In this well-crafted study, Chad Pearson places anti-unionism at the center of Progressive Era America. Employers’ creation of new powerful organizations to put trade unions out of business was consistent with the organizational impetus of the era. Likewise, Pearson argues, employers coopted reform impulses by casting their largely-successful campaign to smash strikes and break unions as a noble and just cause to free individual workers and communities from the tyranny of unregulated labor monopolies.
Anti-union employers and their supporters rallied around the principle of the “Open Shop,” or the notion that membership in a union should have no bearing on employment. Pearson reminds us time and again that open-shop employers really did believe that they were on the side of progressive reform and the common good. They truly saw and presented themselves not as union busters or reactionaries, but rather as protectors of independent workers who longed to remain free from union dictation. The real effect of the open shop, however, was to provide rhetorical cover for the base economic interests of employers. With it, employers were able to mobilize a host of allies in a vigorous moral crusade against unions and to mask the repressive methods (such as strikebreaking and the blacklisting of labor activists) by which they created union-free workplaces. The open shop was a powerful ideological battering ram, useful in preventing “workers from participating in their own confrontational, class-based associations” (3). By the time the United States entered the First World War, employers had “largely succeeded in weakening their working-class opponents while legitimizing an economic system that empowered and enriched the few at the expense of the many” (224).
The opening chapters of Reform or Repression examine the open-shop drive as a national mass movement of anti-union employers and their allies. Chapter One shows employers circa 1900 making the strategic decision to create, sustain, staff, and pay for permanent organizations to confront entrenched unions. Pearson then deploys the defense-to-belligerency thesis long associated with Clarence E. Bonnett, the economist at Tulane University who systematically studied employers’ associations starting in the early 1920s. Banding together defensively in the National Association of Manufacturers, the National Founders’ Association, the National Metal Trades Association, and other bodies, that employers initially favored bargaining with national unions affiliated with the American Federation of Labor, but citing deceit and irresponsibility on the part of union leaders they soon opted to fight for the open shop.
Employers did not go it alone. Chapter Two focuses on the mobilization of the broad middle class in support of the open shop. According to Pearson, some of the era's most noted reformers played a notorious role in legitimizing the open shop. A key moment was President Theodore Roosevelt's political intervention in the anthracite coal strike of 1902. His advocacy of the “Square Deal” as the basis for a settlement between the union and the mine operators entailed the open-shop principle as the foundation of labor peace. Roosevelt's embrace of it emboldened anti-unionists and gave employers “decades of powerful ammunition in their battle against the union shop” (61). Other influential progressive minds coalesced around the open shop, including Ray Stannard Baker of McClure's magazine, Charles Eliot of Harvard (who called strikebreakers American heroes), Woodrow Wilson of Princeton, George Creel (a member of the press committee of the Citizens Industrial Association of America), and most significantly Louis Brandeis, who according to Pearson used his outstanding progressive credentials to give moral cover to anti-union employers.
The battle over the open shop was fought in hundreds of towns and cities across the nation, and Pearson devotes Chapters Three through Six to several local case studies. At the center of the story in Cleveland, Ohio, is John A. Penton, a former leader in the machinery molders’ union who moved to the side of employers, and attorney Jay P. Dawley. These two brothers-in-arms joined forces in 1900 to defeat an iron molders’ strike, with Penton handling the recruitment of strikebreakers and Dawley securing labor injunctions. Later, as a result of a garment workers’ strike in 1910, Dawley broke ranks and became an attorney for the garment workers’ union. Dawley was a rare exception, for virtually no advocate of the open shop was willing to see what it actually meant in practice for working people. The open shop also triumphed in Buffalo, New York, where employers offered it as the only way to redeem the city following the assassination of President McKinley there in 1901. In Worcester, Massachusetts, employers broke a machinists’ strike in 1902 and then went on to construct what they boasted was a realm of permanent industrial prosperity and labor peace under the aegis of the open shop. The 1915 metal workers’ strike in Worcester showed that the reality of labor conditions did not match the rhetoric of employers, but it did nothing to cause them to question open-shop fundamentals or recognize unions.
The final case study focuses on N. F. Thompson and his role in offering the New South as a lasting solution to the labor problem in the United States. Pearson traces Thompson back to his slave-holding father's plantation in middle Tennessee, his enlistment in the Confederate forces during the Civil War, and his leading role in the post-war Ku Klux Klan. Decades later, Thompson would transfer the same alleged nobility and heroism of the Klan in fighting the forces behind Reconstruction to the struggle against trade unionism. A key late nineteenth-century figure in promoting industrial development in places like Birmingham and Huntsville, Alabama, Thompson enlisted in the national open-shop movement and became its most visible champion in the South. Thompson, however, was always much more concerned with promoting the interests of Southern elites than with aiding employers outside his native region. Considering the North hopelessly lost to unions, radicals, immigrants, and labor violence, Thompson urged its manufacturers to relocate to the South where they could enjoy what he advertised as an obedient and nonunion labor force and experience harmonious class and race relations.
A great appeal of this study is the numerous biographical profiles of open-shop movers and shakers. But we never quite get a sense of the broader sociology of employers, other than that they were white males and mainly Republicans and Protestants. Pearson argues that they were more taken by free labor ideology than the trendy Social Darwinism of the era. Curiously, with the partial exception of N. F. Thompson, there is no specific attention to the role of religion in shaping the anti-union sensibilities of employers. Nor is there any consideration of how employers’ early experiences, say, as journeymen workers in foundries and machine shops may have shaped their views about unions or the proper treatment of the workers in their employ. Pearson notes that a fair number of open-shop champions were also Civil War veterans, but again with the exception of Thompson it is not at all clear how this experience was significant to their much later fight against organized labor. Lastly, Pearson suggests that the open-shop movement enabled employer to “reestablish full control” of workplaces (39). This mischaracterizes the situation, particularly in metal-working industries where factory owners never had enjoyed “full control” over the skilled metal workers and foremen who dominated the shop floor. The open-shop movement (with its insistence, for example, that foremen were agents of the employer) dovetailed nicely with the managerial revolution, which was the first assertion of employer power on the shop floor.
With Reform or Repression, Chad Pearson has given us a valuable and indispensable guide to the key organizations and personalities involved in the first systematic anti-union movement in the history of the United States. Most importantly, by paying serious attention to employers, Pearson reminds us what power looks like, both then and now—how it was, and is, amassed, deployed, and defended.
