Much has been written about Chile and Argentina's endeavours to confront the legacy of state-sponsored atrocities committed during the dictatorships in the 1970s and 1980s. Impunity, Human Rights, and Democracy: Chile and Argentina, 1990–2005, is an important contribution to the existing body of scholarship, particularly for its carefully accounting of the end of impunity and renewed possibilities of judicial accountability. As Professor Wright notes in the acknowledgements, the book explores how ‘advocates of justice were able to break down the formidable walls of impunity’, accomplishing a feat unseen in other societies that returned to democracy: ‘the door to justice’ was reopened against ‘all former repressors who violated human rights’.
Unlike earlier cases, such as Greece, Bolivia and South Korea, which meted out forms of ‘exemplary justice’ (p. 2) through prosecutions limited in number and time, Chile and Argentina stand out for their broad and prolonged justice efforts in recent years. Impunity was lifted not just in few, selected, cases. Rather, quoting Kathryn Sikkink, a ‘justice cascade’ process has been unfolding on both sides of the Andes, with prosecutions against ‘intellectual authors, torturers, and killers’, as well as anyone deemed potentially complicit in human rights violations (p. 3).
Upon transition in the 1980s and 1990s, justice for the dictatorships' atrocities seemed beyond reach. Wright convincingly shows how enduring efforts by domestic and international human rights activists, evolving legal environments, unanticipated events, and changes to the armed forces generated a conjuncture of factors ultimately triggered a profound questioning of impunity and the renewing of judicial investigations against hundreds of perpetrators in Argentina and Chile. In the book, the author equates impunity to the absence of judicial prosecutions. It would have been interesting to include a deeper discussion and conceptualisation of this complex question, to address interrelated themes including the existence of a culture of impunity, the societal and cultural consequences as well as remnants of having lived through state terror, whether or not prolonged times of impunity affected these societies' human rights culture, and whether current trials can successfully guarantee non-repetition of abuses in the future.
The book unfolds over six chapters. Chapter 1 traces the origins of state terrorism to the Cuban Revolution and the ‘wave of revolutionary activity’ that shocked Latin America's status quo (p. 6). Increased military aid, training, and equipment provided by the United States to Latin American militaries, together with the ideological underpinning of the National Security Doctrine and the global Cold War, resulted in counterinsurgency warfare across the region. Upon usurping democratic government, on 11 September 1973 and 24 March 1976 respectively, Chile and Argentina's state terrorist regimes set upon the physical extermination of all forms of political opposition. Through networks of hundreds of clandestine detention centres, thousands of people were systematically tortured, murdered, imprisoned and disappeared. The final numbers of victims of disappearances in Argentina ranges from 9,000 (confirmed by the truth commission) and 30,000 (claimed by human rights groups). In Chile, investigations by successive truth commissions corroborated 3,216 dead and disappeared and 38,254 victims of political imprisonment and torture.
The origin and the consolidation of impunity are tackled in chapter 2. The implosion of the Argentine junta in the aftermath of the defeat in the 1982 Falklands/Malvinas War and the military's weak position allowed new president Raúl Alfonsín to undertake policies of truth and limited justice. The 1984 historic Nunca Más (Never Again) truth commission report and the unparalleled 1985 Trial of the Military Juntas exposed to Argentine society the full extent of political brutality. Subsequently, backing down to military rebellions and pressure in the late 1980s, the government adopted amnesty laws and pardons securing impunity from prosecution. Despite similar demands for truth and justice, Chile's negotiated transition and protected democracy had been designed and put in place to guarantee impunity, well before the return of democracy. President Patricio Aylwin's words that he could only pursue justice en la medida de lo posible (to the extent possible) exposed the limitations of Chile's democracy after the dictatorship (p. 105).
In chapter 3, Wright argues how ‘forceful and persistent human rights advocacy was central to the erosion and collapse of impunity in Chile and Argentina’ (p. 43). Similar to what Margaret Keck and Kathryn Sikkink famously labelled ‘boomerang effect’ of transnational advocacy networks, local human rights movements in Chile and Argentina successfully reached out to the international human rights lobby to generate a ‘shifting constellation of actors’ including intergovernmental agencies, NGOs, governments, and individuals, which relentlessly denounced past atrocities and pressured their respective governments to bring former perpetrators to justice.
A complementary and indispensable element in the struggle against impunity is the subject of chapter 4, namely, the changing domestic and international legal environment. During state terrorism, Chile and Argentina's judiciaries had turned a blind eye to the repression, rejecting thousands of habeas corpus petitions and calls to investigate. With the return of democracy, judicial reforms and the evolution of international human rights law throughout the 1990s permitted local justice advocates to call upon international jurisprudence and push national courts to judicially investigate past atrocities.
Chapter 5 discusses precipitating events, such as the 1995 (in)famous confession on the vuelos de la muerte (death flights) by Navy Captain Adolfo Scilingo in Argentina and the 1998 London arrest of General Pinochet. Both events, together with other local anniversaries and developments, amplified existing justice demands. The eclipse of impunity, analysed in chapter 6, was not immediate but, rather, required the undermining of its legal foundations, most often in the form of amnesty laws and decrees, as well as the weakening of military opposition to the justice process. By 2005, activists, victims' families, the local and international human rights movement, had been able to reopen the way for justice.
But, did the end of impunity lead to justice commensurate to the gravity of state terrorism crimes?
In the conclusion, Wright answers that question in the affirmative and also assesses the different levels of justice achieved in Chile and Argentina. He notes some limitations of these processes, such as the leniency of the sentences dictated and the limited number of convicted perpetrators spending any time in jail in Chile vis-à-vis much tougher sentences served in regular prisons in Argentina. Despite these shortcomings, the author highlights ‘the remarkable, unprecedented course of overcoming impunity in Argentina and Chile’ (p. 128). In embarking upon a path of justice moving away from exemplary trials, Chile and Argentina set the bar ‘high for advocates of justice’ in other countries (p. 128). The latest statistics available on Argentina support Wright's main argument on the success of the justice process: a total of 514 trials (complete or in progress), with 2,166 individuals investigated: 622 individuals condemned, 57 absolved, and 883 currently facing trial (see: http://www.fiscales.gob.ar/lesa-humanidad/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2015/11/Informe-Lesa-final.pdf).
This book convincingly depicts the endurance of truth and justice demands in Argentina and Chile. Withstanding the test of time and overcoming times of impunity, the author beautifully narrates how justice advocates effectively restored, against many odds, the possibility of justice through innovative and creative strategies, achieving unprecedented results in the history of transitional justice.
