This is a detailed, systematic and authoritative attempt to examine some of the key principles underpinning the eighteenth-century ballet d’action ‘in the light of contemporary developments in acting, theatre, opera, music, and the aesthetics of the arts in general’ (p. 6). Nye seeks to show how ballet d’action, a hybrid art, aspired to being an art form sui generis, a dance drama achievable through a sophisticated exploitation of the expressive skills of look, gesture and movement in alliance with music.
The book is organized in two parts, the first placing ballet d’action in historical context, the second focusing on dramatic principles. Nye is, of course, concerned with later eighteenth-century Continental, more particularly French, and also some Italian and German, activities, but he also touches on the English scene, remarking the importance of John Weaver's work, that of Marie Salle at Covent Garden, and the great Continental respect shown for, and the influence exercised by, David Garrick's emphasis on physical expressiveness. This first part examines the emergence of ballet d’action in a century governed by an interest in the oral and linguistic, and a theatre dominated by the ‘primacy of the voice’ (p. 37). It further explores this body-based art form in relation to other modes of somatic theatre to which it has often been likened, such as Roman pantomime and commedia dell’arte, and concludes that neither association is persuasive, for practitioners and choreographers of ballet d’action were essentially concerned with the serious treatment of sentiment and character and the task of taking ‘body language beyond comedy altogether’ (p. 69).
Nye is particularly persuasive here in the skill with which he distinguishes ballet d’action from commedia dell’arte. He examines its correspondence with traditional commedia, the Franco-Italian farce of the Paris ‘fairs’, and the reformed Italian theatre of Luigi Riccoboni and others, and acknowledges that the ‘somatic first principles’ of these were ‘related to those of the ballet d’action’ (p. 76), but draws clear distinctions between them. This first part concludes with a chapter remarking on the similarities and differences of technique and principle between the possible ‘distant cousins’ Jean-Georges Noverre and the modern mime artist Etienne Decroux (p. 84), a rather startling but intriguing association that serves to underscore the central importance of mime in ballet d’action.
Part Two begins by focusing on character in action, addressing how contemporary critics recognized ‘fundamental problems with the principle of expressing character in dance’ (p. 139), the possibilities and problems of handling dialogue in mime – for choreographers ‘one of their greatest challenges’ (p. 160) – along with detailed examination of Gasparo Angiolini's programme preface and 1765 work Semiramide, and Noverre's programme for the premiere of Agamemnon Vengé (1772). Chapters then treat the painterly dimension of choreography sought by Noverre and the fusion of music and dramatic action (written jointly with Ruth Eldredge), and, finally, give an examination of performance programmes.
A short review cannot do justice to the high quality of this book. It is manifestly the outcome of wide, thorough and systematic library research in several countries and of deep thought about the nature of ballet d’action in its cultural contexts and in so far as an understanding of it can be gathered from many overlooked or little-considered extant materials, including the musical: ‘we will probably never know exactly what mime dancers did on stage’ (p. 139). There are abundant informative footnotes, appendices of French and Italian texts and the music of a ‘Ballet Pantomime’, and the select bibliography ranges through primary and secondary literature, stage works, periodicals, manuscripts and reference works. Nye has produced an original, intellectually demanding and tightly written study that both opens up new ground and points to opportunities for further research.
