One of the most endearing traces of Locke's influence on Dublin women writers can be seen in a small poem published in 1735, ‘Written for My Son, and spoken by him in School, upon his Master's first bringing in a Rod’ (Barber, Reference Barber1734, pp. 36–37). The schoolboy speaking the poem complains bitterly about the grim prospect of school beatings, then turns to praise ‘that great Sage’, ‘Who taught to play us into Learning, / By graving Letters on the Dice’. The ‘Sage’ is John Locke, who in his 1693 Thoughts Concerning Education recommends that children should enjoy learning their alphabet by playing with a polygon with letters engraved on each face. The child ends by showering praise on Locke:
The poem's author is Mary Barber (1685–1755). Her son Constantine, or ‘Con’, for whom she wrote the poem, grew up to become President of the College of Physicians in Trinity College Dublin. In its blend of humour, domesticity, and light-hearted engagement with education and philosophy, the piece is characteristic of the writings of a group of Dublin women to which Barber belonged, often known as Swift's ‘Triumfeminate’ through their associations with their more famous mentor Jonathan Swift. The group comprised, at various points, Barber (also known as the ‘Citizen's Housewife poet’ because of her humble origins as a draper's wife), the poet and scandal memoirist Laetitia Pilkington, daughter of a Dublin doctor and obstetrician, the classicist, poet and printer Constantia Grierson, and the critic Elizabeth Sican.Footnote 1 Of these four women, the two most active and publicly prominent were Barber and Pilkington, whose work will form the focus for this essay's discussion. Far less is known about the other two women, Grierson and Sican. The prodigiously talented classicist and poet Constantia Grierson (nee Crawley) died at 27, leaving behind only a few poems, most of them posthumously published by Pilkington and Barber. Less still is known about Elizabeth Sican, wife of a prosperous grocer connected to Swift through the Wood's halfpence trial over the Drapier's Letters, other than from a poem ‘On Psyche’ which Swift wrote on her domestic, cultural and intellectual virtues.Footnote 2 To identify these women merely as Swift's protégés (or, as Swift's friend Orrery snidely suggested, his ‘Seraglio’), is of course, reductive. Though Swift undoubtedly helped promote Barber's and Pilkington's well-documented careers, there were other intellectual and literary influences at work in their development as writers.Footnote 3 The cultural background these women shared reveals a more complex engagement with philosophical ideas current in Dublin at the time, such as questions of identity, consciousness and memory, gleaned through their connections with brothers, husbands and fathers at Trinity College Dublin, family book collections, as well as the literary gatherings held by Patrick Delany on Thursday afternoons, nicknamed the ‘Dublin Thursday Society’, at his suburban Dublin villa, Delville, at Glasnevin.Footnote 4 As their writings indicate, these women appear to have been familiar with Locke, Berkeley, and possibly other earlier philosophical authors such as Montaigne.
Recent scholarship has paid considerable attention to Locke's ‘feminisms’, particularly Locke's critique of Robert Filmer's patriarchalism and the extent to which his contract theory includes or excludes women.Footnote 5 Yet most studies of Locke's influence on contemporary women writers have been confined to the feminist Mary Astell's somewhat hostile response to Locke's contract theory, his close friendship and correspondence with Damaris Cudworth, and his admiration for Catharine Trotter Cockburn, whose high-minded 1702 defence of Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding, aligning Locke's moral philosophy with Christian theology, represents one end of a spectrum of women's responses to Locke's thought.Footnote 6 At the other end of the spectrum we find female readers and enthusiasts for Locke whose engagement with him was of a more mediated, domestic kind. Of this kind were the women of the Dublin circle, whose exposure to Locke came through daily domestic contact, conversations and book borrowing from fathers, brothers and sons who studied or taught at Trinity College Dublin, where Locke had been on the curriculum since 1692. One of the ways in which Locke was disseminated among a wider range of women readers was via popular miscellanies on philosophy and education aimed at women readers. The young George Berkeley, future Bishop of Cloyne, compiled in 1714 The Ladies Library, which included excerpts from Locke, Astell and Fenelon, among others, for the purposes of educating female readers.Footnote 7 This domestic, or ‘second-hand’ exposure to intellectual ideas in an age when most women were denied access to formal education and certainly to the study of philosophy, is a process worth studying as evidence of female acculturation to complex philosophical ideas. The women of the Triumfeminate redeployed Locke through a distinctively female, sometimes feminist lens, whilst engaging thoughtfully – yet also playfully – with some of the larger questions of understanding, education and memory raised by texts such as the Essay Concerning Human Understanding and Some Thoughts Concerning Education.Footnote 8
