The Golem is a beast of Yiddish lore. Made out of mud and then brought to life, the Golem is able to defend its master against any onslaught. But it is also unreliable. It can go out of control and wreak wanton destruction. Dr. Golem is a very welcome third volume in Harry Collins and Trevor Pinch's well-known ‘Golem’ series dealing with the nature and ironies of science and technology. The major strength of the previous two volumes was their accessibility, and on this score Dr. Golem does not disappoint. It follows the tried and tested formula of collecting case studies, each based on a number of main sources, linked by commentary. As in the earlier volumes, the cautioning metaphor of the Golem is candidly deployed to evoke the shortcomings and ambiguities in science. The implication is that no matter how sophisticated the science of medicine becomes there are still countless concepts, actions and effects that are contradictory and clumsy. In the view of Collins and Pinch, modern medicine has grown into a discipline that exercises the power to heal but acutely suffers blindness to its imprecision. Although the authors' clear-cut writing makes this message palatable, answers to the big questions brought up lie buried beneath the case studies.
The eight cases considered by Collins and Pinch from the recent history of medicine are fascinating, sometimes amusing, sometimes unsettling. What unites them is the way each carries broader implications for the current state of medicine. Collins and Pinch use case studies to explore the blurring of two main identities for modern medicine, as a science and as a source of ‘succour’ (p. 2). Nowhere is this more apparent than in their discussion of what they call the ‘hole in the heart of medicine’ (p. 18): the placebo effect. With compelling clarity, they devote a whole chapter to dissecting this phenomenon and the paradoxes that accompany it. Though it is still not clearly explained by science, the placebo effect shapes much of medical practice and both doctors' and patients' unconscious evaluation of their encounters. As such, medicine's stubbornness to transform easily into a ‘discourse of evidence-based science’ has implications for therapeutic encounters and the introduction of new drugs.
Subsequent chapters further explore the Golem-like character of modern medicine. A chapter on the diagnostic inconsistency among ‘real’ doctors when confronted with ostensibly innocuous things such as inflamed adenoids and tonsils makes for alarming reading. The invention of ‘new’ diseases also gets the customary treatment, especially chronic fatigue syndrome, Gulf War syndrome and fibromysalgia. The authors expertly question the commonly accepted medical wisdom of the effectiveness of cardio-pulmonary resuscitation. The current debate about the relationship between autism and vaccinations – especially the triple measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine – features in a particularly strong section. A chapter on the patient as expert uses the history of AIDS. (This last chapter is reprinted from the earlier volume on technology.)
Like their readers, the authors have intimate relationships with medicine, while medicine has both worldwide and personal missions. Throughout the volume the authors self-consciously present themselves as patients as well as sociologists. Such reflexivity is seen most memorably in the chapter on the MMR vaccine conflict, on which Collins and Pinch have conflicting views. Their volume is not, it should be emphasized, a radical assault on conventional medicine; they do not particularly endorse alternative medicine or even call for the uncritical democratization of conventional medicine. If anything, they want medicine to be more scientific, not less so. In discussing the ways in which sufferers have their own kind of valued knowledge base beyond the immediate experience of illness, Collins and Pinch point out, for instance, that many AIDS activists became knowledgeable in how antiviral drugs work and in the design of clinical trials. Although insisting that meaningful dialogue about scientific issues requires that both parties know what they are talking about, Collins and Pinch acknowledge the difficulties in the creation of the patient-as-expert, especially given the unregulated nature of the Internet.
Dr. Golem provides an intriguing and considered examination of modern medicine's flaws. Yet Collins and Pinch are reticent about what might be done to change it for the better. They diagnose medicine as Golem-like, but provide no panacea, let alone treatment. There are also oversights. For example, the chapter entitled ‘Alternative medicine’ is not particularly about alternative medicine. Linus Pauling and Ewan Cameron's recommendation of vitamin C as a cure for cancer was articulated within the frame of scientific medicine, not ‘alternative’ medicine. Ultimately, the value of this book lies in the context it provides to consider its questions rather than its actual answers. Like the other volumes in the series, Dr. Golem works wonderfully well as an introductory text to the sociological analysis of medicine.
