To write a book on the European Union is in general a professional hazard these days. The state of the “Union” is such that, from year to year, and from month to month, its apparent condition and future perspectives may vary considerably. What is said or written one day may quickly look either dated or, with hindsight, hopelessly inaccurate.
On the face of it, John McCormick's Europeanism suffers from this very problem. Published in 2010, it came out in time to witness the financial crisis of 2008, the way in which this affected the EU, and the reactions of its institutions to it. But it was too early to take into account the more recent sovereign debt crisis and that of the euro, or, for that matter, the antideficit policies willy-nilly embraced by the EU and most of its governments. In light of these developments, McCormick's wholesome assessment of the EU's reaction to the financial crisis (pp. 122–25) sounds dangerously like wishful thinking. Moreover, in general, his characterization of the “skeptical” and the “optimist” positions at the start of the book (pp. 1–2) does not seem as well balanced as he would wish them to appear, with the burden of proof tilting decisively on the optimist's side. Nowadays, the book's clearly optimistic view may face an increasingly skeptical reader.
Such a skeptical attitude, however, may not be entirely fair: first, because the book is not about the EU but about “Europe,” and secondly, because it is more about European society than EU institutions. Its main thesis is that “Europeanism” both infuses and explains the EU project, while going well beyond the latter's political and institutional reality. By Europeanism, McCormick means the complex of values, attitudes, and self-perceptions characterizing European societies and, broadly speaking, its political systems (in the plural) and political culture (in the singular). The EU and, more specifically, the European integration process are the institutional manifestations of the way in which European societies have developed in the last 70 years as a reaction to the previous four decades of intense warfare on the continent. Europeanism is therefore a way in which one can capture the experience of these last 70 years, during which European societies and their leaders refocused their attention and efforts on the ways to guarantee peace and prosperity in this region of the world by promoting cooperation among nations and progressively overcoming the nation-state paradigm in politics and the economy. At the basis of such an effort was an already-established patrimony of ideas and values that European societies have shared for a number of centuries, in spite of their sociopolitical differences and national divisions, exacerbated by the nineteenth-century growth of aggressive nationalism, and culminating in two dramatic world conflicts.
McCormick develops his argument on the nature and role of Europeanism in eight chapters, each of which illustrates an aspect of the European experience. The first two are more historical, concerning the idea of Europe and how the European integration process redefined it, making the EU and Europe synonymous in some important way. The other chapters are about the dominant paradigms on this redefined continent. At the institutional level, there has been a shift from the national to a more cosmopolitan-oriented conception of the interconnection among states (Chap. 3). At the political level, there is a dominant communitarian conception of the social union, and an institutional preference for the parliamentary model (Chap. 4). At the economic level, there is a prevalent solidaristic and welfarist conception of redistribution, together with greater emphasis on the civilian-industrialist, rather than the military-industrialist, complex (Chap. 5). At the social level, the combined changing patterns in population growth, family, and work life are at the basis of a growing emphasis on the quality of life and on postmaterial values (Chap. 6). And, finally, at the normative level, Europe is characterized by long-standing multicultural attitudes, strong secularism, and a rejection of excessively harsh ideas of punishment, particularly capital punishment (Chap. 7). Each of the chapters develops a synoptic argument about the relevant topic from a comparativist perspective, taking US society as the natural counterpoint for the analysis of Europeanism, and basing its assessment on a combination of wide-ranging historical reconstructions of cultural and ideological trends, with a piecemeal collection of survey data on people's attitudes, opinions, and declared values.
Overall, the result of this analysis is disappointing. In a programmatic book like this one, advancing an ambitious reconstruction of long-term trends, whose evidence is both second hand and impressionistic rather than based on original and extensive data, it is only understandable that the single parts are little more than brief (occasionally rather superficial) overviews of complex topics and material. In such a case, one would hope for the whole to be more than its parts. The book's worth depends mostly on the plausibility of its central concept and on how convincing McCormick's analysis of this concept is. But what is “Europeanism”? The author distinguishes it from both “Europeanness” and “European identity” (pp. 8–9). The latter is a disputed idea in the current literature, though in the context of this book, it should be understood as the process of (mainly social) identification, as distinguished from specific political loyalty. For the author, such identification is to be measured in the sense of belonging and association that individuals feel with a collectivity. Although many of the pieces of evidence that McCormick cites in his analysis are based on how people feel about Europe, for him Europeanism is the object of such feelings, rather than the feeling itself. As for Europeanness, the author does not consider it as an intrinsic quality that distinguishes a group, but as the relative indication of whether someone has acquired or come to share the attitudes and values that characterize Europeanism.