Cultural historians have shown the long reach which Locke's writings had on early eighteenth-century Ireland.Footnote 9 Locke's association with Ireland began properly through his friendship with Sir William Molyneux, founder of the Dublin Philosophical Society and the first translator into English of Descartes’ Meditations, although Locke had also previously known William's younger brother Thomas when both were studying medicine in Leiden. William's praise of Locke in the dedication of his Dioptrica Nova (1692) sparked an intimate, intellectual and personal correspondence that ended only when Molyneux died in 1698. It was Locke's closeness to Molyneux, whose wife Lucy Domville tragically became irreversibly blind in the first year of their marriage, that led him to include a discussion of the so-called ‘Molyneux's problem’ in his Essay – whether a man born blind but restored to sight could visually distinguish between shapes such a cube and a sphere which he had previously known only by touch.Footnote 10 The publication in 1708 of Molyneux's Some Familiar Letters between Mr Locke, and Several of his Friends, was key to getting Locke known in Dublin, and a source of local pride. The Familiar Letters were primarily concerned with the education of Molyneux's son Samuel, but also contained extensive correspondence between Locke and Molyneux over the manuscript of what was published as Some Thoughts concerning Education, particularly Molyneux's very liberal responses to some of Locke's strictures on child discipline. ‘Such a work as this I desire’, wrote Molyneux, ‘and that too, at the request of a tender father, for the use of his only son’.Footnote 11 Some Thoughts Concerning Education, published in London in 1693, was first published in Dublin in 1728, and there were five Irish reprints of the text (2 editions in 1728), 1737, 1738 and 1778. As Gerardine Meaney has shown, Berkeley used extensive passages from the text, alongside excerpts from Astell and Fenelon, for his 1714 anthology and educational guide, The Ladies Library.Footnote 12 Locke's engaging, modern treatise on child rearing, adopting a rational, humane, common sense approach to motherhood and infancy, proved one of the most popular guides in England for parents and tutors on how to educate children in an enlightened fashion. It proved no less popular in Dublin. Although Berkeley in his The Querist saw Locke's treatise primarily as the key to developing an educated gentry class who would take a paternalistic responsibility for improving their localities, there is no doubt that Barber and others like her focused their attention on education for children of lower social status, including children from trading and mercantile classes.
Locke's privileged position in Dublin intellectual circles also stemmed from the early inclusion on the Trinity College curriculum of his Essay Concerning Human Understanding which became a set text in 1692 after William Molyneux recommended it to the provost, St George Ashe. Locke as a political thinker and writer on economics was less widely known in Ireland. Although Jonathan Swift owned copies of, and drew on Locke's treatises on money in his Drapier's Letters (1724), and Molyneux drew on Locke's Two Treatises for his inflammatory 1698 The Case of Ireland, it was not until 1798 that the Two Treatises were added to the Trinity College Dublin university curriculum.Footnote 13
Thus early eighteenth-century Dublin knew Locke not primarily as a political or economic writer, but as a philosopher interested in the development of human perception and understanding, and perhaps even more importantly, as an educational writer, with an interest in childhood development and how children learn, and also in parent/child relationships, maternity and childbirth. Insightful recent scholarship has shown how Locke's experience as medical practitioner intersects with and shapes his role on writing for and about women. As Joanne Wright has shown, during his period of political exile in the Netherlands between 1683–88, Locke was part of a close-knit circle of Dutch medical scholars and practitioners, with a particular interest in male midwifery. It was in Leiden that some of Locke's early connections with Dublin were formed, such as with Thomas Molyneux, William's younger brother, who was studying medicine there. Leiden was a hub for European medical training.Footnote 14 John Van Lewen, Laetitia Pilkington's father, also studied medicine at Leiden and worked with Boerhaave (he was there slightly after Locke but almost certainly became familiar with his work at this time).Footnote 15 The Molyneux family had close links with the Van Lewen family in Dublin: Thomas Molyneux was a colleague of John Van Lewen at the College of Physicians. Thomas's son Daniel Molyneux was very close friends with Laetitia's younger brother Meade.
