Daniel Levitin's preceding book, This is Your Brain on Music (Reference LEVITIN2006), has attracted considerable attention and provides a fascinating, readable exploration of how the brain engages with music. In The World in Six Songs Levitin takes his findings a step further in order to explore, as the book's subtitle puts it, ‘how the musical brain created human nature’ (my italics). Any book making such an assertion on its front cover must surely warrant further investigation by those of us working in music education.
In some senses the book has many companions, such as Anthony Storr's Music and the Mind (Reference STORR1992), Steven Mithen's The Singing Neanderthals (Reference MITHEN2005) and Musicophilia (2007) by Oliver Sacks, as well as the work of many music psychologists and ethnomusicologists. However, part of what makes Levitin's contribution so fascinating is his unique credentials: a college dropout who opted instead to pursue life on the road in a rock band, then becoming a successful record producer, he is now, after finding his way back into medicine, the James McGill Professor of Psychology and Neuroscience at McGill University, Montreal, where he runs the Laboratory for the Study of Music Perception, Cognition and Expertise. The range, mastery and enquiry of Levitin's own brain are quite staggering.
The ‘six songs’ of the title are in fact what Levitin sees as the six essential categories of song: songs of friendship, joy, comfort, knowledge, religion and love. Each category is the subject of a chapter and these chapters are preceded by an opening chapter in which Levitin lays foundations for what is to follow. This first chapter is rich in musical, anthropological and psychological theories and makes interesting reading in itself. In other chapters some familiar concepts sometimes emerge in new light. Consider this brief reference to knowledge songs within the songs of love chapter:
those individuals who enjoyed learning were better able to adapt to changing environments and social conditions. (And as a consequence, they were favoured by natural selection). (p. 241)
This discussion of knowledge songs from thousands of years ago has a ring of many present-day school assemblies concerned with lifelong learning and adaptable skills in a rapidly changing world.
Through each of the song categories Levitin explores the central role of music in our development as a species and in the evolution of the brain. He convincingly demonstrates that music is a fundamental human activity, crucial to the creation of societies and cultures, much more than optional entertainment. He draws freely on a wide range of sources, from challenging scientific explanation to personal anecdote, taking in along the way conversations with songwriters including Pete Seeger, Sting, David Byrne and Joni Mitchell. Sometimes we are given precise references and sometimes none at all: I really did want to know where the psychological study of dogs to which he refers on page 220 might be found. At some points I began to feel that something rather fanciful was being laid before me but then turned the page to encounter intriguing evidence, such as the nocturnal musical activities of the Mekranoti people (p. 46). At other times, in the description of the vegetation around a conference venue for instance (p. 146), Levitin is shamelessly indulgent. It should be said that Levitin does state clearly that he is aware of the potential for personal bias and there is no intention to provide a strictly academic text. He certainly could not be accused of failing to engage personally (and passionately) with his subject.
Perhaps the fluctuations in style help balance some of the more challenging scientific details, resulting in a very approachable book that has appeal for a wide readership. One might debate Levitin's interpretations of some of his anecdotes, for example the fight between Eddie and Victor (p. 124) which Levitin ascribes to passions aroused by differing musical tastes and the relevance to Eddie's family of one particular song – it seemed to me that the fight was as much to do with personalities, Victor's taunts and bullying and the surrounding workplace tensions. Conversely, when drawing on his immense neurological understanding, there is much less ground for debate. The roles of prolactin, oxytocin and other neurochemicals are explained in a convincing and comprehendible manner. The science inevitably is not always easy but Levitin adopts a constructive and non-patronising approach, employing only as much science as is necessary. This may be what prompted Sir George Martin to comment that Levitin ‘explains it all beautifully’. The exploration of uniquely musical processes such as perspective, re-arrangement and representation, as well as the integration of music and dance and music and words, are equally fascinating. One area that seemed to be missing for me was reference to neurodiversity, given both our growing understanding of how the brains of many people process various things in different ways and the growth particularly in America and Australia of a lobby that takes the view that such individuals, be they autistic, dyslexic or suffer mood disorders, ‘have arguably been sidelined by the disability debate’ (Jacobs, Reference JACOBS2010).
Nonetheless, this is worthy reading for all of us involved in music in education. The thinking that Levitin provokes will equip us for those recurring situations in which we are called upon to articulate and justify music's place in the curriculum. For trainee teachers of music the book is worthy of attention. For many trainees the values and significance of music are often personal, assumed and implicit. The World in Six Songs is a great contribution to making these values a little less subjective and considerably more explicit. Levitin also reminds us all that ‘good melody (let alone rhythm) knows no boundaries of class, education or upbringing’ (p. 11). If we take this to refer broadly to all aspects of and all genres of music, there lies a philosophy that should be at the heart of every school music department.
