Dr Locher heads the foreign department of the Federation of Swiss Protestant Churches and is currently President of the European Area of the World Alliance of Reformed Churches. In this study, dedicated to the memory of Colin Gunton, he seeks to diagnose and suggest a cure for a major ecclesiological deficit in the theology of the Protestant, especially the Reformed, churches. The publisher's recommendation aptly sums up the aim and pattern of the volume:
This study aims at taking up the discussion of the visibility of the true Church in the form of a direct dialogue with sixteenth-century Reformers. It seeks to portray early Protestant versions of the Church in its visible and invisible dimensions in the context of their respective ecclesiological settings, to assess these concepts on the basis of ecclesiological realities at the beginning of the third millennium and to propose a re-definition of such a ‘Church in Duality’ for our time based on and developed in the form of Protestant ecclesiology.
The ‘duality’ here in mind is that between the visible and the invisible church. Locher accordingly sets out, in the first part of his work, early Protestant versions of the ‘Church in Duality’ as found in Luther, Zwingli, Calvin, Melanchthon and early Reformed Confessions; with the exception of the later Melanchthon, he finds here a recurrent tendency to ascribe the attributes of the true Church to the ecclesia invisibilis, with a consequent disinclination to be overly concerned with the shape of the ecclesia visibilis. This first part is a useful comparative analysis of the sources. Part 2, ‘Assessment of the Church in Duality’, covers the same ground, but now more analytically than synthetically, exploring such themes as ‘The Church – Essential or Visible’; ‘The Body (or Bodies?) of the Church’ and ‘Attributa ecclesiae: Attributes of the Two-Dimensional Church’. Part 3 attempts to ‘re-define the duality of the Church’ under the circumstances of the present time, beginning with ‘the Essentially Visible Church’ and going on to discuss the church's essence, attributes and mission.
The aim is ambitious and indeed worthy, for the truth of the matter is probably that most Protestant theology and most Protestant churches have not the slightest notion of or interest in the ecclesia catholica and leave that ground unreflectingly to Professor Josef Ratzinger, a.k.a. Benedict XVI (except when his clear-cut statements provoke their protest). In that regard this study is a useful and thought-provoking challenge. On the downside, it has a somewhat limited historical and theological base and is distinctly repetitive in the development of its main argument. The critique of dualistic thinking (distant echoes here of T. F. Torrance?) is doubtless justified but remains something of a one-stringed symphony, making no attempt, for example, to offer a deeper critical analysis of the predestinarian ecclesiology developed in Calvinism. In addition, for all the study's concern to be practically relevant, it contains only sketchy references to what the churches of today actually look like. The book also contains interesting examples of the kind of typesetting that the computer age has made possible and prevalent – e.g. on p. 185, where the word ‘two’, for reasons that are not further explained, is printed תו! In general too (תו?), while Gottfried Locher's English is mostly very fluent, it might have been advisable to have the manuscript copy-edited by a native English speaker before publication. That said, however, he has put his finger upon a genuine deficit in much Protestant ecclesiology and to that extent his argument deserves serious consideration.