Like Locke, Van Lewen was very interested in obstetric practice, and when he returned to Dublin from Leiden, ‘there then being but one Man-Midwife in the Kingdom; my Father made himself Master of that useful Art, and practis'd it with great Success, Reputation, and Humanity’. It was this reputation as a male midwife that first attracted the bookish and precociously scholarly Constantia Crawley to the Van Lewen household, where she lodged in order to study professional midwifery under Van Lewen. The Dublin Scussles, or the hungry poets petition praises one ‘Miss Crawley, a lady of notable abilities… no less famous for her Poetical Prowess than her skill in Midwifery’. Born in Kilkenny to humble parents, Constantia Crawley, later Grierson, was a child prodigy who mastered Latin, Greek and Hebrew and French, much of it self-taught. She married the printer George Grierson and shared the honour of being King's Printer, acting as editor and compositor for many of the works his press published. She died aged 27 after acquiring a formidable reputation as editor and classical scholar. Constantia and Laetitia, who lived in the same house for a period of time, became very close friends, sharing an interest in philosophical and scientific ideas, as well as affectionate youthful exchanges of poems.Footnote 16
Laetitia Pilkington and Constantia Grierson both became friends with the significantly older Mary Barber, who by the early 1720s had started to become well known in Dublin. Barber, a highly intelligent, independent-minded woman, who struggled to overcome adversity (marriage to a failing linen draper, four dependent children and poor health), had been friends with Patrick Delany since 1719, long before her association with Swift. She was also close friends with the independent-minded widow Mary Pendarves, her great supporter, who married Delany in 1743. Barber's son Rupert, who became a famed portrait painter, married Delany's niece. They were all part of the group that met regularly, along with Matthew Pilkington, Swift and the Carterets, at Delville, where they discussed philosophical and literary topics. Barber showed a keen interest in Locke's work, and makes explicit, often playful reference, to his ideas, especially on education, child rearing, and man in a state of nature. Barber's Poems on Several Occasions of 1734 (in fact published in 1735), aided by Swift's support, attracted a huge subscription list of over 900 subscribers including peers and distinguished literati in both Ireland and England.Footnote 17 Her relationship with her four surviving children, particularly her two older sons, Constantine and Rupert, was often the stimulus for and the very subject of her poems. At least fifteen of her poems are explicitly written for her children, and the role of the maternal in education, as well as within marriage, reflects a reading probably not just of Locke but also of Mary Astell, whose Some Reflections Upon Marriage may have been introduced to her by Mary Pendarves.Footnote 18
Despite Locke's assumption that authority in marriage should fall to the man as the ‘abler and stronger’, he by no means undervalued the mother's role in the marriage contract, especially as an educator of her children. In the Two Treatises, following a rather unorthodox discussion of polyandry, Locke notes that ‘In those parts of America where when the Husband and the Wife part, which happens frequently, the Children are all left to the Mother, follow her, and are wholly under her care and Provision’.Footnote 19 In the more domesticated home environments described in Thoughts on Education he advocates that all children should be initially be educated at home, rather than at school – a mode customary to the education of girls, rather than boys. In his version of home schooling, Locke sees mothers as essential. He praises the role of mother as early educator in literacy and language: ‘and indeed whatever stir there is made about getting of Latin, as the great and difficult business, his Mother may teach him herself, if she will but spend two or three hours a day with him’.Footnote 20 Locke's strong belief in the power of mothers as early educators found an embodiment in Mary Barber, who invested an extraordinary level of effort and responsibility – as well as genuine pleasure – in her children's education. In her Preface to her Poems Barber claims that the education of her children was her chief reason for writing and publishing verse: she wrote her poems ‘To form the Minds of my children’ as ‘I imagined that Precepts conveyed by verse would be easier remembered’: ‘What has the public to do with verses written between a mother and her son? I answer, that as nothing can be of more use to society than the taking every care to form the minds of youth, I publish some of the verses written by me with that view, when my son was a schoolboy, as the best apology a woman could make for writing at all’ (Barber, Reference Barber1734, pp. xvii-xviii). Barber's interest in education went far beyond the modest female defence of writing to improve or enhance the financial prospects of one's family that women writers often had to adopt to sanction and legitimise their appearance in print. Many of Barber's poems embody a rational, practical approach to childhood learning, inculcated by maternal instruction. The pleasure that Barber took in this role is evident from one of the early poems in Poems on Several Occasions, ‘A True Tale’, which depicts her sitting at home with her children:
Barber's role as a closely involved home educator of her own children is remarkable for its time, and shows the influence which Locke's ideas on education had on Irish readers. In her ‘Conclusion of a Letter to the Reverend Mr C’, a poem in which she mimics a misogynistic Irish cleric who deliberately wants to marry an uneducated wife who will cook and sew, and who he can master and control, she passes down this advice to her son when he comes to have children of his own: choose a wife who will be both an intellectual companion and tutor of their children.
