The key contribution of The Silent Sex, by Christopher F. Karpowitz and Tali Mendelberg, is to examine how the representation of female voices in deliberation is influenced by the interaction of the sex ratio of a group with the rule that the group uses for making decisions. The core of the analysis is a controlled experiment in which participants made a nontrivial commitment of two hours of their time and spent an average of 25 minutes in a group deliberation; the extensive analysis of this deliberation included measures of obvious concern such as the sex ratio of talk time, but also investigated more subtle dimensions of deliberation such as word choice and interruption type. The book is a fine contribution to the literature on female representation and serves as an excellent model of social science, addressing a normatively important concern with rich analyses of high-quality empirical evidence.
Chapter 1 introduces the main concern of the study: the underrepresentation of female voices in political deliberation. Chapter 2 reviews the literature on the gender gap in political participation, tracing this underrepresentation not to a lack of education or ability but rather to a lack of motivation and opportunity to participate in political discussions. Chapter 3 then introduces the three key hypotheses of the study: The first hypothesis is that the average woman will participate more in groups in which women comprise a higher percentage of the group, because the increase in female representation increases the authority of women in the group; the second hypothesis is that all-female groups serve as a special case in which the average woman will be especially likely to participate; and the third hypothesis is that the group's sex ratio will interact with the group's decision rule in influencing the representation of female voices in deliberation. Compared to majority rule, “[u]nanimity will elevate both genders when they are in the minority, but women go from underrepresentation to equality, while men go from equality to overparticipation” (p. 93).
Chapter 4 describes the experiment to test these hypotheses: 470 persons from a recruited convenience sample were randomly assigned to a five-member group that had between 0 and 5 women and had either a majority decision rule or a consensus decision rule. The groups deliberated about which of four redistribution principles should govern the distribution of rewards to members of the group on a task that members of the group would subsequently perform, although members of the groups were also instructed to—and did—deliberate the value of the redistribution principles outside of the experimental context.
The next few chapters analyze results from this experiment, such as the average proportion of talk time from men and women (Chapters 5 and 6), the content of the talk (Chapter 7), the style of talk (Chapter 8), and the decisions made by individuals and the group (Chapter 9). There are several important findings in these chapters, many of which were consistent with the interaction hypothesis regarding sex ratio and decision rule. For example, the ratio of female-to-male talk was largest when majority-rule groups contained a supermajority of women and second largest when unanimous-rule groups had only one woman; moreover, lone women were much more likely to introduce topics of special concern to women when the lone woman was in a unanimous-rule group compared to a majority-rule group. In addition, women in the minority were first to articulate a preference regarding the redistribution principles 12.5% of the time in majority rule groups and 37.5% of the time in unanimous rule groups, but respective percentages were 75% and 50% in groups with four women.
Chapter 10 adds external validity to the research, examining the real-world behavior of men and women in school board meetings and in civic dialogue groups. The Conclusion summarizes results, proposes implications of the findings, and discusses the extent to which the findings can be applied to other characteristics such as race and in other domains such as Congress. The book contains an extensive appendix, and the book's website contains additional supplemental materials such as coding instructions and sample transcripts of the deliberations.
The Silent Sex should be of interest to anyone studying gender or deliberation, but it also should be useful as a model of high-quality social science. Measurement of so many aspects of deliberation permitted Karpowitz and Mendelberg to test their hypotheses on many different dimensions, adding richness to the analysis and making the argument of the book more convincing. The regular inclusion of figures was helpful for interpreting results, especially given that the key hypothesis involved an interaction.
One minor stylistic shortcoming of the book is that the analysis at times appeared to be arguing for the hypotheses instead of dispassionately testing the hypotheses; for example, presentation of p-values were used sometimes for two-tailed tests and other times for one-tailed tests, and some regressions included a control for an outlier but did not indicate the coefficient for the outlier. Nonetheless, the sidedness of the tests was clearly labeled, and the text did provide a sense of how extreme the outliers were.
The book's Conclusion addresses many concerns about the generalizability of the findings, but questions nonetheless remain about the extent to which the hypotheses hold for larger groups and for groups comprised of elites. There are also concerns about the application of the finding that, for maximizing the representation of female voices, the ideal decision rule is unanimous rule when women are in the minority and majority rule when men are in the majority. Presumably, many groups face constraints in changing their decision rule due to inertia, practical considerations such as group size, and the perception that one rule is better than the other rule for producing outcomes in particular contexts.
Given the current underrepresentation of women in many political groups, the study's findings suggest that unanimous rule would be the preferred decision rule for these groups. Karpowitz and Mendelberg address the concern that unanimous rule tends toward the status quo, presenting evidence that deadlocking is rare in unanimous-rule juries, and correctly noting that civil juries are more of an analog than criminal juries to the type of deliberation studied in the research. But the status quo might operate differently enough in juries to make deadlock jury rates less relevant: The status quo reversion point for, say, a school board is often the current policy, but the status quo reversion point if a jury deadlocks is often an unjust situation that called for some sort of legal proceeding in the first place. The status quo thus might be more fair and attractive to a minority of members of a political group than to a minority of members of a civil jury. Considering such practical concerns about unanimous rule, it might be worthwhile if future research in this area examined deliberation in larger groups with a supermajority decision rule; presumably, a supermajority-rule group that needs the vote of at least one female would operate similarly to a unanimous-rule group with a minority of female members.
Notwithstanding these concerns, The Silent Sex makes a strong contribution to the fields of gender and deliberation by emphasizing that “the decision rule itself is gendered” (p. 317), in the sense that unanimous rule fosters a more feminine inclusive style of deliberation and majority rule fosters a more masculine competitive style. The study's finding that a group's decision rule interacts with the group's sex ratio to influence the representation of female voices is an important consideration for groups concerned about equalizing participation of its members in deliberation.
