In 1900, tribes claiming descent from the Turkic warrior Oghuz-khan and calling themselves “Turkmen” were dispersed throughout the Middle East and Central Asia. The Teke, Yomut, Gökleng, and other tribes stretched from Anatolia to Iraq and Russian Turkestan. Despite a common genealogy, a dizzying array of factors shaped very distinctive identities among them. They spoke a variety of dialects, inhabited at least five states, occupied different positions on a continuum between nomadic and sedentary life, and adhered to descent groups that often clashed with one another.
Within three turbulent decades, the Soviet Union had dramatically reshaped this landscape. However, socialism was not the sole instrument of transformation. Along with the Red Army and the brutal discipline of the collective farm, the Soviets introduced a 19th-century European understanding of nationhood. Out of a tsarist colony inhabited by a heterogeneous population marked by fluid identities, the Soviets sought to forge a homogenous and clearly demarcated “Turkmen nation,” alongside Uzbek, Tajik, Kyrgyz, Kazakh, and other nations. By 1936, a Turkmen Soviet Socialist Republic—with a fixed territory and borders, a standardized language, an official flag, and a national elite—stretched from the Caspian Sea to the borders of Iran, Afghanistan, and the neighboring Soviet republics.
The remarkable story of Soviet attempts to make Central Asians “modern,” by which they meant socialist and nationalist minded, is the subject of this brilliant book. In elegant prose and rich detail, Adrienne Edgar presents a highly original reinterpretation of the Soviet impact on the region. Her research affirms an interpretive shift, born in the early 1990s, that views the Soviet state not as the “breaker” but the “maker” of nations and challenges the Cold War notion that the Soviets created the Central Asian republics as part of a strategy of “divide and rule.” This is where her agreement with this new scholarship largely ends, however. Drawing on recently declassified archives in Russia as well as Turkmen-language printed sources, Edgar's case study goes well beyond the Moscow-based party functionaries, state planners, and ethnographers whom others have identified as the actors most responsible for Soviet nation making.
Tribal Nation breaks from this top-down approach and focuses instead on interactions between Moscow and local elites. It shows how Turkmen intellectuals and communists, many of whom had received secular educations under the tsars or had been exposed to Muslim reformism and nationalism elsewhere, embraced the proposition that Turkmen formed a nation defined by a common territory and language. Unlike other scholars who have highlighted the invented or imagined character of nationhood, Edgar remains attentive to the inherited cultural and social material that elites struggled to mold into nations. The Soviets did not invent a sense of “Turkmen-ness” out of nothing. A genealogical basis for Turkmen identity had preceded the revolution. Combined with the Soviet strategy of “nativizing” institutions and the drawing of republican boundaries, such indigenous concepts quickly gave rise to entrepreneurs who engaged the Bolsheviks and their linguistic and territorial understanding of nationhood. They adopted the Soviet view that Turkmen should reside in a “national” republic ruled by a Turkmen elite, and they promoted themselves to fill these positions of authority. However, this is not simply a story of collaboration. Edgar convincingly shows how Turkmen elites not only participated in the process of nation making but shaped it in fundamental ways—for example, by insisting on the location of boundaries, laying claim to territory and assets, and constructing a “supratribal” literary language.
In telling the story of nation building, Edgar never loses sight of the Soviet commitment to socialism. The Bolsheviks waged war against the “backwardness” of the tsarist empire and sought to foster progress—and loyalty to the Soviet system—by transforming the Tsar's colonized peoples into modern, socialist nations. Edgar eloquently brings out the contradictions that haunted this project. Russians protested ethnic preferences designed to indigenize the party and state apparatus as reverse discrimination, while disappointed Turkmen protested the regime's failure to live up to its promise of equality among nationalities. Seeking to mobilize Turkmen and supplant tribal identities through land reform, promotion of class conflict, and emancipation of women, the party-state only reinforced the importance of descent groups. Turkmen villagers manipulated official categories such as “class” to pursue clan rivalries and reasserted patriarchal controls. Elites produced by Moscow's policies chafed under its increasingly centralized and repressive control. In the early 1930s, the radical pursuit of socialism through forced collectivization prompted rebellions and emigration but also undermined national construction: “The Soviet assault on ‘backwardness,’” Edgar writes, “targeted the practices that most clearly defined Turkmen identity, including their distinctive genealogical structures and practices relating to marriage and the family” (pp. 13–14).
Edgar's masterful reconstruction of the tensions that burdened these contradictory projects and her careful attention to the power of Turkmen actors to shape their local outcomes make this book a landmark achievement in the study not only of the USSR and Central Asia but of the phenomenon of nationalism as well. Beautifully written and tightly argued, it is a model for scholars interested in similar themes in the Middle East and Eurasia. Finally, Tribal Nation stands out as an indispensable guide to contemporary Central Asian politics. Although the glow of the red star of communism has faded over the deserts and oases of the region, the hammer (if not the sickle) of Soviet-style nationhood lives on.