Barber had clearly assimilated Locke's Thoughts on Education closely. Although the earliest Irish edition of 1728 was aimed at an elite – ‘Published at the request of several of the nobility of the kingdom’ – in line with Berkeley's ideal in The Querists of an educated, responsible and paternalistic Irish gentry who would provide a lead in the improvement of their localities, Barber expands Locke's text to appeal to a broader social audience. The Dublin subscription list for the 1728 edition included many ordinary local tradespeople. Excerpts from it were printed in the 1735 Dublin reprint of The Apprentices’ Vade Mecum, whose author, Samuel Richardson, drew heavily on Thoughts on Education in his second ‘Pamela’ novel, Pamela in Her Exalted Condition (1742), devoted to the servant Pamela's rearing and education of her children with the aristocrat Mr B (Richardson, Reference Richardson and Rivero2012). Samuel Richardson, a friend of Mary Barber and publisher of her Poems on Several Occasions, would undoubtedly have approved of her educational aims and poems drawing on Locke's theories on education, designed to improve the minds of her children.
Barber uses her closeness to her oldest son Con to comment on his daily life at school, his relationship with his school friends, and especially his school masters. She ventriloquizes Con's voice to explore and critique contemporary educational practices and other social ills from a child's viewpoint. The poem with which I opened, ‘Written for My Son, and spoken by him in School, upon his Master's first bringing in a Rod’, echoes one of Locke's abiding concerns in education, the role which corporal punishment should, or ideally should not, play at home and in school. Locke himself was severely beaten at Westminster school under the notorious Dr Busby, and in the preface to Thoughts on Education he suggests that his friend Edward Clarke might send his own recalcitrant son there for a short period of time to instil in him gratitude for the more benevolent regime of home schooling. Thoughts on Education is regularly punctuated by Locke's protests against the inefficacy and cruelty of beating, for example, ‘Beating then, and all other Sorts of slavish and corporal Punishments, are not the Discipline fit to be used in the Education of those who would have wise, good, and ingenuous Men’ (Locke, Reference Locke1693, pp. 50–51). Locke believed that persuasion and argument were far more effective than the rod in teaching a child. In the Familiar Letters Molyneux discussed Locke's fondness what we would now describe as ‘educational toys’, ‘the contrivances you propose for teaching them to read and write’ including games to teach the alphabet and /writing skills (Molyneux et al., Reference Molyneux1708, p. 53). In ‘Upon his Master's first bringing in a Rod’, Con echoes Locke's opinion that education should involve fun and play, rather than whipping and beating.
The asterisk is footnoted with a reference to ‘Mr Locke’, who advocates that ‘Play will then become a Science’. The reference to ‘graving Letters on a Dice’ refers to section 149–50 of Thoughts on Education:
Locke's Thoughts on Education also inspired Barber's most frequently anthologised poem, ‘Written for my Son, and spoken by him at his first putting on Breeches’. In this imaginative, unusual poem, Barber projects herself into the mind of a little boy who is made to wear tight-fitting masculine clothes after an infanthood in gender-neutral frocks, when, at the age of seven or eight, as was customary, boys were ‘breeched’.Footnote 21 Con's protests against the discomfort and dangers of stiff, formal and tight-fitting clothing, including trousers, shoes, waistcoats and hats, are expressed with an eloquence and philosophical sophistication humorously incongruous for a little boy, albeit a precocious one.
Mary Barber's adult voice can be heard behind that of her son. The critic Christopher Fanning claims that Barber is using her son covertly to ventriloquize typical female grievances against society's demands for women to subject themselves to discomfort and pain in the service of conformity to fashion or in order to please men (Fanning, Reference Fanning2001). The small boy vocalises the type of complaint more often made by eighteenth-century women forced into tight bodices and stays to attract potential suitors.Footnote 22 Yet it is clear to anyone who has read Thoughts on Education that Barber is also echoing both Locke's, and even earlier, Montaigne's, radical hostility to oppressive forms of ‘Custom’ in dress which damage the development of the human body, and that she is engaging with a larger philosophical debate about what is ‘natural’ and what is socially determined.Footnote 23
Among the evils in dress about which Barber's son complains, tight shoes are the most vivid and visceral:
Barber's description of the deliberate ‘cramping’ and ‘binding’ of ‘growing Feet’ evokes Locke's horrified account of Chinese female infant foot-binding in Thoughts on Education. ‘The Women of China, by bracing and binding them hard from their Infancy (imaging I know not what kind of Beauty in it) have very little Feet’. He complains about their stunted growth and short lives, which he attributes to ‘the unreasonable binding of their Feet; whereby the free Circulation of the Blood is hindred, and the Growth and Health of the whole Body suffers. And how often do we see, that some small part of the Foot being injured by a Wrench or a Blow, the whole Leg and thigh thereby lose their Strength and Nourishment, and dwindle away?’ (Locke, Reference Locke1693, p. 12). Locke's account (one of the earliest), later taken up by Mary Wollstonecraft, was almost certainly an influence on Barber, who also includes in her poem references to other barbaric patriarchal oriental practices, such as nooses made of bow-strings by the ‘Grand Turk’ by which Turkish sultans murdered disobedient wives and enemies (Barber, Reference Barber1734, p. 14).