Europeanism is, therefore, both objective and absolute. And yet, as it emerges from McCormick's analysis, Europeanism is the concretization of an intersubjective experience, open both to interpretation and, arguably, change over time, since the Europeanism of which he wishes to talk is the one that has emerged from the postwar experience. (Was there a different Europeanism beforehand? Or was there no Europeanism at all?) Unfortunately, throughout the book, Europeanism remains a rather elusive concept. At times it resembles a projective ideology (as when it is used in association with cosmopolitanism); at other times it takes the place of a national character (in substitution for Frenchness or Englishness); and yet at others, is used as shorthand for a reconstructed set of values and attitudes (as when used as a counterpoint to Americanism, which is often taken, in substance though not in name, as the negative counterpart of Europeanism). In short, by the end of the book we are never fully clear what Europeanism is and how to either assess or evaluate it, if not by taking for granted the kind of characteristics that the author assumes it to have (pp. 217–21).
The other book under review, on the Political Theory of the European Union, needs to solve the reverse problem. This book is a collection of theoretical reflections on the EU from different disciplinary and theoretical perspectives. Its value is mostly determined by the value of its parts, which turn out to be interesting and well-crafted essays, offering challenging views on how we should think about the European Union from either a positive or a normative theoretical perspective. There is no space, in a short review like this, to engage with the single contributions. Most of them are worth reading, and even if there is the danger (as for Europeanism) that the main object of their analysis—the EU—may change in ways that unhinge the fundamental presuppositions on which the analysis is based, the theoretical reflections offered in the book may apply beyond the specific experience of the EU itself. Indeed, one may take this as the underlying question of the book as a whole.
The Political Theory of the European Union may be something of a misnomer in the circumstances, since this collection, as with most of the theoretical reflections on the EU, is interested in theorizing the European polity and its political system both as a singular instance and as the representative of a more general species. The EU has come to represent the paradigmatic instance of a regional and postnational form of political organization. Whereas McCormick's book tries to find the root of this experience in European exceptionalism, the collection edited by Jürgen Neyer and Antje Wiener explores the possibility of theoretical discourse and whether it can help define the generalizable characters of the European experience, as well as in what sense, if any, this is a political paradigm for things to come.
The organization of the book is significant in this respect. The first part nominally addresses the question of “political authority and world order,” which, I think, should be rephrased as the question of the legitimate space within which political authority operates. In other words, is politics as we know it—determined, as it has been for the last two or three hundred years, by the nation-state framework—still feasible and authoritative? The second part, on the questions of sovereignty and constitutionalism, shifts the discussion from politics as the fundamental activity of collective self-determination to the way in which this has been conjugated with law—another and, for some, even more fundamental way in which the community organizes itself. The third and final part engages with democracy. In particular, it questions whether the principles of equality and autonomy that characterize democracy itself can be conceived and justified without reference to a well-defined agent, traditionally identified in the demos. The alternative is for these principles either to operate in the interactive environment of multiple demoi or to find their justification in more procedural, less agent-based, frameworks.
In short, the book as a whole offers an agenda for the political theory of the EU by posing the well-known though still-pressing questions of whether politics in the contemporary world order can remain national, constitutional, and democratic, or whether and how we need to redefine these categories. Does Europe indicate the way? If this is the case, does it have to do with the more general developments in and of contemporary politics, to which the EU experience is a possible answer, as most of the chapters in this collection indicate? Or is it something more intrinsic to the European experience, as McCormick's book suggests? These are a few of the important questions the books encourage us to consider.
