Understanding the dominant norm in twenty-first-century international air transport policy—liberalization—requires legal, economic, and political analysis. With the exception of multilateral economic regulations of the WTO (World Trade Organization) and the ICAO (International Civil Aviation Organization), international air transport was at one time mainly governed by protectively written bilateral air services agreements. Over the past few decades, however, liberalization has become an unassailable doctrine in aviation. Indeed, liberalization has spread over most of the world, with some variations in style and substance. And yet, while states generally agree that air transport liberalization will be beneficial to all states and users in the long term, there are stark differences between individual states in terms of speed, scope, and method.
This book employs a multidisciplinary approach to answer the questions the authors promise to address: “What are the forces that have given rise to regulatory reform?” “What is the structure of the regulatory change that has occurred to date and what is likely to occur in the immediate future?” and “What have the effects been on industry efficiency, prices, and profits, of the reforms that have occurred to date?” (p. 1). In the book's twenty-four chapters, the thirty-seven contributors assemble largely economic research (with substantial legal and political components) to paint a comprehensive picture of air transport liberalization. These chapters are divided into five sections.
Part A (Liberalization and Airline Competition) and Part B (Liberalization and Low-Cost Airline Competition) mainly discuss how liberalization has affected competition. Recognizing competition as the primary justification for liberalization, contributors analyze the diverse opportunities and outcomes that result from liberalization. Nearly all contributors agree that the most significant development in the post-liberalization period is the emergence and growth of low-cost carriers (LCCs), which can be divided into the “truly low-cost” model and the “full-service airline competitor” model (p. 154). Rather than revisiting the proven ways in which liberalization benefits competition, it is more compelling to read about the failure of a national carrier so as to understand the relationship between liberalization and competition. In Chapter 6 (How Liberalization Can Go Wrong: The Case of Alitalia), Beria, Niemeier, and Fröhlich convincingly argue that “never-ending political protection” (p. 124) by the Italian government weakened Alitalia's competiveness in a liberalized market.
Part C (Liberalization and Airline Cooperation) is the most interesting section by far. Contributors discuss cross-border airline mergers and acquisitions, the relationship between open skies agreements and antitrust law, and antitrust immunity for airline alliances, all of which are controversial and hotly debated topics among scholars and officials in national and regional competition. Questions the contributors pose, such as whether “easing actual or potential entry, as through an ‘open skies’ treaty, [is] a good substitute for actual competition ‘in the air’ between incumbent operators” (p. 221) and “whether granting antitrust immunity is necessary to realize the key benefits for consumers, or whether lower degrees of cooperation can reach comparable benefit levels” (p. 250), are more than worth the attention of policy-makers. In their observation that “‘openness’ is not sufficient to safeguard competition” (p. 230), contributors suggest that air transport liberalization should ensure close interactive application of competition law.
Part D (Liberalization and Infrastructure) reminds readers that the liberalization of air transport has led to far-reaching changes in closely linked sectors: namely airports, ground handling services, and air navigation service providers. The editors introduce Part D by saying that “access to infrastructure is a key precondition for workable competition in airline markets” (p. 6). In the context of Asia, all three chapters in Part D sound the alarm for India. It is no secret that poor infrastructure is acting as a powerful deterrent to realizing the potential of the Indian aviation sector.
The final section, Part E (Liberalization and Public Policy), analyzes the steps taken towards liberalization in different markets thus far, and forecasts the course of liberalization in the future. Chapter 19 (Economic Impact of Aviation Liberalization) provides a clear-cut justification for liberalization, arguing that it “could bring about significant increase in traffic, substantial fare reductions, and economic and employment gains” (p. 368). In contrast with what its name (European Liberalization: A View From Afar) might suggest, Chapter 20 provides a wide-ranging discussion, tracing the development of Australia's aviation relationship with Europe and discussing ASEAN and New Zealand aviation agreements and operations in Europe. Since the contributor does not explain the obstacles facing ASEAN, it is rather surprising to see him remark correctly that “ASEAN is ill-equipped as a body to negotiate either a horizontal agreement or an agreement to establish a common aviation area with EU” (p. 390).
One possible criticism of the book is that it is dominantly Eurocentric, despite its claim to provide “insights on a broad range of topics related to aviation liberalization in various parts of the world” (p. 1). Given that substantial liberalization is taking place in Asia—and particularly in Southeast Asia, where more than fifty percent of traffic is operated by LCCs—the fact that not a single chapter (out of the twenty-four in total) focuses on Asia is a clear defect. This shortcoming, however, is inherently linked to the mixed picture in Asia (p. 8). While Asia has shown noticeable liberalization over the past decade (including the rapid growth of LCCs throughout the region, a dramatic shift in Japanese aviation policy in 2007, and the 2010 ASEAN Multilateral Agreement on Full Liberalization of Passenger Air Services), three of Asia's largest countries—China, India, and Indonesia—adhere to their protectionist stance, rejecting the proven benefits of liberalization. The national carrier-centric approach of these countries should be reassessed in the light of the well-explained thesis of this book.