Barber's foot obsession might stem in part from her painful attacks of chronic gout. Yet her hostility to tight footwear and her preference for bare feet echo many of Locke's ideas on bare-foot health. Locke advises that the young children of the gentry should have their ‘Feet to be washed every night in cold water and to have his Shooes so thin, that might leak and let in Water’ (Locke, Reference Locke1693, p. 5); and he even advocates that well-bred children should walk barefoot in the cold and wet to make them hardier like ‘the poor People's children’. This is part of Locke's ongoing advocacy in Some Thoughts with the hardy and robust as opposed to the over-refined and over-bred.
Those who have been bred nicely, will wish he had, with the poor People's Children, gone Bare-foot; who, by that means, come to be so reconciled, by Custom, to Wet in their Feet, that they take no more Cold or Harm by it, than if they were wet in their Hands. And what is it, I pray, that makes this great difference between the Hands and the Feet in others, but only Custom? I doubt not, but if a Man from his Cradle had been always used to go bare-foot, whilst his Hands were constantly wrapped up in warm Mittins, and covered with Handshooes, as the Dutch call Gloves; I doubt not, I say, but such a Custom would make taking Wet in his Hands, as dangerous to him, as now taking Wet in their Feet is to a great many others (Locke, Reference Locke1693, pp. 5–6).
As Robert Mankin has shown, Locke's attack on ‘custom’ derives in part from Montaigne's essay ‘De l'usage de se vestir’, or ‘Of the Custom of Wearing Clothes’, in which Montaigne argues that even in cold northern climates nature has equipped us to live with more exposure to cold and wet then we endure, and that only the force of custom limits us and makes us behave (and dress) as we do (Mankin, Reference Mankin2005). Although Locke never visited Ireland, he must have been familiar from his conversations with Molyneux about the Irish practice of walking barefoot everywhere, with only upper stocking covering the ankles and calves – a practice common into the nineteenth and even twentieth centuries, the barefoot Irish were viewed in different ways by Irish philosophers and ‘improvers’. Berkeley, Swift and Samuel Madden often used the barefoot Irish peasant to typify Irish poverty and degradation. Berkeley often alludes to Irish shoelessness in The Querist. In his Short View of the Present State of Ireland (1728) Swift described ‘The families of farmers who pay great rents … without a shoe or stocking to their feet’. Samuel Madden in 1738 complained of the ‘poor Natives so low … fed with wretched scraps and cloath'd with Rags; numbers of them going bare-legg'd and barefooted, or at best wearing Brogues (as they call their Shoes) so wretched and vile, they are little better than the Wooden Shoes of France, or those of the Peasants in Spain’.Footnote 24 Yet Mary Barber radically follows Locke, and before him, Montaigne, in defending bare feet and Irish brogues as a positive type of hardy primitivism.
From the medical perspective which informs all his writings on obstetrics and the raising of children, Locke abhors the deformities of body and the illnesses caused unnecessarily, he believed, by the constricted apparel favoured by ‘custom’. He advises parents to make sure that
… your Son's Cloths be never made strait, especially about the Breast. Let Nature have scope to fashion the Body as she thinks best: she works of herself a great deal better, and exacter, than we can direct her … Narrow Breasts, short and stinking Breath, ill Lungs, and Crookedness, are the Natural and almost constant Effects of hard Bodice, and Cloths that pinch. That way of making slender waists, and fine shapes, serves but the more effectually to spoil them. Nor can there, indeed, but be disproportion in the parts, when the nourishment, prepared in the several offices of the body, cannot be distributed, as nature designs. (Locke, Reference Locke1693, pp. 10–11)
Locke (somewhat playfully) adopts a politicised language of captivity and liberty when he condemns the widespread practice of swaddling babies: ‘The poor Thing lies on the Nurse's Lap, a miserable little pinioned Captive, goggling and staring with its Eyes, the only organ it has at Liberty, as if supplicating for Freedom to its Fetter'd Limbs’. Barber goes much further than Locke himself in drawing on Montaigne's essay on clothing in her attacks on the tyrant ‘Custom’. The animals and birds all dress in perfect proportion to their wants and needs, so why can't we? Montaigne argues that ‘as plants, trees, and animals, and all things that have life, are seen to be by nature sufficiently clothed and covered, to defend them from the injuries of weather:
Proptereaque fere res omnes ant corio sunt, Aut seta, ant conchis, ant callo, ant cortice tectae [And that for this reason nearly all things are clothed with skin, or hair, or shells, or bark, or some such thing. – Lucretius, iv. 936.] so were we: but as those who by artificial light put out that of day, so we by borrowed forms and fashions have destroyed our own. And ’tis plain enough to be seen, that ’tis Custom only which renders that impossible that otherwise is nothing so (Montaigne, Reference de Montaigne and Cotton1574).
