Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T00:02:37.523Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

An analysis of money's worth ratios in Chile

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 October 2007

CRAIG THORBURN
Affiliation:
Operations Policy Department, World Bank
ROBERTO ROCHA*
Affiliation:
Operations Policy Department, World Bank
MARCO MORALES
Affiliation:
Diego Portales University, Santiago de Chile
*
*Correspondence address: Roberto Rocha, Rrocha@worldbank.org
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Empirical analyses of annuities markets have been limited to a few developed countries and restricted by data limitations. Chile provides excellent conditions for research on annuities due to the depth of its market and the availability of data. The paper utilizes an extensive dataset on individual annuities to examine econometrically a measure of market performance – money's worth ratios (MWRs), or the ratio of the expected present value of annuity payments to the premium. The results show that annuitants in Chile have generally got a good deal for their premiums, as indicated by MWRs higher than one and also higher than those estimated for other countries. The difference between Chile and other countries is striking considering that annuities in Chile are indexed to prices. The wide range of indexed instruments in Chile, allowing providers to hedge their risks while extracting higher returns, helps explain the difference. The high degree of market competition has also contributed to this outcome. Efforts to improve market transparency through a new electronic quotation system have decreased the dispersion of MWRs. Finally, MWRs tend to decrease for contracts with longer durations, reflecting pricing for higher longevity and reinvestment risks. These results are consistent with separate research on the annuity rate, and indicate the need to ensure competition and market transparency, as well as to develop appropriate financial instruments for providers in order to ensure good outcomes for annuitants.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2007
Figure 0

Table 1.Breakdown of stock of pensions, by type of instrument, 1985–2004

Figure 1

Figure 1.Number of Life Insurance Companies, Annuity Providers, and AFPs, 1988–2005

Figure 2

Figure 2.Market Concentration Ratios in Pensions and Annuities Herfindahl and Share of Three Largest Firms, 1988–05

Figure 3

Table 2.Summary statistics of the dataset

Figure 4

Table 3.Summary statistics of dataset by subgroups

Figure 5

Table 4.Money's worth ratios in March 1999, 2002, 2003, 2004 and 2005Computed with the risk free rate and an update cohort annuitant table.

Figure 6

Table 5.Main determinants of MWRsDependent variable: 100*MWR; Least squares with robust standard errors pooled data for 1999, 2002, 2003, 2004, and 2005; observations: 6,526.

Figure 7

Table 6.Mean, standard deviation and coefficient of variation of MWRs in different years

Figure 8

Figure 3.MWRs and premiums in 1999 and 2005

Figure 9

Table 7.White heteroskedasticity test

Figure 10

Table 8.Money's worth ratios in Chile, March 2004Computed with cohort annuitant tables and alternative discount rates.

Figure 11

Table 9.Money's worth ratios in selected countriesComputed with cohort annuitant table and risk-free rate.

Figure 12

Table 10.Average money's worth ratios in selected countriesComputed with cohort annuitant table and corporate bond rate.

Figure 13

Table 11.Money's worth ratios for Chile estimated by James et al. for 1999 and 2003

Figure 14

Figure 4.Annuity Rate and Interest Rates on Central Bank Bonds and Corporate Bonds (% p.a.), 1993–2005

Figure 15

Table 12.Money's worth ratios for Chile estimated by this report, 1999 and 2003