Contemporary Muslim Apocalyptic Literature is a fascinating read. It is a scholarly study of a rich body of apocalyptic texts, integrating hadith literature, Qurءanic exegesis, and Christian apocalyptic tales, along with narratives similar to those one would find in contemporary magazines sold in American supermarkets that deal with unidentified flying objects and flying saucers. Cook's exploration looks at the new ways in which apocalyptic writers construct time and meaning and underlines the changes that occurred when medieval apocalyptic literature was transformed into the modern context.
Chapters 1 and 2 detail the major concepts and methodologies within Muslim apocalyptic writing and identify schools of thought within the modern apocalyptic worldview. Cook distinguishes three subgroups in the discourses: first, a conservative school, which is produced and controlled by the ulema and often makes no effort to relate the apocalyptic traditions to present realities; second, a radical school, which appeals to the present and produces apocalyptic scenarios “based on classical Muslim material, more or less in the same manner that evangelical Christians use biblical materials” (p. 15); and third, a neoconservative school, which synthesizes the radical outlook yet minimizes the biblical material used by the radical method.
Other chapters deal with the particularities of the grand apocalyptic narrative. They explore concepts such as that of the mahdi (chapter 6) and the Antichrist (chapter 9); analyze textual problems encountered by apocalyptic writers when reinterpreting holy scripture and sacred traditions (chapters 10 and 5); underline new concepts of apocalyptic time (chapters 3 and 4) and apocalyptic space (part of chapter 6); and examine the ways in which contemporary realities such as the involvement of America in Middle Eastern politics, the existence of the state of Israel, or the new regime of the Taliban were reconfigured into the present apocalyptic literature.
Undoubtedly, readers will benefit from Cook's extensive knowledge of the classical apocalyptic literature in both the Shiעite and the Sunni traditions. Cook's mastery of such sources, moreover, enables him to underline the modern and popular nature of the new apocalyptic texts and expose their hybrid nature. Every chapter provides a rich and meticulous description of its subtheme, incorporating as many apocalyptic works as possible. This finding is most evident in chapter 6, which describes a long fantasy concerning the changes that will occur in the universe after the arrival of the mahdi. Cook takes us step by step on a captivating journey illustrating the various battles that are supposed to occur at the end of time.
Another important strength of the text is its ability to challenge the simplistic categories of “clash of civilizations” by demonstrating how Western narratives and images, from the Protocols of the Elders of Zion to the biography of Henry Kissinger (who is sometimes identified as the Antichrist, p. 163), are incorporated as signs of the coming end. Cook, however, convincingly illustrates that the radical groups themselves adhere to a concept of “clash of civilizations,” which classifies “the world into stark, easily identifiable categories and bolster[s] a worldview in which the West and Islam are in total opposition” (p. 6). The text also highlights some unexplored aspects of radical Islamic literature. For example, it contains interesting discussions on the appropriation of scientific, technological, and pseudoscientific motifs in apocalyptic works (p. 71–83, in particular). These accounts are used by writers to scientifically authenticate the correctness of their religious beliefs—much like 19th-century biblical archeologists used archeology to substantiate the Bible.
Another interesting aspect of the book is the new light it sheds on the market of modern religious literature. Cook demonstrates how the reprinting of the classic apocalyptic heritage in the past fifteen years by the religious establishment enabled radicals to recreate their own messianic scenarios and challenge the conservative knowledge of the sacred tradition. Finally, this book exemplifies the vitality of Qurءanic exegesis and interpretation of tradition by examining the ways in which such readings are produced in a modern context and the problems faced by the new, popular interpreters.
One wishes, however, that Cook would have given more attention to the context of the Arab state and to the Arab readership. Although it is virtually impossible to assess the reception of conspiracy theories or obtain data on sales of apocalyptic books, it would have been useful if Cook had included more biographical information on the apocalyptic authors or information regarding the frequency with which these texts are mentioned in the more conventional media. Although the invaluable parallels Cook draws between Christian and Muslim apocalyptic traditions generate a much-desired comparative analysis, what is lacking is a more detailed comparison to the Arab secular discourse, because such writers challenge tolerant and secular voices in the Arab world. In fact, some narratives mentioned in the book are the mirror images of particular reformative and secular representations. Radical writers incorporate and compete with the national discourses, presenting their own version of Arab nationalism and the state. The depictions of the just caliphate created by the mahdi could be viewed as the counterimage of many Arab states. The mahdi, we note, not only rids the world of Israel but also destroys the Gulf shaykhdoms, in particular Kuwait (not surprisingly, some texts appeared after the first Gulf War). Because such narratives also feature Saddam Hussein, Michel עAflaq, King Hussein, Yasir Arafat, and Hafez al-Asad, more about the relationship of such groups to local politics seems to be in order, especially because Cook notes that their apocalyptic message inspires them to challenge the current political norms. The emphasis on the Arab national context might undermine Cook's hypothesis that such texts, although written in Arabic, are also geared toward Christians in an attempt to contest the “apocalyptic philo-Judaism so prevalent among Protestant evangelicals” (p. 220). Similarly, the very rich bibliography could have benefited from texts dealing with contemporary Islamic discourses by Emmanuel Sivan, Gilles Kepel, or additional works by Yvonne Haddad (the bibliography only lists one article).
Lastly, although Cook is careful to note that the texts he read are pertinent to apocalyptic Muslim writers, at times he generalizes about “Islam” or the “Muslims.” Commenting on Israel's centrality within anti-Semitic conspiracy theory depicted in the apocalyptic texts, Cook writes that Israel is “a country that has succeeded in building a democratic and progressive society when the Muslims [my italics] overwhelmingly have not” (p. 21), neglecting that the Arab press often criticizes Israel for its undemocratic politics. Likewise, in answering the question, “What does the outside observer gain by gazing at Muslim apocalyptic literature?” Cook writes that we see “the lack of self criticism, the defensive attitude towards anything that comes from the outside world, the self-imposed prison of the conspiracy theory … One could therefore say that while there are many positive qualities in contemporary Muslim society, in reading the apocalyptic literature, we are able to see the depth of the opposition to such qualities” (p. 229). This statement about Islam seems to undermine the book's emphasis on the hybrid nature of such apocalyptic texts, borrowing from Muslim as well as European and American sources.
Nevertheless, this is a very interesting study that is sometimes even humorous because of the nature of the narratives presented. (Who knew that the Antichrist might come from the Bermuda Triangle?) It can serve our students, who might not know the cosmology of the Muslim Day of Judgment yet will surely be familiar with the elements taken from evangelical mythologies and science-fiction tales that populate this Islamic–eschatological space.