Mary Barber's poem expands Montaigne's account with imaginative liberty.
The Memoirs of Laetitia Pilkington, published between 1748 and 1754 by Mary Barber's Dublin friend, and later rival, Laetitia Pilkington, also testify to a domestic familiarity with Locke. Much has been written on Pilkington, whose lively Memoirs offer a uniquely intimate domestic account of her mentor Jonathan Swift, her Dublin childhood, and her later descent into poverty in London following her infamous divorce from her clerical poet husband Matthew. Recent scholarly attention has focused more on Pilkington's survival strategies for surmounting a series of abusive relationships with more powerful men than on her intellectual seriousness and engagement with philosophical or scientific debate.Footnote 25 Yet it is often forgotten that Pilkington, before she acquired a reputation as a Grub Street demimondaine, was better known as the youngest daughter of a distinguished doctor, John Van Lewen, President of the College of Physicians, and that her mother Elizabeth was an educated and intellectual woman, who also attended the Thursday salon gatherings at Patrick Delany's Delville. Pilkington obviously did not enjoy the benefits of the Trinity College education experienced by her younger brother Meade, but she grew up in a house surrounded by books, ideas and conversation. In December 1731 the intellectual Mary Pendarves, who subsequently married Patrick Delaney, described a Sunday evening to the Van Lewens household.
Spent the evening at Doctor Van Luens. I believe I have mentioned that family to you before: they are sensible and cheerfull. It was proposed by Mrs Van Luen that everybody should own what quality they valued themselvs most for, and afterwards, what they most disliked in themselves: this fancy made us very merry, and made our conversation not unlike some in Clelia [de Scudery's philosophical novel, 1644–1661]. (Elias Jr (ed.), Reference Elias1997, vol. 2. p. 374 n. 16:23)
Laetitia was also, as Catherine Ingrassia has shown, a voracious reader in Swift's library, and her love of reading, writing and memorising texts started in infancy (Ingrassia, Reference Ingrassia2016). She also had a serious interest in scientific ideas, striking up a friendship in London with the eminent physiologist Stephen Hales in 1739 (Memoirs, 1. 33–34). She was clearly familiar, as we will see, with both Thoughts on Education and The Essay on Human Understanding. Patrick Kelly notes that undergraduate understanding of the nuances of Locke's Essay, part of the curriculum since 1692, were often shaky. More than a century later, the eminent Dublin lawyer Sir Jonah Barrington commented that ‘the college course at that time, though a very learned one, was ill-arranged, pedantic, and totally out of sequence. Students were examined in Locke on the Human Understanding, before their own had arrived at the first stage of maturity’ (Kelly, Reference Kelly1989, p. 22). Arguably a clever, quick and curious young woman like Pilkington, raised in an intellectual Dublin household, might have come to a better understanding of Locke's ideas than many male undergraduates. Pilkington clearly enjoyed playing word games at home which depended on puns and ambiguity. Snippets from diaries and letters of Trinity College students during this period show a familiarity with Locke that anticipates the playful pleasure in the ambiguity of words that we find in the work of another Irish writer, Laurence Sterne. In his autobiographical novel The Life of John Buncle (1753), the former Trinity College student Thomas Amory praises his first year encounter with Locke's Essay very highly: ‘When I was sent to University … The first book I took in my hand was the Essay of that fine Genius Mr Locke … who shewed me greatly how true knowledge depended on a right meaning of words’.Footnote 26 In her Memoirs, Pilkington engages repeatedly with Locke's Essay. She recalls a Lockian conversation with her younger brother Meade over the ‘right meaning of words’. Meade ‘teiz'd me one Evening to write some verses as a School Exercise for him’. ‘I asked him what I should write upon’. ‘What should you write Upon’, he replies, ‘but the Paper?’ (Memoirs, 1. 45). The ambiguity of the preposition ‘Upon’ recalls Locke's discussion of ‘the doubtfulness or ambiguity of the signification of words’. Pilkington responds to Meade's teasing with a poem, ‘O spotless Paper, fair and white’, later given the title ‘Carte Blanche’, which she prints in the Memoirs. In his Some Thoughts on Education Locke describes the child's mind as ‘White Paper, or Wax, to be moulded and fashioned as one pleases’. In her impromptu poem occasioned by her brother's teasing, Pilkington's blank sheet of paper becomes a metaphor for that schoolboy's mind. As Chantel Lavoie notes of this poem, the title ‘Carte Blanche’ ‘may refer not only to the purity of the unspoiled page, but also to the possibilities presented by John Locke on the changeable nature of humanity, and the personality as a tabula rasa’. (Lavoie, 1999, p. 208)
