Hüseyin Yılmaz's Caliphate Redefined: The Mystical Turn in Ottoman Political Thought is one of the most informative and well-researched books I have read recently. It traces the genealogy of the concept of the caliphate in the Ottoman world in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. Its merit comes not only from its erudite analysis of Ottoman political thought, but also from its perceptive overview of post-Abbasid political thought in Southwest Asia from the thirteenth century onward. The historical breadth of the book evidences years of careful research in manuscript libraries and nuanced world-historical reflection on the content of a highly diverse and variegated body of manuscripts, some known and others yet to be known. This breadth makes the book's broader theoretical claim all the more convincing. Yılmaz argues that in the post-Abbasid and post-Chinggis worlds of the Ottomans, the idea of the caliphate was reconstructed in the language of Sufism, which itself incorporated indigenous traditions of rulership and was shaped by defining historical moments, rather than through the juristic canon of medieval universalism. In sixteenth-century political discourse, the Ottoman sultan is portrayed not as a Mawardian caliph expected to function according to jurisprudential precepts, but a Sufi-caliph, a friend and deputy of God on Earth, a messiah, whose shadow extends over both temporal and spiritual realms to serve a divinely ascribed purpose and who would surrender his authority only at the end of times. The close association of the Ottoman ruling elite with prominent Sufi orders in the Ottoman lands rehabilitated Sufi practices and discourse as the principal language of Ottoman dynastic legitimacy, in which the sultan ruled as the supreme spiritual leader. This mystical configuration of sultanic authority enabled the Ottoman court to tap into Sufi vocabulary and practices to stall the political challenges by major Sufi orders and others. Sanctified by dynastic apologists, enigmatic scribes, mainstream scholars, and others, the Ottoman caliphate emerges in discursive narratives as a comprehensive cosmological position linking and operating between various levels of spiritual realm and the material world. This “mystical turn” in political discourse is best evidenced in the fact that the instruction of the Ottoman dynastic princes on statecraft between 1400 and 1600 involved studying books written almost entirely by Sufi scholars. In conversation with ground-breaking studies in the field of the last three decades or so, Yılmaz makes an excellent case for how the Ottoman sultanic authority became defined increasingly in Sufi terms. He thus allows us to imagine the global economy of a pervasive spiritual politics or of political esotericism, khilafat-i ma'nawi, functioning from Bengal to the Balkans in the territories of the Mughals, the Shaybani Khans, the Safavids, and the Ottomans, whose primary currency was Sufi vocabulary, and even performance.
Caliphate Redefined is divided into five well-argued chapters, in addition to its thought-provoking introduction and conclusion. In the introduction, Yılmaz lays out the scope of his research and summarizes the main arguments of the study against the background of the juristic notions of the caliphate and of moralist political thought. Articulated especially by those members of the cosmopolitan scholarly elite who had active and practical links with the state bureaucracy and Sufi orders in various provinces of the empire, Yılmaz notes, political thinking acquired a recognizably Ottoman character (Rumi, Osmanlı), which frequently entailed assertions of “Ottoman exceptionalism,” as richly illustrated in dynastic epics and stories. Yılmaz identifies the birth-pangs of “the state,” where ideas and claims of “government by law” and “institutional continuity of the state” became primary objectives of rulership, in the shift in the middle of the sixteenth century toward “legalism” in political thinking, which measured success and propriety by conformity to the established Ottoman model of government instead of the precepts of traditional moral excellence. In this form, “the state” was headed by the grand vizier who replaced as the center of government the sultan, who now was seen as a remote and abstract but legitimating figure for the dynasty.
In chapter 1, Yılmaz traces Ottoman political discourse from its origins in the early fifteenth century to the third quarter of the sixteenth century, following themes and questions that a large number of Ottoman intellectuals raised in their writing. Yılmaz categorizes political literature of the age of Süleyman into four principal genres: ethics, statecraft, jurisprudence, and Sufism, which were expressed in three principal languages. The administrative language of the bureaucrats was distinguished by its empirical content drawn from Ottoman administrative practice. The juristic language was the medium of exchange throughout the global ulama network and tied political thinking to a universally conceived jurisprudential imperative. The esoteric and symbolic language of Sufism required one to occupy a particular spiritual state (hal) or a station (maqam, daraja) to access the hidden messages contained in the language. The full corpus of political writing became part of the mainstream Ottoman thought through these channels in the sixteenth century.
Chapter 2 deals with what Yılmaz calls the formative period of Ottoman political thought from the dawn of the fourteenth century to the Egyptian campaign of 1517. As a frontier state at the margins of Muslim expansion, the early Ottoman sultanate was an uncharted landscape of revolutionary ideas in political thought where, in thirteenth-century western Anatolia, mystical political ambitions were boldened by a new breed of Sufi leaders and rulers seeking political sovereignty and further social expansion through mushrooming Sufi fraternities. Sufi orders, among them Mevlevis and Babais, two politically active Sufi orders in the Anatolian and later Balkan regions, nurtured political ambitions and harbored notions of authority in the great transformation of the thirteenth century to negotiate their positions with the established order. In turn, Ottoman political ideals and imageries were drawn from the Ottomans’ own political experience, from appropriation of the Arabic and Persian canons of political theory as well as from their exposure to indigenous practices of authority. In the dialectic of these two practices, the Sufi notions of authority became an integral part of state formation and of the ruling ideology that defined rulership in general, and the caliphate in particular.
