This is a campaigning book, but it is also much more than that, carried forward on a wealth of insight, a breadth of source material and the voices of the very large number of people in Brazil and Mexico whom John Gledhill has interviewed and whose lives he has in some cases followed for many years. The author has an irrepressible inclination to see situations from many different points of view, especially when he comes to Mexico. He has been working there for too long to think that any story with the slightest political connotation in that country can be told in a linear narrative, and much the same applies to his depiction and interpretation of security in low-income areas of Brazil's great metropolises. These qualities of listening and seeing from many points of view prevent the book from falling into moralism or self-confident opinionating, despite the sometimes painful nature of its subject matter.
The chapters on Brazil describe the UPP (Unidades de Polícia Pacificadora) introduced in Rio de Janeiro in the early 2000s as part of multi-agency operations to upgrade and ‘clean up’ some of the favelas which had become no-go areas – independent republics living, as is well known, under a mafia-style order. The package included property titling to raise the value of dwellings and encourage people to invest in them, permanent presence of police units to put an end to ‘no-go areas’, and formalisation or legalisation of electricity and water provision (to put an end to illegal and dangerous connections).
These initiatives, so easily labelled neoliberal, also have much to recommend them to social democrats: recognising that inhabitants of less desirable low-income and ill-served neighbourhoods, variously known as favelas (only in Rio), periferia (in São Paulo), or comunidades (in Salvador da Bahia), are victims equally of violence perpetrated by police and drug traffickers, the UPP model ticks many boxes: it attempts to bring a new approach to policing, to remove the drugs traffickers, or at least the ‘big fish’, and then to introduce the services which are provided to other urban areas, such as legalised electricity, water and sanitation plus legalisation of property. But first comes security, and since the traffickers resist, the operation retains a repressive dimension. Keeping the police away from the traffic is a big challenge.
Gledhill's account brings to the surface underlying issues, notably the heterogeneity of the target or beneficiary population, and the many ways in which the line between that population and the rest of the city is less clear-cut than ready-made dualisms lead one to believe: in the wake of the UPP-induced upgrading, slightly more respectable or prosperous people move in, tourists are brought by the merchants of social voyeurism; those who cannot afford the utility charges and taxes brought by legalisation move out, while traffickers move on to other areas or back to the areas ‘where they came from’.
Housing projects built under the federal government's low-cost housing programme (Minha casa minha vida) have been intimidated by milicias – gangs of serving or retired security personnel, running all sorts of extortion rackets related to the purchase of electricity, water, cable connections and even the food stamps known as ‘cesta básica’ (a minimum list/basket of groceries). (In this case people were forced to use their stamps at certain shops where they would get a raw deal.)
Moving on to Salvador da Bahia, Gledhill describes in sometimes feverish detail the multiple motives and interests behind a similar programme, known as Base Comunitaria de Segurança (BCS). In lengthy conversations with female police officers, Gledhill is impressed by their ‘ethic of public service’ which he sees as a ‘manifestation of class consciousness’, but it turns out that they are biding their time before going to university and qualifying for another sort of career, not least because community policing is not the way up the police hierarchy to better pay and status.
When he comes to Mexico the reader is drawn to a spine-chilling world reminiscent of that described (for another region) by Juan Rulfo, notably in El llano en llamas. The book covers events which sometimes have their origins back in Salinas’ rigged election of 1988, with observations spanning high and low politics, provincial sub-cultures varying from rugged manliness to local defensiveness, all wrapped in political and criminal networks and social milieux from the presidency down to the smallest hamlet, from Chiapas to Guerrero and Michoacán itself, and extending to the revolutionaries of Guerrero in the 1960s (involving a mix of Catholics, Maoists and authentic peasant resistance). At the core of his account is a chapter on paramilitaries and autodefensas, in which the actors are indigenous farmers, mestizo rancheros, local, state and national politicians, drug barons high and low, teenage workers recruited as foot soldiers, schoolteacher-dealers, police, army, marines, lawyers, state governors, and at least two presidents – Calderón and Peña Nieto. There are walk-on parts for earlier presidents and for the Zapatista National Liberation Army, for a Chinese company swapping chemical inputs for drugs manufacture for iron (hundreds of thousands of tons of it). For Gledhill all these elements, Brazilian and Mexican, fit in to a larger scheme of capital accumulation – the construction industry and the utilities in Rio and São Paulo, mining and plans for a seaside tourist development encroaching on some of the land at stake in Michoacán.
There is also an indigenous interest, deeply entwined with the other elements: if there is a beginning to the story it is in a decades-old claim to land in the area of Ostula, promoted and resisted by various individuals and institutions. The violence leads indigenous leaders to transform their own longstanding community policing, in which service rotated among the members, into heavily armed autodefensas, which are drawn into the wars. At first the authorities recognise the autodefensas but eventually, for murky reasons, they clamp down on some of them violently. There are indigenous on many sides and they have interests in more than the classic indigenous issue of land. Gledhill pins no blame – except on some presidents and state governors: the impersonality of his account makes one understand intuitively why in some cultural contexts evil is understood as a supernatural force abroad in a community or a family, which takes possession of human agents.
The purpose of this book's rather alarmist title is to draw attention to the ways in which insecurity among the disenfranchised draws states into securitisation. Gledhill is not so naïve as to think that policing is irrelevant to the reduction of violence, and he therefore would like to see reforms of the police which would discipline their use of arms and of course immunise them from the corrupting influences which surround them. He does not parade facile solutions or utopian alternative worlds, so his pessimism falls short (just) of catastrophism, and he makes some quite pragmatic proposals. He is above all an anthropologist who is most at home in the field, listening, and whose passionate convictions come from what he hears.
