No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
Few Westerners enjoy Graham Fuller's breadth of experience in the Muslim-majority world. Decades of government work and extensive travel after retirement clearly have made him comfortable in an area stretching from North Africa to Indonesia. The book under review reflects Fuller's intellectual odyssey into the world of political Islam, which in its modern forms has largely developed on his watch.
Fuller's book begins promisingly. He usefully begins by defining an “Islamist” as “one who believes that Islam as a body of faith has something important to say about how politics and society should be ordered in the contemporary Muslim world and who seeks to implement this idea in some fashion” (p. xi). While many who write for public audiences seek to elide “Islamist,” “fundamentalist,” and “jihadist” into one threatening ball of pathological behavior, Fuller manages to define the word “Islamist” in a way that concentrates on the mainstream of the phenomenon rather than on its most radical extremes.
The first part of the book explores the growing intersection of Islam and politics in the 20th century, portraying it as a response to internal and external factors and, not least, the colonial legacy and the failure of secular politics to deliver either freedom or prosperity in the modern period. Fuller's account reflects thousands of conversations he has had on these subjects with Muslims, but he does not situate this discussion in either the Western academic debate or the public debates going on in Muslim communities. One is left with Fuller's conclusions, but it is hard for an uninitiated reader to understand how he arrived at them or to get a sense of what is contested and what is generally accepted in what he says.
Fuller's predilection for presenting conclusions rather than the reasoning that led him to them is even more evident in his chapter on Islam and terrorism, which feels as if it was dropped into the middle of the book after 11 September. He asserts, for example, that “[n]early all Muslims including a broad range of Islamist leaders, immediately condemned the attack as a crime against the tenets of Islam” (p. 84). He offers no examples or qualifications, and he appears untroubled when he notes the lingering assumption of many that the attack was not done by Muslims at all but was, in fact, a Mossad plot. Similarly, he writes that “[m]ost Muslims, including most Islamists admire U.S. political values, even when uncomfortable with many U.S. social values (or absence thereof)” (p. 86). What is one to make of contrary views that one has read in the press, on Islamist websites, and elsewhere? In yet another instance, Fuller asserts that Islam unambiguously condemns violence against civilians and cites Khaled Abou El Fadl, an erudite and learned U.S.-based scholar. Abou El Fadl is one authority, but he is neither the most authoritative nor the most influential. His judgment of what is and is not permissible under Islamic law is hardly the last word, especially in the face of the large number of Muslim clerics—such as the al-Jazeera personality Shaykh Yusuf Qaradawi and the former Egyptian Mufti Shaykh Nasr Farid Wassel—who have ascertained various exceptions to rules barring such violence. Not only does Fuller not engage with contrary ideas; in those instances where he acknowledges them, he swiftly marginalizes the extremists and moves on.
The remaining chapters return to his earlier theme: that political Islam is a natural outgrowth of Islam and the historical experiences of Muslims. He calls for understanding toward authoritarian Islamist regimes such as Afghanistan, Iran, and Sudan, asserting that their authoritarianism is an outgrowth not of Islam but of these countries' authoritarian past and their troubled present. He argues that the true judgment of Islam in politics can come only after an Islamic regime arises in a democratic state, and he points hopefully to Turkey as an example.
Time after time, Fuller emphasizes exculpatory evidence for Islamic thought and minimizes the debates going on within it. At the same time, he has a far keener eye for incriminating statements from Western figures than from Islamic ones. He argues, for example, that Islam has no historical beef with Judaism or Christianity and suggests that “any latent tensions with Jews were rekindled, redramatized and intensified 1,400 years later by contemporary hostility between the modern state of Israel and the Muslim world.” Western hatred runs deeper, apparently. The next paragraph quotes the evangelist Franklin Graham saying, “The God of Islam is not the same God … It's a different God and I believe it is a very evil and wicked religion” (pp. 147–48). Does anyone doubt that intolerant, xenophobic, and hateful utterances have come from Muslim clerics? Indeed, they are legion, but Fuller neither contextualizes nor explains them because he determines that they are not mainstream.
Most of this book is about the past and the present, but it is clear that when Fuller looks forward, he cannot envision a democratic future for the Middle East that does not contain a special role for Islam. That judgment is likely right, and for many of the reasons Fuller cites in his book.
Sadly, however, this book is unlikely to create the debate it clearly hopes to incite. Academics will be put off by the author's lack of engagement with the academic literature, the sweeping breadth of the material, and the author's tendency to use bullets and italics—rather than grammar and language—to emphasize his key points. A popular readership will have a hard time absorbing it, because it contains few of the anecdotes, quotations, and illustrative details that help make complex topics digestible. Finally, those critical of political Islam will dismiss Fuller as a mere apologist.
This is a shame, because this book is based on considerable experience and contains many savvy judgments. It is clearly empathetic to the struggles of Muslim-majority populations to shape their own societies and to define the place of those societies in the global community, and one can learn much from it. But in that struggle is a remarkable vitality, and that vitality is missing in this otherwise valuable book.