Shawn Miller's latest book positions itself firmly in the field of ‘history as natural history’ taken to Latin America, and produces a synthesis of a historical perspective for the region, stating its aim as follows: ‘This is a history of humans and nature in the Neotropics, the bioregion of tropical and subtropical America that ranges from Mexico and the Caribbean well down into South America's southern cone … My primary focus, however, will be on humans striving to make themselves a tropical home’ (pp. 2–3). Miller narrates Latin America's environmental past, spanning six centuries, from ancient Amerindian civilisations to today's asphyxiated urban habitats, covering a broad range of subjects, from the specialised topic of Tupi agriculture to contemporary popular environmentalism. His book is at once chronologically and topically organised, but distinctive time sequences serve to design chapters and set the course of his analysis. In addition to the introduction, entitled ‘Props and Scenery’, the book's structure includes seven chapters (‘An Old World Before It Was “New”’, ‘Nature's Conquest’, ‘The Colonial Balance Sheet’, ‘Tropical Determinism’, ‘Human Determination’, ‘Asphyxiated Habitats: The Urban Environment’, ‘Developing Environmentalism’), an epilogue (‘Cuba's Latest Revolution’), a ‘Suggested Further Reading’ section, and maps and illustrations that provide a necessary visual supplement.
All these chapters encompass a project that overcomes the limited ‘recentism’ that informs, according to Andrew Sluyter in a 2005 article in Environmental History, the scholarly production on environmental history in the region. Miller's work achieves the not minor task of extending and deepening our understanding of pre-Columbian America and early modern (colonial) times in the Americas, thus contributing to a more comprehensive history of Latin America, in which nature is restored to its rightful place. Belonging to an area that was good news in the field in the 1980s (pioneered by Donald Worster's influential essay ‘History as Natural History: An Essay on Theory and Method’), that of the ‘new [way of writing] history’ (natural sciences and history together again), which renovated and started to take further and further an ancient enterprise never totally forgotten, the project undertaken by Miller also participates in world environmental history. Its twofold mission, formulated by Clive Ponting (A New Green History of the World, 2007), is as follows: ‘How has the environment of the world shaped human history and how have people shaped and altered the world in which they live?’ It is true that humanity remains central to green historians, but as Miller says: ‘History without nature is not only self-serving: it is inaccurate, shortsighted, and potentially perilous to the human story line. For the drama to be complete, we must cast both nature and culture in the role of protagonist, for each have dealt the other health and sickness, aid and harm, and life and death’ (p. 2). For the same reason Miller is compelled to pose a warning that accounts as a sort of justification for doing ‘natural history’: even though ‘humans will remain at the center stage in our drama’, the inanimate objects, the non-human creatures and phenomena, such as soils, metals, parasites, diseases, natural catastrophes, guano and plant maladies, will also become characters in his plot (p. 5). However, Miller's work is not only concerned with this interplay between nature and people at a regional level, but also with making the necessary references and connections to the green history of other geographical locations, such as Europe, North America, Africa and Asia, proposing at the same time a balanced understanding of what a post-colonial reflection has to contribute to an environmental history of Latin America, since colonialism and post-colonial conditions have had a major impact in this region as well as on world history. J. Donald Hughes (What is Environmental History?) pointed out in 2006 the reason behind this globalised awareness: ‘Environmental issues in the twentieth and early twenty-first centuries have increasingly assumed worldwide proportions’, simply because ‘environmental factors operated beyond single cultures and regions even in early times’.
An Environmental History of Latin America is a solid and exemplary interdisciplinary study that seeks to comprehend processes that are both environmental and social, and boldly defies our paradigm based on anthropocentric values and the utopia of unlimited development. It also proposes a new system of ethics for our civilisation: a decisive challenge to our level of consumerism. The main concern of the environmental history practiced by Miller is the question(ing) of sustainability. In this context, the author focuses on four major themes: ‘population, technology, attitudes toward nature, and attitudes toward consumption’ (p. 4). Miller analyses the contradictory relationship in recent years between our unprecedented environmental awareness and our devastating actions, and he is fully (and sadly) aware that ‘sustainability is largely a human-centered aspiration. It promises nothing to the rest of nature's health and survival, just to that of humans’ (p. 6). Going back to the beginning of the book in order to end this review there, we want to take note of how Miller finishes his introductory pages with a seemingly tragic/apocalyptic stand and a prophetic statement, which combined are a sort of anticipated lesson worthy of being listened to: his vision of the future implies a hypothesis that human-caused destruction of the environment is imminent, and the action to prevent it must be instantly applied. Such projection of the future entails a radical adjustment of our attitudes toward nature, and highlights the necessity of re-examining our values, reorienting our cultural goals and stimulating environmental awareness; ‘[e]ven if our civilizations will hereafter not require the biodiversity that much of the rest of nature provides, the next evolution in environmental thought must be the realization that we desperately want it anyway’ (p. 7). While creating an excellent (transatlantic) panorama of the environmental history of Latin America and its global implications, which begins with an invaluable survey of pre-Colombian societies, continues with discovery and colonial (re)considerations, and concludes with a discussion of current practices and future developments, Miller's work makes an indispensable contribution to the conceptualisation and feasibility of sustainability, one of the most relevant and urgent problems of our time, giving Latin America a central and strategic place in the discussion.
