Leigh K. Jenco treats the subject matter differently from many similar studies: instead of writing an intellectual biography, she treats Zhang Shizhao (1881–1973) as a serious political theorist who is not only a learner and adapter of Western political theory but also a contributor to it. The book does not focus on the interactions between Zhang's thought and the enormous social turmoil he went through, as do many similar studies when it comes to the question how Chinese intellectuals try to save the country by studying Western ideas. This is remarkable in view of the fact that Zhang had worked closely with such drastically different Chinese political leaders as Yuan Shikai, a general of China's last dynasty who put an imperial crown on his own head in the end; Duan Qirui, an early Republican general who became a premier; Chen Duxiu, a founder of the Chinese Communist Party; Sun Yet-Sen, founder of Kuomintang; Du Yuesheng, one of the most infamous mafia heads in modern Chinese history; and, last but not least, Mao Zedong, Red China's ruler from 1949 through 1976.
The first part of the book, in two chapters, deals with some theoretical issues related to Zhang's ideas and the historical background against which his political thought emerged. In chapter 1, Jenco criticizes the Eurocentric tendency in Western scholarship and resists the idea of “comparative political theory,” because it implies that those theories from non-Western countries are “the other,” not an integral part of political theory as a whole. For Jenco, many scholars “present Western traditions as inevitable aspects of all theorizing, in the process suppressing or ignoring the indigenous traditions of inquiry that have motivated political thinking in diverse places and times” (9).
Chapter 2 is supposed to discuss the historical background against which Zhang's ideas emerged. But the author has chosen to focus on Zhang's involvement in the magazine Tiger during the period 1914–1917, not his entire career. This treatment leaves some crucial questions underexplored, because, first of all, Zhang's ideas were not static. For instance, during the late Qing period, Zhang was a strong advocate of constitutional reform. After 1919, however, Zhang started to doubt the suitability of Western-style institutions for China (37). In addition, the evolution of Zhang's ideas was closely connected with his career. For instance, Zhang's later reluctance to pursue parliamentary government allowed the authoritarian Quan Qirui to appoint him minister of education in 1924 (37). Although Zhang's Tiger magazine was influential, it eventually lost out to Chen Duxiu's New Youth, as the Chinese enlightenment during the Republican era became more radicalized in the 1920s (77).
Part 2 of the book, “Founding,” has three chapters. Chapter 3 deals with the issue of the founding of a democratic regime in China, especially the issue “who are the prime movers, if any?” In Jenco's view, Zhang did not believe that China needed a benevolent lawgiver who could impose a new political system on the Chinese people. Instead, he advocated the idea that individual action could be capable of bringing about self-rule where such practice did not exist (49). “Individual exemplary acts can both challenge authority and justifiably embody it” (65). For Zhang, “natural rights” equaled liangzhi, or conscience (57). Zhang believed that although each person may strive in idiosyncratic but meaningful ways, these ways may become aligned with each other in a vision of order. “This vision is informed, however, not by cosmological patterns or Heavenly mandate but by intuitions about what will and will not resonate with fellow citizens” (67).
In chapter 4, “‘Rule by Man’ and ‘Rule by law,’” Jenco interprets Zhang to mean that the two concepts mentioned in the chapter title are complementary, although many people believe that he tended toward rule of law. Zhang promoted liberal institutionalism and rejected rule-by-man theories in his early career. Later, Zhang realized that self-cultivation is useful for the founding of a democratic system too. For Zhang, “constitutions are matters of politics and history, not purely matters of laws” (68). Zhang was not alone in his change of mind regarding this issue. For instance, before 1911, Liang Qichao advocated constitutional reform. After 1911, he did not believe that the time was ripe for democracy in China (83). The “rule of law” argument encountered two major obstacles in China then. First, China's institutional reform during the early Republican period was not successful: Yuan Shikai dissolved the legislature and made himself the emperor. Second, many people at that time confused the Western “rule of law” argument with the Chinese Legalist School that had origins during the Spring and Autumn period (770–476 BC), focusing on penalties.
Chapter 5 deals with the issue of the relations between the public, the private, and the political. According to Jenco's interpretation, Zhang believed that the public and private cannot be separated. The political “consists not in bridging the gaps between oneself and others for the purposes of concerted action, but in overcoming the disparity between the world one envisions internally and the reality one faces externally” (18). Zhang believed in the decisive role of the mental and moral orientations in transforming society. Founding “does not require wisdom so much as motivation; it does not require an already existing community so much as self-awareness, the creative application of one's talents and abilities, and a willingness to live together, somehow” (133).
The third part of the book, “Action,” like the second has three chapters. Chapter 6, “Self-Awareness,” deals with Zhang's argument that self-awareness was not simply a private matter, because it can constitute the foundation for wider sociopolitical change. Zhang was against Liang Qichao, who viewed the education of the masses as the key to founding a feasible polity, Sun Yet-sen, who relied on the party leadership for the same purpose, and Yuan Shikai, who advocated benevolent dictatorship. Zhang instead advocated self-cultivation. Acquiring self-awareness is, to Zhang, a process that fosters democratic practices and subjectivities spontaneously, without recourse to top-down control (141).
In chapter 7, Jenco outlines Zhang's idea of “the self-use of talent.” In dynastic periods, talent was narrowly defined as writing skills and understanding ethics and was used by the state. Zhang not only broadened the scope of talent to include scientific and technological knowledge but also believed that talent was for self-use. According to Jenco, Zhang believed that this use of each individual's talent is essential politically for the founding of the democratic regime. This differs from the overemphasis on morality during the dynasties. “Moral goodness does not always result in political efficacy, Zhang realizes, and being ‘selfless’ in the way many contemporary political leaders recommended often resulted in sacrificing oneself not for the greater good but for the power plays of political elites” (26). The overemphasis on virtue, which stresses sameness to the neglect of diverse talents that vary, leads to authoritarianism (174).
In the last chapter, Jenco analyzes Zhang's ideas regarding “accommodation,” which is defined as “the peaceful, non-assimilative negotiation of differences between two or more putatively equal parties” (244). In the preceding chapter, it was shown that Zhang refuted hegemonic notions of virtue and advocated the self-use of talent, which implies a radically decentered and diffuse capacity first to build and then to participate in political institutions (192); on this basis, we learn, Zhang argued for pluralist politics.
This book is the only systematic study of Zhang Shizhao, an important and colorful intellectual-political figure in twentieth-century China. In addition, this study looks at Zhang from the perspective of political theory, not intellectual history. Therefore, it has filled a vacuum. The book is academically sophisticated and the sources, both primary and secondary, are solid. The weakness of the book comes from its strength: precisely because the author has chosen to look at Zhang from a political-theory perspective, the interactions between his ideas and the social turmoil that he went through are underexplored. The writing of the book is dense. It is not suitable for undergraduate teaching.
