This readable translation of the third volume of Herman Bavinck's Reformed Dogmatics provides not only his doctrine of sin but also the ‘central point of the whole system of dogmatics’: his christology. John Bolt has split the three chapters of the Dutch original into four: ‘The Fallen World’, ‘Christ the Redeemer’, ‘The Work of Christ’ and ‘Salvation in Christ’. The extra part results from the division of the original's second chapter – ‘On the Person and the Work of Christ’. He has kept the same sub-paragraph numbering, enabling cross-reference between the original and translation.
Bavinck (1854–1921) wrote for the newly formed Gereformeerde Kerken in Nederland (Reformed Churches in the Netherlands). The sides of this united church, though sharing a commitment to conservative Calvinism, had different styles of piety. Bavinck mediated by shying away from speculative constructions like a ‘justification from eternity’ and reminding readers of the limits of biblical revelation. His Dogmatics was balanced, irenic and reconciling – the theological textbook par excellence for the Neo-Calvinist movement.
The Reformed Dogmatics displays a characteristic Neo-Calvinist eagerness to interact with culture. An opponent of the evolutionary world-view, Bavinck nevertheless welcomed the advent of the science of heredity to the extent that it dispelled rationalistic prejudice against inherited sin. He noted points of contact between the concept of punishment for sin and the discipline of criminology, but warned that by blurring the ‘boundaries between crime and disease’ the state might classify socially disruptive forces – even recalcitrant Calvinists – as social ills to be cured. After his move from the Theological School of Kampen to the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Bavinck's interests broadened; he added discussions, for example, of William James and the new discipline of religious psychology.
Bavinck rooted his doctrines in the Bible but also considered common experience and the history of doctrine. He drew on an astonishing range of sources, moving with intellectual ease from church fathers (especially Augustine), medieval scholastics (he included a valuable disquisition on the development of Western atonement theory), Counter-Reformation Roman Catholics, Lutheran scholastics and the Socinians to moderns like Schleiermacher and Ritschl, as well as philosophers such as Spizona, Kant, Hegel and von Hartmann. The notes bristle with his erudition. However, his primary points of reference are Calvin and the Reformed scholastics; he is at his best when exploring controversies such as the seventeenth-century dispute among Reformed theologians about the proper relation between the covenant of works and the covenant of grace.
As might be expected with a theology textbook written around the turn of the previous century, Bavinck occasionally defended antiquated scientific positions. But he was also prescient, recognising, like Barth a generation later, that to meet Feuerbach's critique theologians must begin with God, not humanity.
The Reformed Dogmatics remains contemporary not only because it offers one of the most lucid expositions of the doctrines of sin and grace, but also because it provides a model for engaging modernity with the Christian mind.