It is through the lens of Locke's Essay that Pilkington filters her personal memories of her childhood experiences of education and learning. Her rather bitter recollection of her mother's daily beatings owes far less to Locke's benign Thoughts on Education, with its general hostility to corporal punishment of children, than to the Essay on Human Understanding’s account of childhood memory retention through pain and pleasure. Pilkington's mother clearly did not follow Locke's injunctions against corporal punishment. ‘My mother strictly followed Solomon’s Advice, in never sparing the Rod … whether I deserv'd it or not, I was sure of Correction every Day of my Life’ (Elias Jr (ed.), Reference Elias1997, vol 1. p. 13). Pilkington relates how her mother prevented her from trying to read books, following a bout of smallpox which had weakened her sight and which threatened her looks and hence marriageability. When she pestered her exasperated mother for the meaning of a word, she ‘would tell me the Word, but accompany it with a good Box on the Ear, which I suppose, imprinted it on my Mind’. Her phrase ‘imprinted it on my Mind’ recalls Locke's terminology in his tabula rasa discussion in Some Thoughts on Education, showing how ideas are imprinted on the childhood mind through sensory impressions. Pilkington claims that her mother's ear-boxing ‘had this Effect on me, insomuch that I never forgot what was ever told me; and quickly arrived at my desir'd Happiness, being able to read before she thought I knew all my Letters’. The enforcement of memory through pain echoes Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding: ‘Attention, repetition, pleasure and pain, fix ideas. Attention and repetition help much to the fixing any ideas in the memory. But those, which naturally at first make the deepest and most lasting impressions, are those that are accompanied with pleasure or pain … pain should accompany the reception of several ideas’ (Nidditch (ed.), Reference Nidditch1975, II. X: 3). Pilkington ironically equates pain with rapid acquisition of literacy but is very clear that this is not the best way to learn. In her Memoirs she contrasts this severe and painful mnemonic tool with the more positive rewards – high praise, commendation, and a shilling – that her father gives her for learning to read.
Pilkington was clearly particularly interested in Locke's theories of memory in the Essay's Book II, Chapter X ‘Of Retention’. This is an unusual and early female interest in memory and cognition. Women writers had long been associated with memory, but more often memory as a pious, social and commemorative act – the recording of the passing of life, expressed in the elegy for the dead parent, spouse and most commonly child.Footnote 27 Memory as a cognitive function, or as something which related to a sense of individual personal identity and development, did not emerge until far later. Yet in the Memoirs, which spend so much time recording the lives of others and how they intersect with her own life, Pilkington is drawn at frequent moments to consider memory as an intellectual faculty, and her conceptual (rather than merely personal or anecdotal) engagement with memory appears to be inspired primarily by Locke. Arguably Locke's interest in consciousness and identity, the joining up of the dots between past and present selves, as well as his interest in memory as a faculty, held a particularly strong appeal to women who were starting to experiment with life-writing and other autobiographical and self-exploratory modes. Locke defined personal identity as consciousness rather than substance. ‘And as far as this consciousness can be extended backwards to any past action or Thought, so far reaches the Identity of that Person; it is the same self now as it was then, and tis by the same self with this present one that now reflects on it, that the Action was done … So that what-ever has the consciousness of present and past Actions, is the same Person to whom they both belong’.Footnote 28 For Locke, consciousness comprises identity, and eighteenth-century philosophers such as Berkeley believed that Locke's theory of personal identity depended upon memory, a reaching forward and backward of consciousness through time in a continued life.Footnote 29
Such concerns shape Pilkington's life-writing. The Memoirs are studded with an unusual awareness of the nature and function of memory. In proto-Proustian mode, she remarks that ‘I have observed, that the Scent of a Flower, or the Tune of a Song, always conveys to Remembrance the exact Image of the Place in which they were first noticed’ (Elias Jr (ed.), Reference Elias1997, vol. 1, pp. 282–83). Discussing the relationship between wit, memory and the imagination, she disputes an aphorism in Pope's Essay on Criticism to argue that that memory is a prerequisite for wit. ‘I know not how any Person can be witty without a good Memory’ (Elias Jr (ed.), Reference Elias1997, vol. 1, p. 55). Her own retentive textual memory supplied her with material for wit and play. She drew on between 250–300 quotations from memory for the Memoirs and loved to play games with Swift in which they matched each other quotation for quotation through the works of Shakespeare and others. Yet Pilkington's obsession with memory was far deeper than textual recall. One day, after reading Locke and speculating ‘on that most amazing Faculty of the human Mind, Memory’, she writes ‘Memory: A Poem’.
