Inquisition trials and medical records have long provided historians with insight into the politics of sex and reproduction in colonial and modern Latin America. Yet, until now, no one had utilised such sources to write a comprehensive portrait of contraception and childbirth in Mexican history. As Nora Jaffary tells us, this lacuna reflects the challenges of historicising reproductive biology and maternity: because both are viewed as ‘natural’ and ‘essential’, they have long been seen as ‘beyond history’ (p. 211). With historical sensitivity, patience, and originality, Reproduction and its Discontents offers a very successful reply to this longstanding oversight. The six thematic chapters – which draw elegantly on criminal trial records, inquisition cases, medical treatises, legislation, and newspaper reports – immerse readers in the interlocked histories of virginity, pregnancy, contraception, abortion, infanticide, monstrous births and obstetrics. By the mid-nineteenth century, Jaffary argues, state officials, medical doctors, legal experts and residents alike exerted increased surveillance over women's sexual and reproductive habits. With rich nuance and attention to local context, this study also unearths a surprising array of popular perspectives on reproduction, and demonstrates how these shifted and persisted throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
It is well known that colonial elites pressured pre-marital women to preserve their public reputation as virginal subjects. Because property titles and social status claims were connected to both limpieza de sangre (blood purity) and the legitimacy of offspring, control over female sexuality was a key function of Spanish colonial society. Though Ann Twinam, Patricia Seed and others have already interrogated such obsessions with birth status, Jaffary's opening chapter breaks new ground by linking eighteenth-century cultural constructions of virginity to nineteenth-century scientific investigations of the same. By the time of the Porfiriato, doctors argued that a widespread lack of female virtue harmed modernisation and development efforts. In both pre-independence and modern Mexico, the author elegantly argues, notions about both ‘biological virginity’ (the presence or absence of a hymen barrier) and ‘social virginity’ (a woman's reputation and honour) were contingent on factors other than sexual activity or the lack thereof.
At the same time that colonial authorities lacked concern about the virginity of non-elites, they did little to restrict popular contraceptive methods. Despite a dearth of documentary sources, Chapter 2 sustains impressive discussions of tepalehuiani (midwives) and their herbal remedies. Readers will also find an excellent discussion of popular colonial views of conception, which was understood as simply ‘detention of the menses’ (p. 33) and not proof of the existence of a foetus. Likewise, and as Chapter 3 explains, colonial Mexicans did not view contraception and abortion as categorically distinct: rather, they were among many options for ‘menstrual regulation’ (p. 81).
As the nineteenth century progressed, republican authorities adopted a more punitive approach toward contraception, abortion and infanticide. As Chapters 3 and 4 reveal, the modern state was more concerned with holding women of all classes accountable to buenas costumbres (respectability); at the same time, increasing denunciations of abortion and infanticide by family members, neighbours, employers and lovers evidenced popular uptake of these new standards. Here, Jaffary's fine attention to historical contradiction shows that even while Mexico witnessed a shift in cultural attitudes towards crimes against foetuses and infants, judges displayed a persistent reluctance to prosecute women for these offences.
The second half of Reproduction and its Discontents considers the advent of a Porfirian ‘medical nationalism’ (p. 196) in obstetrics. Chapter 5 presents an engaging and sophisticated discussion of a major shift: whereas Enlightened Creole patriots celebrated monstrous births as prodigious and ‘natural’, Porfirian doctors viewed monstrosity as a form of degeneracy transmitted by faulty Mexican biology. Finally, Jaffary's sixth chapter adds significantly to our understanding of a major – and, heretofore, largely overlooked – medical obsession with ‘the gynecological distinctiveness of Mexican women’ (p. 198). This degeneracy theory led to an increase in the use of forceps and other surgical interventions in Mexico City's Maternity Clinic, which contributed to high rates of post-puerperal infection.
Jaffary departs from much of the established literature on Porfirian obstetrics by proposing that the topic may best be understood within Steven Palmer and Marcos Cueto's model of ‘medical pluralism’. (Readers will note that her main evidence for such pluralism is the persistence of pre-Columbian midwifery and pharmacological practices.) The author thus counters Ana María Carrillo, Cristina Rivera Garza and Laura Cházaro's collective thesis that Porfirian obstetrical medicine exemplified state efforts to ‘subjugate female bodies to technologies of control’ (p. 214). Even as Jaffary avoids truisms on resistance and subaltern agency, one of her overarching arguments will resonate broadly with historians of gender in Latin America, as it bolsters Elizabeth Dore's claim that the ‘era of political liberalism’ was, for women, ‘innovation in a retrogressive direction’ (p. 2).
Although Reproduction and its Discontents is an enviable and seamless fusion of medical and popular history, its treatment of societal institutions is less satisfying. The author is the first to note that the Catholic Church is absent from the narrative; even so, a lack of attention to the state and its conflicts is more conspicuous. For example, there is a tendency to group post-1850s sources as ‘late nineteenth century’, which effectively blurs distinctions between republican, imperial, Juarista, Lerdista, early Porfirian and late Porfirian trends in medical practice. In any case, readers unfamiliar with Mexican history will not find synopses of these and other regimes in the text. Perhaps, ultimately, a thematic chapter organisation limits what we learn about how Mexican governmentality affected the politics of maternity and childbearing. This problem can partially be attributed to an overrepresentation of Bourbon and Porfirian sources in the documentary base. At times, the book reads more like a comparison between these two eras, and less of a sweep across time.
Notwithstanding the challenges posed by her sources, readers will appreciate Nora Jaffary's clear, eloquent and sophisticated prose, as well as her impressively thorough searches in multiple and often unyielding data sets. Researchers, likewise, will benefit from appendices on abortion and infanticide cases, as well as visual references from primary sources. In all, Reproduction and its Discontents is a highly valuable example of cultural history, and will be a foundational text for scholars of gender and medicine in Latin American history.
