interpretations of the role of money in Samuelson’s overlapping generations model. Money, in this latter model, is not a second-rate asset that people use to approximate the efficient equilibrium outcome; the presence of money is rather a defining characteristic of the efficient equilibrium (pp. 62–63).
While Lucas finished his graduate school at Chicago as a committed Keynesian (p. 503), and Milton Friedman was never his official teacher in a macro class (p. 508), Lucas’ work carries a substantial monetarist message related to neutrality and non-neutrality of money, which is also the second major theme of the book. A key starting point throughout the papers in the book is the proposition of long-run neutrality of money, supported, in Friedman’s words, by a “mountain of evidence” (p. xix). Lucas is concerned by the observation that some “generally well trained” economists are unaware of the evidence supporting the neutrality proposition (ibid.), and it is perhaps this perceived lack of awareness that explains why he revisits the evidence on multiple occasions (chs. 4, 15, 16, 21, pp. 521–525).
Although the proposition of long-run neutrality of money goes well with the technical rigor of general equilibrium analysis, Lucas senses a tension when it comes to the proposition of short-run non-neutrality of money. On the one hand, he believes that money has real effects in the short run (pp. xxiii–xxiv, 514–515), and he builds corresponding models (eg., chs. 1, 12, 20). On the other hand, general equilibrium models that are built to capture the short-run non-neutrality are generally unsatisfactory because they do not address events like the Great Depression or Japanese experience in the 1990s (p. 514). Lucas points towards methodological reasons for the unsatisfactory performance of the models. The technique of general equilibrium theorizing constrains the types of questions that economists ask as well as the answers they can expect to secure, which is the price that economics currently pays for the increasingly closer relationship between the technical and choice–theoretic rigors of economics. In other words:
The problem is that … the theories embedded in general equilibrium dynamics of the sort that we know ... how to use pretty well now —there’s a residue of things that they don’t let us think about.… In terms of the theory that researchers are developing as a cumulative body of knowledge—no one has figured out how to take that theory to successful answers to the real effects of monetary instability. (pp. 514–515)
The view that technical rigor in economics can impede efficient application of the choice–theoretic rigor leads to a number of questions. If general equilibrium analysis limits our understanding of short-run monetary instability, can it equally well limit our understanding of other monetary issues, such as that of long-run neutrality of money or the role of money in the economy discussed above? Moreover, since the same methodological concern can be extended beyond the scope of monetary economics, one can even ask what is the cost of emphasizing the technical rigor in economics, and how it compares with the respective benefits. How far it is possible to follow this line of argument will, however, at this point, have to remain an open question.
The book conveys a number of other themes besides the ones that I discussed above. These include, for example, welfare effects of inflation (chs. 5 and 17), optimal fiscal and monetary policy (chs. 7 and 9), the end of Keynesian economics (pp. 500–503), or Skidelsky’s biography of Keynes (pp. 516–521). With the exception of the preface by Gillman, introduction by Lucas, chapter 12 (which is a previously unpublished manuscript), and the essay “The Death of Keynesian Economics,” the content of the book has been already, in some form, available to the general public. The value added is, however, still high because the book puts Lucas’ writings within historical context, and it provides readers with an easy access to papers of a great economist.