In its scientific approach and intellectual content, ‘Memory’ is an unusual poem, especially for an Irish female poet of the early eighteenth century. Pilkington draws primarily on Locke's transitional treatment of memory, which combines earlier ideas of memory as mnemonic system with a more modern, subjective concept of memory that equates memory with identity, individuality and selfhood. It is also possible (as with Barber's knowledge of Montaigne), that the reading of these Dublin women was wider and deeper than we can conjecture, and that Pilkington may have been influenced by other scholastic and Renaissance philosophers on memory she may have encountered in her father's library – or indeed in Swift's library, to which she describes having access. Locke in his Essay deploys the traditional spatial metaphors of the Aristotelian and later Renaissance mnemonic tradition, which views memory, in its ideal form, as a retrieval mechanism for what has been previously stored, memory as a store room, through which the individual moves to retrieve the images placed there.Footnote 30 Memory is ‘the storehouse of our ideas. For the narrow mind of man, not being capable of having many ideas under view and consideration at once, it was necessary to have a repository to lay up those ideas, which at another time it may have use of’.Footnote 31
Pilkington's apostrophe to memory as the ‘surprising Storehouse!’ echoes Locke's, and prior to that, the medieval scholars Albertus Magnus and Thomas Aquinas's metaphor of memory as the ‘storehouse of ideas’.Footnote 32 Pilkington depicts memory as a cabinet of curiosities made up of ‘recesses in the brain’, ‘a hidden Cell, / Wherein ten thousand different Objects dwell’. It is the repository of the ‘Sacred Stores of Learning’. Yet, in an original turn, Pilkington transforms the static ‘container’ into an organic, specifically female container: ‘In whose narrow womb / All things, the past, the present and to come / Find ample space and large and mighty room’. This container is paradoxically ‘narrow’ yet also ‘mighty’, intimate yet expansive, female and gestational. Pilkington wrote the poem when she was pregnant with her daughter Charlotte: maternal imagery here ‘approximates the mind's profound generation of mental associations, extends the day's ruminations. Pregnant with expansive reading and literally pregnant with her daughter Charlotte, Pilkington imagines her wit ‘lay'd up till season due and fit’.Footnote 33 Pilkington boldly figures memory as the mother of wit. Whereas earlier male writers such as Rochester and Pope equate the maternal imagery of wombs and procreation with dullness, amnesia and vacuity, Pilkington's gestational metaphor for memory is richly productive. Throughout the Memoirs, we see Pilkington concerned with both the mnemonic aspects of memory – her ability to learn texts off by heart and to recite them, a foundational part of her early girlhood desire to please and be praised, part of the traditional repertoire of female accomplishment – and with memory as individuated, personal history, a capacity for reflection, a linking of past and present selves. Memory is a function of mind, a capacity to recall at will past perceptions and to renew them again.
The influence of Locke's thought – and indeed, of philosophical thought in general – on the women of eighteenth-century Dublin is a subject which has barely been touched by scholars. Topics worth pursuing will be the extent to which women associated through fathers, husbands and sons with the academic milieu of Trinity College Dublin, had access to the ideas, books and scholarship which characterised their world. Further work still needs to be done in exploring the links between Locke, Holland, Dublin and the relationship between medical understanding, cognitive philosophy and educational theory. Yet a preliminary study of the writings of at least two of the women of the Dublin Triumfeminate from a philosophical perspective, and, in turn, the writings of other contemporary women who produced poetry on a sometimes amateur or domestic basis, not necessarily to get into print, might encourage us to consider the ways in which ordinary women of the ‘middling sort’ accessed philosophical ideas in a domestic context and how these might have entered into their works. Not all philosophical debates took place in the public male spaces of school, coffee house and university. The intimacy of Locke's personal correspondence with friends and writers like Molyneux or Cudworth, focusing on maternal and familial relations, sickness and health, care of infants and early education, as well as Locke's personal recollections within his correspondence of the influence of his own father and mother, and his inexhaustible fascination with childhood play and games, might send us back into an examination of the domestic spaces of the period to uncover more about women's engagement with philosophy in the early modern period.
