In his book, McGee Young examines the development of four interest groups in the United States during the twentieth century. He uses some of the tools of the American political development approach, a perspective that is probably insufficiently appreciated by interest group scholars, to emphasize the manner in which interest groups develop identities. Many studies tend to take the interest group landscape as a given, without considering how the landscape came to be. Young argues persuasively that an interest group's basic features, such as its strategic posture toward the government, its relationships with other advocates, its portfolio of key issues, and its approach to engaging citizens in collective action, constrain the group's ability to influence public policy. Furthermore, an interest group's identity is not created in a vacuum and does not turn on a dime, but evolves over time in response to the political context and the entrepreneurial inclinations of interest group leaders.
The main body of Developing Interests is organized into two sections. The first section examines the origins and development of two national groups that advocate for the interests of small businesses, the National Small Business Association (NSBA) and the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB). The second section provides a similar historical analysis of two environmental groups, the Sierra Club and the National Resources Defense Council (NRDC). Young chronicles each group's origins and subsequent efforts to adapt to changing political conditions.
Some of the theoretical architecture of the book will look familiar to interest group scholars. For example, Young argues that organizational entrepreneurs are critical to the formation and survival of interest groups. However, he also argues that interest group leaders are motivated in part by exclusive benefits they receive from their organizational efforts. For example, early leaders of the NSBA benefited financially from the efforts of their organizations (p. 40). Similarly, the growing prominence of the Sierra Club made political celebrities out of John Muir and David Brower at different points in the group's history. Young also notes that supportive relationships with government officials are important to an interest group's development and policy success. More importantly, he argues that there is a path-dependent quality to the development of interest groups. Organizational maintenance mechanisms or advocacy methods developed by interest group founders may persist well after the founders are gone and the conditions that gave rise to those processes have ceased to exist. For example, NFIB leaders instituted a poll of their members in the group's newsletter as a way to differentiate itself from rival groups, to cultivate a sense of involvement among members, and to ensure that NFIB lobbyists correctly advocated for the positions of its members. More than 60 years later, the NFIB still polls its members, even though it is now comfortably established as the largest advocacy group for small businesses in the United States (p. 167).
The book's most important argument is that the path-dependent nature of interest group development affects a group's ability to influence public policy. Organizations that develop a particular identity may be ineffective at serving the interests of their members when changing political conditions create tension with the group's identity. For instance, Young documents how neither the NSBA nor the NFIB was able to capitalize on the creation of the Small Business Administration (SBA) in the 1950s (Chapter 3). The NSBA, whose identity was defined by a free-market ideology, was philosophically opposed to the creation of the agency. The NFIB's focus on antitrust issues did not mesh with the SBA's legislative mission to provide loans to small businesses. As a result, Young argues, the SBA served more of a patronage function for members of Congress than as a client for the nation's largest small business interest groups.
The main evidence for the book comes from the internal archives of the four groups that Young profiles. It is clear that he spent a considerable amount of time and effort scrutinizing this historical evidence. He uses the archival evidence most effectively in the case studies of the NSBA and NFIB, documenting the rivalry between the two groups and the internal tensions as they came to grips with the SBA. In addition, there is a compelling account of how the two small business groups came to swap political and ideological postures over time. The NSBA was organized around a conservative philosophy in opposition to the New Deal and “socialized medicine” (p. 46) and thus did not cultivate much of a relationship with the Democratic majority in Congress. In contrast, the NFIB developed early ties with Democratic leaders in Congress who shared the group's position on antitrust issues. After the death of NSBA founder DeWitt Emery in 1955, the group moved toward a more moderate political position and helped its members make use of SBA services. The NFIB subsequently adopted the antigovernment mantle, developing close ties with the Republican Party and growing into a powerhouse lobbying organization during the backlash against government regulation in the 1980s and 1990s. Readers who observed the key role of Senator Max Baucus (D-MT) in the passage of health-care legislation in 2010 can also flash back to Baucus's role in dooming President Bill Clinton's health-care legislation in 1994 after being targeted by the NFIB (p. 81).
No book can do everything, and one shortcoming of an investigation based largely on the internal archives of interest groups is that we get a less complete picture of other political actors, particularly other advocates for small business and the environment inside and outside of government. For example, it would have helped to include more information about other groups that were competing to represent small businesses during the New Deal. How is it that the NFIB and NSBA survived? What did they do that other aspiring small business groups failed to do? These questions are important for understanding the development of both groups and could have received a bit more attention. In addition, with the author focusing so heavily on the development of an interest group, it can be difficult for the reader to determine how responsible each group is for its political and policy successes and failures compared to other factors. Young argues that the NFIB was the interest group most responsible for the Republican Party winning majority control of Congress in 1994 (p. 83), but there is no assessment of the role of other groups aligned with the GOP. What organized opposition did these groups face? How strong was the opposition? What organizational allies collaborated with them? The book gives some consideration to these questions but could have done so more systematically.
This does not detract from Young's main point, which is that the manner in which an interest group develops an identity can limit or strengthen the group's ability to advocate on behalf of its members when political conditions change. He makes a convincing case that the development of an identity had a lasting impact on the organizations profiled here. As a result, this book should encourage interest group scholars to give more consideration to the organizational history of the interest groups we study.
