It takes just a glance at the back cover of Ignacio Walker's new book Democracy in Latin America: Between Hope and Despair to realize we are in the presence of an important piece of scholarly work about the region. Former president of Brazil Fernando Henrique Cardoso praises the book as a very fruitful dialogue between politics and academia, “one politically passionate in its commitment to democracy and intellectually acute in its inquiry about the vicissitudes of representative government in Latin America.” Guillermo O'Donnell stresses the uniqueness of the book for taking “a broad historical view, grounded on a good command of the relevant literature.”
Walker's contribution comes at the right time to fill in an important gap in the study of democracy and democratization in Latin America. This book is a welcome and much needed comprehensive historical journey through the successes and failures of democracy in the region starting with the demise of oligarchic rule in the early decades of the twentieth century.
From the introduction it is evident that we are in safe hands to undertake such a difficult journey. Walker is a political scientist trained at Princeton, but he is much more than that: he is one of a few political scientists who have entered the world of politics equipped with the most influential theories and concepts of the discipline who has had the chance to test them in the laboratory of political praxis. For political scientists alien to the hardships of practical politics this is an important, down-to-earth, and refreshing book. It is also extremely well written and organized.
At the outset, Walker, the political scientist, warns us about the dangers the discipline faces today of turning into a subset of mathematics and applied statistics with little explanatory power. He urges us to step back and bring history into political analysis so as to better understand actors’ rationality.
Walker's main assertion is that political outcomes are not predetermined or inevitable. Even if I have reservations with this particular aspect of Walker's argument—how to assess whether outcome X was indeed inevitable—I agree both with his rejection of theories that stress structural determinants or preconditions to explain political outcomes and his emphasis that “it is primarily the actors, institutions, and public policies that make the difference between progress and regression in Latin American democracy” (5).
Walker serves the profession as well as practitioners concerned with the future of democratic politics in Latin America by making explicit that while most countries of the region have made significant progress in the last decades, there are still some crucial pending tasks before high-quality democracy in the region is fully consolidated.
Democratization, Walker stresses, is not a linear process; academics, practitioners, and citizens should always be alert to the dangers of authoritarian regression. Consequently, Walker rejects the vulgar idea in vogue in some academic and political circles that it is just a matter of time before Latin American democracies improve their quality. This is another type of determinism, one that I personally consider highly dangerous. Walker's message is very clear: progress has been made, but we should never forget the possibility of authoritarian setbacks. In this respect, the public figure and academic meet the citizen. In chapter 3 Walker tells the story of his first encounter with the brutal dictatorship of General Pinochet in Chile in the 1970s, when the high school he was attending (St. George's School, affiliated with the Congregation of the Holy Cross) was taken over by military personnel. In addition, Walker began his professional career as a human rights lawyer (still under the dictatorship). Walker knows better than most about the dangers of the “serpent's egg.” I highly commend his work for reflecting on this.
Walker's book is also a fascinating critical intellectual history of the most influential theories aimed at explaining the successes and failures of democracy in the region in the twentieth century. Page after page Democracy in Latin America is a living example that social science is a collective enterprise.
Walker's journey starts in chapter 1 with a thorough discussion of the crisis of oligarchic domination and the emergence of several ideological and institutional alternatives to fill in the political vacuum it left (liberalism, positivism, revolution, corporatism, patrimonialism, clientelism, socialism, and populism). He concludes that today “we are still trying to consolidate an authentic representative government” (41). Chapter 2 discusses the implementation in the 1930s and 1940s of ISI (import-substitution industrialization) as the dominant economic development model in the region and its interrelationships with the emergence of bureaucratic-authoritarianism and the perils of democracy. Chapter 3 deals with the breakdown, transition, and consolidation of democracy in the 1970s and 1980s. Chapter 4 addresses neoliberal economic restructuring and chapter 5 the reemergence of neopopulist regimes in the 1990s. Chapter 6 reviews contending views about the best institutional frameworks for regime stability in Latin America (presidentialism versus parliamentarism). Walker is rather skeptical about parliamentarism as it has been proposed by most scholars. Chapter 7 deals with the current “new social question” and the need to streamline social policy to address new and old vulnerabilities in a region where, despite sustained economic growth in the last decade or so, inequality remains pervasive.
In chapter 8 Walker brings the historical journey full circle with a sound emphasis on the pending tasks most countries of Latin America face to achieve a high-quality democracy or, in his own words, a democracy of institutions (“a self-sustaining political system capable of producing concrete results for its citizens,” 226). “The biggest political challenge for Latin America, today and in the future, is the transition from an electoral democracy to an authentic representative democracy, while addressing the broader issue of democratic governance” (215). He concludes that “the path towards democratic deepening must be built on gradualism and reformism” (215).
While I fully agree that the major current challenge in Latin America is the need to strengthen representative democratic institutions, I am less convinced by Walker's distrust of institutions of direct democracy. He is right in pointing out the misuse of such mechanisms by opportunistic delegative leaders in many countries of the region. However, in some countries those same mechanisms have significantly contributed to strengthening representative democratic institutions by making the process of political representation more open, accountable, and transparent. Walker does not oppose mechanisms of direct democracy, but he assigns them a secondary role. They should be the exception and not the rule (225). In my view, if we are to strengthen the institutions of representative democracy, institutional innovation to improve citizen's participation is of foremost importance. Walker's contention definitely opens the way for a new debate on institutional design.
In sum, for the several reasons stated above, Walker's book must, and will be, a crucial reference in any discussion of democracy in Latin America, past and present.
