Agile Actors on Complex Terrains is the first publication in the ‘Complexity in Social Science’ series, aimed at promoting interdisciplinary explorations of the relevance of complex systems approaches to the social world. It is, in many ways, a companion volume to Room's earlier book Complexity, Institutions and Public Policy: Agile Decision-making in a Turbulent World, published in 2011. In policy worlds which are multiple, fragile and uncertain, Room shows the need to address complex inter-relations between social structure and social action and, in particular, to address the contingencies of differentially agile social actors struggling for positional advantage.
At the very end of this book, Room concedes that the discussion “may at times have been somewhat demanding, for reader as much as for writer” (p. 193). Whilst this certainly was the case for this reader, it perhaps need not have been so. It is only on completing the book that one realises that, in a way, it was written backwards. Two of the three chapters on public policy which appear in Part Three of the book, respectively on ‘evidence-based policy’ and on ‘policy nudging’, are revised versions of texts which have already been published. Together with a rather disappointing chapter on inequalities, these three chapters form the understated ‘core’ of the book, showing the kind of contemporary policy puzzles which Room believes insights from complexity theory can shed light on, conceptually, empirically and in terms of alternative policy agendas and processes. Much of Parts One and Two of the book, often rather obtusely, seek to orient the reader to social scientific approaches which yield a vast array of concepts, marshalling a vast array of social, political and economic theorists, buttressing the claim that complexity theory, insofar that it addresses institutional arrangements and the political economy of power dynamics, is an important framework for understanding public policy.
The balance of the book is, perhaps, too focused on complicating complexity theory, spending considerable effort in understanding its roots in the natural and informational sciences, without warning sufficiently of the dangers of socio-biological approaches, underpinned as they are by evolutionary understandings of ‘the survival of the fittest’. At times, the ‘targets’ of rational choice approaches, random controlled trials, and the like, combined with very dated empirical examples of alternative understandings of policy (Shelling's 1978 study of racialized residential segregations in the United States reappears throughout the book, for example), appear to be nothing new, at least to any reader versed in critical policy studies. At other times, Room seems to admire the “technical sophistication” (p. 191) of the old orthodoxies of policy studies a little too much, suggesting that complexity theory can compete with them in terms of “skilful computational modelling of non-linear dynamics” (ibid.) Despite the constant plea to take institutional and power dynamics seriously, this is rather less central, and rather less well developed overall, than it might have been.
Whilst marshalling, in the text and in footnotes, vast canons of social scientific work, the neglect of Marxist, post-structuralist, discursive and interpretive approaches to policy analysis is particularly telling. These offer equally, if not more, plausible perspectives on the non-linear nature of the social world than the rather jumbled idea of complexity theory presented here. Despite Room's invocation of the importance of “‘thick’ qualitative accounts of positional struggle” (p. 191), almost nothing of an emerging ‘anthropology of policy’ is referred to in the book. In the end, a plea for public policies which are “wise and reasonable” (p. 189) involving wider citizen participation, appears far from original, and insufficiently radical, to meet the challenges of ‘wicked’ problems in ever more complex policy landscapes. Room's invocation of a ‘new social contract’ (p. 156) reads like a hybrid of ‘social investment’, ‘decent work’ and ‘community participation’, with far too little focus on how this might differ from solutions in “traditional welfare systems” (p. 156) and with virtually no exploration of policy problems in the context of emergent, ‘wicked’, ecological challenges.
The book may be useful for those who have begun to think about the application of complexity theory to public policy and are searching for more sophisticated approaches. The focus on ‘transformative realism’ in the first part of the book, and on agile actors in Part Two, whilst dense and challenging, do offer a range of ideas and models which could be applied in meaningful and fruitful ways. Chapter Three (‘contingent development and explanation’), also published earlier, provides a detailed outline of what a ‘contingent historical model’ might look like, as a way of understanding choice architectures in complex ecosystems in which “specific outcomes are difficult to predict” (p. 59). The utility of the model for understanding ‘institutional innovations’, ‘feedback loops’, and ‘mutual adaptations’ is, however, limited by the abstract nature of the model as presented. Students of public policy may find the discussion of contemporary themes in public policy useful and, at the very least, policy makers who manage to read the book in its entirety may come away with greater distrust of policy panaceas in complex contexts. In the end, one cannot help thinking that, differently organised, the book could have been both more readable and more influential than it is likely to be.