In chapter 3, Yılmaz turns to the spectrum of perspectives on the nature of political authority and visions of the sultanate. The significance of the question is evident in the consistent interest of many authors in the nature, content, operation, and history of authority and in the methods of inculcating moral habitus for rulers. Although authors arrived at differing positions in defining and describing political authority, they did not question either its existence or its ontological rank as the noblest station a human being could attain. Yılmaz argues that the modus operandi of Ottoman authors was, commonly at least, conciliation and reconciliation among various models of political authority—including philosopher-king, prophethood, and imamate—with the fact that the Sufi and esoteric under- and overtones were evident in the presentation and argumentation of their writings. Contrary to Abbasid discourses on qualification for rulership, Ottoman Sufis, bureaucrats, and jurists focused on whether authority was attained by grace, merit, or executive power; the dominant view was that it was a grace from God (ni'met), whose absence would lead to the collapse of social order. While the focus on grace made virtually every Sufi saint a potential claimant for the caliphate (and the Ottomans had their share of high-profile uprisings led by rebel mystics challenging Ottoman order), the Ottomans succeeded in defining their rule in Sufi, theological, and historical terms. This new way of thinking about authority (caliphate), according to Yılmaz, was an epistemological break with the Abbasid juristic imperative of high Islam.
Chapter 4 resumes the discussion of perspectives on the nature of authority, visions of the caliphate and its relation to sultanate, and portrayals of the perfect ruler through archetype building and the interpretation of Islamic history. A long-standing question in political discourse since Umayyad times had involved the prophethood of Muhammad, succession to him, and the various capacities through which one could succeed his position. Ottoman Sufis engaged and enriched this discussion by espousing the view that Muhammad had three distinct natures: saintly or spiritual (wilaya), political (saltana), and prophethood (nubuwwa), the latter two emanating from the first one. A substantial number of Sufi-minded supporters of the Ottoman dynasty went by another route. They bypassed Muhammad's mediation in politics and instead imagined the caliph as God's deputy (khalifat Allah) and attributed to the Ottoman ruler the spiritual qualities and powers accorded to the axis mundi (qutb), the perfect human being to whom God entrusted the governance of the creation in Sufi cosmology. Sufi moralism, as distinct from the moral regime of philosophers, ethicists, and jurists, required a prior endowment with godly moral traits (akhlaq Allah) which would engender from the endowed at once a caliph, imam, pole, succor, perfect human being, shadow of God, and vicegerent of God's mercy. A practical application of Ibn Arabi's mystical interpretation of Farabi's notion of philosopher-king, this notion of rulership would parallel the nature and status of ruler-prophets and full manifestation of God's names and attributes.
In chapter 5, Yılmaz examines the Ottoman-Safavid conflict in the sixteenth century to trace the apocalyptic-messianic structuring of imperial ideology and the mystification of the Ottoman caliphate. Yılmaz argues that millennial, eschatological, and messianic anxieties and expectations, the spread of spiritualism across all sectors of the Ottoman establishment, and the challenges of the rising universalist empires in Eurasia prompted the Ottomans to refashion the caliphate through the language of Sufism. Sufi-minded Ottoman historians (and astrologers, geomancers, and craftsmen of divination and occult knowledge under the patronage of Ottoman rulers) wrote about the Ottoman-Safavid competition as a titanic conflict between good and evil since the creation of Adam, the outcome of which was signaled in the well-known Qur'anic verse foretelling the victory of the Romans over the Persians. They also sought an updated noble genealogy for the Ottoman dynasty linking it to ancient dynasties and to the notion of divinely appointed families. They excavated verses from scripture to mold an eschatology foreordaining the rule of the Ottoman dynasty as the seal of the caliphate until the end of time. Through the efforts of Sufi-minded professionals, this esoteric epistemology became a formal part of the teaching of Islam and a significant component of imperial ideology.
In the conclusion, Yılmaz summarizes his main arguments. He notes that by highlighting the notion of unified (spiritual and temporal) authority, the Ottoman Sufis revived the idea of the “true caliphate,” which the jurists reserved for the first four caliphs after the death of Muhammad, and prognosticated its reinstitution at the hands of the Mahdi, whose appearance was seen as imminent or even as having just occurred. In the world of the sixteenth century, the political as well as ideological and administrative challenges coincided with or produced anxiety and ardor among the adherents of the dynasty to attribute a greater meaning to the Ottoman rule, which came to be associated and interchangeable with Rumi/Rumlu (Roman). God's design, the Sufi-proponents of the dynasty claimed, was that the Rum represented the next dawla of Islam, the epochal turn of comprehensive rulership, after that of the Arabs and of the Persians, which would last until the Ottomans delivered the caliphate to the awaited Messiah. The representation of the Ottoman sultan as the true caliph, holding both authorities, emerged as a response to Sufi claims of universal authority, which appeared, at least in their articulation, to surpass and undermine that of the sultan. The turn to Sufism shaped the Ottoman understanding of the caliphate as a unified authority in the image of God's government and granted it a unique status in cosmological time-space. It thus enabled the sultans to reclaim their impaired sovereignty, but at the same time, it subjected them to the requirements of the caliphate as a moral paradigm demanding compliance.
Yılmaz has placed Ottoman political thought in the world-historical context of the sixteenth century, an area of inquiry to which it rightly belongs. His monograph is rich in detail and sources, clearly written, carefully argued, and well-informed. One could point to few structural and technical infelicities, but such criticism would neglect the book's great value in guiding the reader to reflect anew on the trajectory of Ottoman political thought. It is a must-read for scholars and students in the field of Ottoman studies and for those interested in political thought in any region. Although undergraduate students and the lay public will find the details of primary-source material challenging, they will be rewarded by the author's knowledgeable and accessible prose.
