Have your eyes ever glazed over while lawyers argued an obscure point of international human rights law? If so, unless you are a lawyer yourself you have probably wondered, “What's the point?” And if you have ever spent time in the slums of the developing world—the kind where raw sewage flows freely—the futility of international rights discourse must have seemed even more obvious. Why learn the rules of an arcane international legal system that seems to matter so little?
For an alternative view, try Daniel P. L. Chong's 142-page book—(the rest is appendices and notes). Although Freedom from Poverty draws on a limited pool of informants, it ably synthesizes the latest literature and uses sectorwide case studies to claim that exciting changes are afoot. For maximum effect, read this book with other recent discussions of human rights policy, including the quantitative work of Emilie Hafner-Burton and Eric Neumayer; the Amnesty International ethnography by Stephen Hopgood; the advocacy book authored by Amnesty's former secretary general, Irene Khan; and Peter Uvin's book on human rights and development. If you have time for only one quick read, however, Chong's short volume will do the trick.
Chong makes two main points. First, human rights promotion need not be done legalistically. Human rights work has changed, moving from a Cold War–era focus on law and diplomacy toward a vibrant, grassroots-style language of morality and political engagement. Human rights promotion is no longer restricted to stuffy legal debating clubs but can be an exciting arena of political and moral contestation. Second, the human rights movement's focus on civil and political rights is now passé. Although Cold War pressures once forced human rights groups to focus on liberal staples such as elections and torture, those days are long gone. Most Western nongovernmental organizations have incorporated economic and social rights into their mandates, joining forces with southern activists pressing for rights-based attention to poverty. Taken together, Chong claims, these shifts—human-rights-as-morality and human-rights-as-a-response-to-poverty—have revolutionized the business of human rights.
Consider each of these in turn. Chong distinguishes between the “legal approach” to human rights—the one pursued by international lawyers and diplomats—and the “moral approach.” The legal approach is useful, he admits; after all, it never hurts to elaborate international legal standards, reform national legislation, litigate against abuse, and shame violators. Indeed, this approach is still standard operating procedure for many “traditional” NGOs such as Human Rights Watch, as well as some southern NGOs, especially in Latin America.
Yet the legal approach can also create an exclusive, elitist club since it requires the kind of deep familiarity with international law that only a handful of transnational experts truly possess. Thus, while the legal approach may resonate quite well in global hubs and some national capitals, it cannot take root in more popular settings. Consider persuading a Jewish settler, Gujarati policeman, or Cairene slum dweller with quotes from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and you will see what Chong means.
Enter human-rights-as-a-moral-discourse, where practitioners emphasize the systemic nature of poverty, the immorality of deprivation, and the importance of victim self-help. Thus invoked, human rights is no longer restricted to elite legal arenas, but can instead be used as a rallying cry for activists in multiple local contexts. The goal of this approach, Chong argues, is to transform popular social attitudes toward poverty. If activists can make societies regard extreme poverty as an abomination, appropriate legal and policy changes will surely ensue.
The book's second major point is that the human rights discourse has recently shifted from its early focus on civil and political rights. During the Cold War, both Western and Western-supported groups feared being tagged as communists, and thus spent most of their time documenting abuses of liberal norms. This has now changed, Chong claims, and to prove his point he begins with Western NGOs such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty. Both now work on social and economic rights, although Amnesty has gone furthest by adopting a solidarity-style campaign, “Demand Dignity.” Although the author acknowledges that Amnesty probably made the switch for tactical reasons—it was seeking buy-in from southern publics—the change was also heartfelt.
Next, Chong turns to the United States, where social justice, Civil Rights, and antipoverty groups have begun using human rights language to make their points. Although they largely eschew boilerplate references to international law, these local groups make frequent use of the language of rights and fairness, themes that resonate with most ordinary Americans. As a result, he claims, these groups have enjoyed some success in portraying poverty as a fundamental abuse of human dignity. The most prominent example of this success is Barack Obama's campaign on behalf of health-care reform; although proponents rarely invoked the international right to health, human rights moral themes were crucial to their efforts.
Chong's third case focuses on private international aid groups such as CARE and Oxfam, many of which have adopted a “rights-based approach” to development that eschews legal instruments and focuses instead on empowering marginalized communities. Rather than perceiving development as a technical service offered by Westerners to their less fortunate counterparts, the rights-based approach sees aid as a mechanism for enhancing the ability of poor communities to mobilize on their own behalf. International development aid, in this sense, is a social movement capacity-building exercise, rather than a vehicle for transferring technology, skills, and capital.
Chong's analysis is upbeat, and the book has a feel-good quality that may leave younger readers energized and eager to engage. For a more mature social-scientific audience, the book might certainly have benefited from additional social-scientific rigor, attention to methodology and evidence, and a larger dose of skepticism. Although the author does not shy away from intellectual challenges to his views, he has a tendency to advocate rather than analyze, leaving readers unsure as to what empirical reality really is. What, for example, is the precise evidence that a human-rights-as-morality discourse was crucial to Obama's health-care campaign? What evidence do we have that another discourse would not have done the same trick?
Chong also glosses too quickly over faith-based alternatives to secular understandings of rights. With Pentecostal Christianity and other world religions picking up new adherents at breakneck speed (as noted, among others, by Harvey Cox's Fire from Heaven, 2001), can any secular discourse really be as pervasive and powerful as Chong suggests? After reading Freedom from Poverty, few would argue that the contemporary human rights movement has not become more vibrant, poverty focused, and grassroots oriented. Its true global strength and resonance, however, remains unclear, especially when compared to other populist messages promoted by Christian, Muslim, and Hindu activists.
Still, there is little doubt that this book will be a useful supplement for graduate courses on international human rights and development, and as background reading for sector-specific scholars seeking a clearly written overview of recent changes in the human rights movement. The book might also be useful for courses on international law and society, especially those focusing on social constructivism and the law. For undergraduate audiences, individual chapters will be useful. The chapter on human rights in the United States could be integrated into courses on sociology or political science, while the chapters on international human rights and development NGOs are suitable for classes focusing on international development, international politics, and global civil society.
